Train/Test with Complete • Test with Incomplete • Train/Test with Incomplete
- Epoch 3
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 25.42 | 10.17 | 44.07 | 33.90 | 47.46 | 33.90 | 36.27 | 11.62 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 38.98 | 27.12 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 32.20 | 40.00 | 7.99 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 40.68 | 25.42 | 45.76 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 32.20 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 36.61 | 7.12 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | 23.73 | 28.81 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 25.42 | 32.71 | 6.87 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 44.07 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 27.12 | 39.15 | 6.13 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 30.51 | 25.42 | 47.46 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 50.85 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 25.42 | 36.27 | 8.34 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 56.10 | 3.26 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 58.81 | 3.48 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 44.07 | 23.73 | 27.12 | 28.81 | 22.03 | 10.17 | 16.95 | 23.73 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 26.95 | 9.51 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 13.56 | 30.51 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 10.17 | 6.78 | 13.56 | 35.59 | 22.03 | 20.85 | 10.69 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 10.17 | 18.64 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 22.03 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 23.73 | 27.12 | 23.73 | 24.75 | 6.35 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 10.17 | 22.03 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 22.03 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 18.64 | 28.81 | 23.73 | 24.58 | 6.35 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | 10.17 | 20.34 | 28.81 | 28.81 | 22.03 | 32.20 | 25.42 | 22.03 | 30.51 | 22.03 | 24.24 | 6.11 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 10.17 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 25.42 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 25.93 | 6.39 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 10.17 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 24.75 | 6.57 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 44.07 | 22.03 | 37.29 | 52.54 | 33.90 | 15.25 | 38.98 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 32.20 | 38.31 | 12.44 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 42.37 | 27.12 | 47.46 | 30.51 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 33.90 | 42.37 | 42.20 | 8.46 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 23.73 | 44.07 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 50.85 | 22.03 | 22.03 | 29.49 | 10.03 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 20.34 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 23.90 | 5.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 25.42 | 32.20 | 23.73 | 27.12 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 23.73 | 4.79 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 20.34 | 23.73 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 23.73 | 21.69 | 4.34 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 18.64 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 16.95 | 25.76 | 5.40 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 27.12 | 22.03 | 22.03 | 24.75 | 5.48 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 33.90 | 59.66 | 9.06 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 61.02 | 45.76 | 33.90 | 47.46 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 9.22 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 5.08 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 23.73 | 24.58 | 7.81 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 15.25 | 25.42 | 5.08 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 27.12 | 18.64 | 23.73 | 23.73 | 8.44 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 28.81 | 23.73 | 27.12 | 10.17 | 28.81 | 22.37 | 6.24 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 10.17 | 25.42 | 22.71 | 6.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | 27.12 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 27.12 | 8.47 | 28.81 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 10.17 | 27.12 | 21.53 | 7.31 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 20.34 | 27.12 | 10.17 | 33.90 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 13.56 | 20.34 | 22.20 | 6.88 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 27.12 | 8.47 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 27.12 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 22.20 | 6.80 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 55.93 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 54.24 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 38.31 | 10.48 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 30.51 | 16.95 | 22.03 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 18.64 | 49.15 | 27.46 | 9.34 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 68.81 | 3.14 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.69 | 2.84 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 70.34 | 2.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 70.00 | 4.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 71.69 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 70.17 | 2.96 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 3.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 72.54 | 5.81 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 70.17 | 3.88 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.03 | 2.18 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.17 | 3.95 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 2.63 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.86 | 3.57 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.36 | 2.45 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 71.86 | 4.30 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.69 | 3.64 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Branches | 67.80 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.97 | 4.94 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 60.68 | 2.92 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.75 | 3.85 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 63.39 | 3.49 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 65.93 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 49.15 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 66.61 | 6.78 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 66.95 | 4.63 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 63.90 | 5.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 79.66 | 66.95 | 5.83 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 65.59 | 4.92 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 70.00 | 3.31 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 4.35 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 83.05 | 70.00 | 5.42 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 68.64 | 4.44 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 3.13 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 68.98 | 4.49 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 79.66 | 70.34 | 4.17 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches | 61.02 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 65.93 | 5.11 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 88.14 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.27 | 2.67 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 87.12 | 3.05 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 87.97 | 2.88 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.10 | 2.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 91.53 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 86.95 | 4.16 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 85.76 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 77.97 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 85.42 | 4.17 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 87.12 | 3.32 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 87.29 | 2.96 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 87.97 | 2.20 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 2.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.78 | 2.25 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 83.05 | 67.80 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 81.36 | 69.49 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.78 | 5.47 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 77.97 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 3.64 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 83.22 | 3.34 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 66.10 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 6.02 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 59.32 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 88.14 | 78.81 | 8.42 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 86.44 | 72.71 | 6.88 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 61.69 | 2.96 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 62.71 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 88.14 | 78.64 | 7.85 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 73.22 | 6.47 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 85.42 | 2.54 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 86.95 | 3.31 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 93.22 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 87.46 | 3.32 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.20 | 3.23 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 72.37 | 2.84 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 2.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 70.17 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 73.56 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 72.37 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 2.14 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 72.20 | 4.87 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.53 | 4.41 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs4 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.15 | 2.71 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 73.73 | 3.06 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 73.39 | 3.13 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 75.59 | 3.23 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.07 | 2.74 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.03 | 3.41 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 73.22 | 3.37 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.54 | 4.47 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Branches | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 4.11 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.53 | 2.60 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 70.51 | 2.30 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 1.52 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 68.81 | 3.95 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 68.64 | 4.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.66 | 3.26 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 70.00 | 4.68 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 70.34 | 4.56 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.37 | 2.63 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 70.85 | 3.37 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 3.22 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 70.17 | 2.96 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 70.85 | 2.82 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 70.85 | 3.01 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.36 | 4.38 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 68.47 | 4.81 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 88.14 | 91.53 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 87.46 | 2.30 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 87.12 | 3.14 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 2.84 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 85.76 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 86.10 | 2.82 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.10 | 2.25 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 87.12 | 2.42 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 93.22 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 91.53 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.61 | 3.90 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 91.53 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 87.80 | 3.01 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.95 | 1.70 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 2.14 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 86.10 | 3.01 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 91.53 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 87.12 | 2.86 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 77.97 | 85.42 | 3.14 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 93.22 | 77.97 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 87.12 | 4.03 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 93.22 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 87.80 | 2.71 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 94.92 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 87.29 | 2.76 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 93.22 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 87.97 | 2.45 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 93.22 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 87.29 | 2.96 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.78 | 3.01 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.78 | 1.98 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 86.78 | 2.92 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 87.46 | 2.03 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |76.27|72.88|69.49|72.88|69.49|71.19|74.58|69.49|74.58|71.19|72.20|2.30| | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |71.19|69.49|67.80|67.80|69.49|67.80|62.71|74.58|62.71|79.66|69.32|4.82| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |62.71|69.49|72.88|69.49|66.10|69.49|55.93|71.19|62.71|72.88|67.29|5.14| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |71.19|74.58|72.88|74.58|67.80|67.80|76.27|72.88|71.19|67.80|71.69|2.94| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |62.71|67.80|66.10|64.41|59.32|71.19|69.49|66.10|69.49|69.49|66.61|3.48| | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |74.58|66.10|62.71|71.19|66.10|69.49|66.10|72.88|67.80|74.58|69.15|3.85| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |69.49|66.10|74.58|66.10|71.19|72.88|66.10|76.27|67.80|72.88|70.34|3.58| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |69.49|71.19|71.19|69.49|71.19|69.49|71.19|69.49|71.19|71.19|70.51|0.83| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |66.10|69.49|71.19|66.10|67.80|69.49|71.19|66.10|67.80|64.41|67.97|2.20| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |64.41|69.49|69.49|66.10|72.88|67.80|72.88|71.19|69.49|74.58|69.83|3.01| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |71.19|67.80|67.80|62.71|66.10|69.49|67.80|69.49|69.49|69.49|68.14|2.25| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |74.58|62.71|64.41|62.71|66.10|69.49|66.10|69.49|66.10|67.80|66.95|3.41| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |71.19|64.41|71.19|69.49|62.71|66.10|71.19|69.49|74.58|67.80|68.81|3.41| | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |72.88|67.80|64.41|67.80|71.19|72.88|71.19|74.58|69.49|66.10|69.83|3.11| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|72.88|67.80|67.80|71.19|76.27|72.88|72.88|71.19|71.19|71.19|2.63| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |69.49|62.71|69.49|71.19|71.19|72.88|67.80|66.10|71.19|67.80|68.98|2.84| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |66.10|66.10|59.32|69.49|71.19|66.10|67.80|71.19|69.49|64.41|67.12|3.41| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |69.49|72.88|66.10|74.58|71.19|66.10|64.41|67.80|72.88|71.19|69.66|3.26| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|71.19|67.80|69.49|74.58|72.88|64.41|72.88|66.10|72.88|70.00|3.22| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |66.10|66.10|72.88|66.10|69.49|71.19|72.88|64.41|69.49|71.19|68.98|2.94| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |69.49|67.80|71.19|61.02|71.19|71.19|66.10|62.71|69.49|69.49|67.97|3.43|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 60.85 | 2.67 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 3.72 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.19 | 3.26 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.19 | 2.98 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 60.51 | 3.87 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 2.63 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 60.17 | 2.76 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 3.71 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 60.85 | 3.59 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 6.78 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 3.39 | 28.81 | 13.56 | 8.47 | 11.86 | 18.64 | 3.39 | 13.05 | 7.58 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 3.22 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 60.68 | 3.29 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 60.68 | 3.37 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 60.85 | 2.20 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 60.85 | 3.75 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 10.17 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 1.69 | 27.12 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 13.56 | 3.39 | 12.71 | 6.92 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.15 | 3.90 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 60.00 | 4.62 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.46 | 3.51 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 58.98 | 1.98 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 60.17 | 3.41 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 60.68 | 3.37 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 61.02 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 58.14 | 2.84 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 2.63 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 60.17 | 2.96 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.49 | 1.60 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.49 | 3.17 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.53 | 1.86 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 58.98 | 3.54 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.66 | 2.49 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 59.49 | 3.17 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.97 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 60.00 | 2.86 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 60.85 | 3.75 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 60.34 | 3.05 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.49 | 3.26 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 3.79 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.69 | 2.75 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 60.85 | 3.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 58.64 | 4.30 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 4.85 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 60.51 | 4.01 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 6.78 | 25.42 | 15.25 | 0.00 | 8.47 | 5.08 | 15.25 | 10.17 | 13.56 | 3.39 | 10.34 | 6.97 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.49 | 4.45 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 4.48 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 57.97 | 4.00 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 58.14 | 3.64 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.66 | 3.01 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 6.78 | 27.12 | 15.25 | 0.00 | 8.47 | 6.78 | 13.56 | 13.56 | 11.86 | 3.39 | 10.68 | 7.15 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.46 | 4.25 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 59.83 | 3.31 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 57.63 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 58.47 | 3.49 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 60.34 | 3.73 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 60.34 | 3.57 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 57.63 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 57.12 | 2.63 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 58.64 | 2.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 47.46 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 54.24 | 58.64 | 5.68 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 59.32 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 60.34 | 3.41 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.15 | 2.67 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 59.83 | 3.48 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 50.85 | 58.14 | 3.64 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 1.86 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 60.00 | 3.32 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 57.80 | 2.88 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 4.34 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.03 | 4.03 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 73.05 | 2.45 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.86 | 3.65 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 4.01 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 70.34 | 3.06 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.02 | 4.04 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 70.85 | 3.54 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.54 | 2.25 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 10.17 | 22.03 | 13.56 | 25.42 | 15.25 | 1.69 | 3.39 | 18.64 | 11.06 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 2.73 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.20 | 4.17 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.36 | 2.33 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 2.63 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 70.34 | 2.76 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 20.34 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 11.86 | 23.73 | 13.56 | 25.42 | 15.25 | 3.39 | 5.08 | 18.98 | 10.74 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.86 | 2.65 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.02 | 3.67 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.20 | 2.96 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 73.39 | 1.32 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 73.90 | 2.03 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 73.56 | 2.03 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 73.39 | 2.74 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 2.37 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.02 | 2.45 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.71 | 2.33 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.86 | 2.75 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 2.84 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.54 | 3.11 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.86 | 3.73 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.86 | 2.03 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.69 | 2.74 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.03 | 2.86 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.02 | 2.78 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.02 | 3.07 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 70.51 | 3.95 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 73.73 | 2.43 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 73.90 | 1.12 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 73.56 | 2.42 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 23.73 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 13.56 | 32.20 | 16.95 | 5.08 | 22.03 | 21.19 | 9.01 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 2.82 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 73.39 | 3.64 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.20 | 3.32 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 1.66 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.24 | 2.25 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 23.73 | 40.68 | 32.20 | 13.56 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 32.20 | 22.03 | 3.39 | 23.73 | 21.53 | 10.88 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 73.56 | 2.30 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 73.39 | 2.15 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 70.85 | 3.11 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.92 | 2.25 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.24 | 2.12 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 71.19 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.66 | 3.26 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.07 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 1.98 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.54 | 2.12 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 3.31 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.54 | 3.20 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 74.58 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.24 | 2.12 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.54 | 2.37 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 2.40 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |64.41|61.02|61.02|61.02|54.24|59.32|67.80|57.63|61.02|61.02|60.85|3.43| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |61.02|55.93|57.63|57.63|61.02|57.63|55.93|57.63|50.85|62.71|57.80|3.17| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |59.32|55.93|62.71|61.02|61.02|66.10|61.02|55.93|61.02|66.10|61.02|3.30| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |55.93|59.32|66.10|61.02|57.63|59.32|45.76|61.02|50.85|64.41|58.14|5.78| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |61.02|62.71|59.32|61.02|61.02|62.71|62.71|61.02|64.41|61.02|61.69|1.36| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |61.02|54.24|61.02|59.32|61.02|57.63|55.93|61.02|55.93|57.63|58.47|2.43| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |64.41|57.63|52.54|59.32|61.02|61.02|54.24|55.93|62.71|61.02|58.98|3.62| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |61.02|62.71|64.41|71.19|64.41|62.71|64.41|62.71|59.32|59.32|63.22|3.22| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |54.24|59.32|62.71|64.41|64.41|66.10|61.02|61.02|59.32|61.02|61.36|3.20| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |57.63|59.32|52.54|57.63|55.93|57.63|57.63|54.24|59.32|62.71|57.46|2.67| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |59.32|54.24|54.24|50.85|62.71|55.93|57.63|57.63|57.63|59.32|56.95|3.14| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |61.02|54.24|62.71|55.93|57.63|61.02|55.93|64.41|61.02|59.32|59.32|3.13| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |52.54|59.32|64.41|59.32|55.93|57.63|62.71|57.63|62.71|57.63|58.98|3.37| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |66.10|57.63|50.85|52.54|57.63|57.63|61.02|61.02|55.93|59.32|57.97|4.14| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |57.63|64.41|59.32|57.63|57.63|61.02|62.71|61.02|62.71|62.71|60.68|2.37| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |59.32|57.63|62.71|59.32|61.02|62.71|62.71|57.63|61.02|62.71|60.68|1.98| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |61.02|64.41|55.93|55.93|62.71|57.63|59.32|66.10|66.10|61.02|61.02|3.64| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |57.63|64.41|59.32|61.02|62.71|59.32|52.54|64.41|61.02|61.02|60.34|3.32| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |57.63|54.24|55.93|59.32|62.71|55.93|59.32|59.32|52.54|66.10|58.31|3.81| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |61.02|54.24|64.41|55.93|61.02|62.71|62.71|57.63|59.32|61.02|60.00|3.05| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |61.02|59.32|66.10|55.93|62.71|61.02|54.24|57.63|62.71|61.02|60.17|3.33|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 57.63 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 53.05 | 4.29 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 53.39 | 4.69 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.71 | 3.59 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 52.71 | 4.51 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 54.07 | 4.11 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 4.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 51.53 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 51.02 | 5.05 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 53.22 | 3.05 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 8.47 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 11.86 | 25.42 | 10.17 | 8.47 | 1.69 | 20.34 | 3.39 | 12.37 | 7.15 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 50.17 | 4.30 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 50.17 | 3.57 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 52.37 | 3.75 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 44.07 | 49.83 | 4.56 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 52.37 | 3.17 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 8.47 | 18.64 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 13.56 | 15.25 | 0.00 | 20.34 | 5.08 | 13.22 | 6.29 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 49.66 | 4.01 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 42.37 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 51.19 | 3.77 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 59.32 | 50.00 | 5.10 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 44.07 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 50.17 | 5.58 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 51.86 | 3.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 55.93 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 50.17 | 3.88 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 51.02 | 4.32 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 44.07 | 49.32 | 7.48 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 48.81 | 2.60 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 51.19 | 4.72 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 38.98 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 50.00 | 4.56 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 44.07 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 42.37 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 52.03 | 5.52 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.32 | 3.26 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 48.81 | 6.86 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 45.76 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 54.24 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 47.63 | 5.59 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 52.54 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.51 | 4.00 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.03 | 3.39 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 51.36 | 3.79 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 4.08 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 53.56 | 4.17 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 53.56 | 3.73 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 52.37 | 3.51 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.83 | 5.04 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 50.68 | 3.97 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 50.68 | 3.82 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 3.39 | 20.34 | 16.95 | 3.39 | 16.95 | 11.86 | 18.64 | 13.56 | 13.56 | 5.08 | 12.37 | 6.02 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 49.32 | 3.34 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 51.02 | 3.26 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 48.14 | 3.23 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 48.81 | 3.62 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.68 | 2.56 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 3.39 | 20.34 | 16.95 | 3.39 | 15.25 | 13.56 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 5.08 | 12.71 | 5.98 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 48.98 | 3.51 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 51.53 | 5.53 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 47.46 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 48.64 | 3.39 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 51.36 | 3.64 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 51.53 | 3.32 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 44.07 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 48.98 | 3.51 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 51.53 | 3.57 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 37.29 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 49.49 | 4.78 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 44.07 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 50.00 | 3.41 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 57.63 | 44.07 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 5.08 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 51.86 | 5.26 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 3.56 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 50.51 | 4.41 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 48.81 | 3.20 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 54.24 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 49.32 | 4.18 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 66.78 | 4.81 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 77.97 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 4.42 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.32 | 2.56 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 66.95 | 5.32 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 55.93 | 76.27 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 66.44 | 6.24 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.27 | 5.54 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 68.81 | 3.73 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.83 | 3.11 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.15 | 3.77 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 15.25 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 8.47 | 23.73 | 16.95 | 23.73 | 18.64 | 3.39 | 6.78 | 17.63 | 8.81 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 3.26 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 70.00 | 3.39 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.63 | 3.90 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 3.30 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.66 | 3.07 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 8.47 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 10.17 | 20.34 | 13.56 | 20.34 | 23.73 | 6.78 | 5.08 | 17.46 | 9.80 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 70.85 | 3.85 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.15 | 3.70 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.53 | 3.20 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.86 | 1.89 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 73.05 | 2.88 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.36 | 3.90 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.66 | 3.34 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.53 | 2.82 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 66.10 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.69 | 3.22 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.86 | 2.75 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 3.64 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.02 | 2.07 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 70.00 | 5.20 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.83 | 3.46 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.12 | 6.17 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.44 | 4.21 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.44 | 3.46 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 79.66 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 68.64 | 5.43 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 65.59 | 3.39 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 63.90 | 4.80 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 68.47 | 2.54 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 70.68 | 4.16 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 57.63 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 68.98 | 5.31 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 11.86 | 30.51 | 25.42 | 6.78 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 20.34 | 18.64 | 8.47 | 15.25 | 16.95 | 6.91 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.15 | 3.92 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.32 | 3.07 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 70.34 | 2.86 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 68.47 | 4.03 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 70.34 | 3.58 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 10.17 | 30.51 | 22.03 | 5.08 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 27.12 | 16.95 | 8.47 | 15.25 | 16.95 | 7.62 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 70.34 | 3.49 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 68.47 | 4.75 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 65.25 | 3.73 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 68.98 | 4.55 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.15 | 5.30 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 66.10 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 63.56 | 3.15 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 70.17 | 3.49 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 68.47 | 4.10 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.53 | 1.98 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 70.34 | 2.96 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 2.73 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.03 | 2.76 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 70.51 | 3.88 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 70.17 | 3.73 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |55.93|47.46|57.63|49.15|47.46|54.24|61.02|55.93|54.24|47.46|53.05|4.61| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |52.54|49.15|52.54|52.54|54.24|45.76|54.24|50.85|49.15|54.24|51.53|2.65| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |55.93|47.46|52.54|50.85|44.07|49.15|54.24|57.63|49.15|52.54|51.36|3.87| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |55.93|55.93|55.93|49.15|50.85|57.63|38.98|49.15|47.46|54.24|51.53|5.37| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |62.71|57.63|50.85|50.85|57.63|54.24|55.93|52.54|52.54|50.85|54.58|3.70| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |45.76|45.76|45.76|40.68|50.85|55.93|49.15|49.15|49.15|38.98|47.12|4.66| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |49.15|44.07|54.24|47.46|54.24|47.46|45.76|50.85|55.93|50.85|50.00|3.73| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |52.54|61.02|55.93|54.24|52.54|49.15|47.46|57.63|54.24|57.63|54.24|3.87| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |47.46|45.76|50.85|54.24|50.85|45.76|50.85|55.93|47.46|52.54|50.17|3.32| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |52.54|52.54|47.46|45.76|54.24|45.76|49.15|49.15|47.46|57.63|50.17|3.73| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |47.46|54.24|42.37|47.46|57.63|45.76|44.07|50.85|47.46|49.15|48.64|4.36| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |49.15|49.15|52.54|44.07|45.76|52.54|45.76|57.63|49.15|47.46|49.32|3.82| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |55.93|49.15|55.93|55.93|47.46|47.46|49.15|55.93|49.15|50.85|51.69|3.58| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |54.24|50.85|49.15|45.76|47.46|45.76|49.15|54.24|44.07|52.54|49.32|3.43| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |47.46|57.63|50.85|54.24|47.46|64.41|47.46|50.85|55.93|50.85|52.71|5.17| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |47.46|52.54|50.85|49.15|57.63|42.37|49.15|49.15|45.76|47.46|49.15|3.87| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |55.93|52.54|49.15|54.24|49.15|49.15|49.15|52.54|52.54|52.54|51.69|2.31| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |45.76|55.93|42.37|55.93|50.85|52.54|55.93|50.85|52.54|54.24|51.69|4.30| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |50.85|52.54|54.24|49.15|49.15|55.93|52.54|47.46|47.46|55.93|51.53|3.05| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |55.93|52.54|47.46|50.85|55.93|47.46|52.54|54.24|49.15|50.85|51.69|2.96| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |50.85|55.93|54.24|47.46|52.54|49.15|49.15|47.46|54.24|54.24|51.53|2.96|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.00 | 2.74 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.83 | 1.98 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.02 | 2.20 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 2.20 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 2.33 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.86 | 1.89 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.66 | 3.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.53 | 2.71 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.86 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 6.78 | 20.34 | 23.73 | 10.17 | 16.95 | 6.78 | 6.78 | 6.78 | 15.25 | 6.78 | 12.03 | 6.18 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 70.00 | 3.22 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 70.85 | 2.82 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 72.37 | 3.39 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 73.56 | 2.54 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.20 | 2.96 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 10.17 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 6.78 | 18.64 | 6.78 | 8.47 | 5.08 | 22.03 | 6.78 | 12.54 | 6.57 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.69 | 2.40 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 2.63 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.97 | 2.98 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 2.14 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 70.51 | 2.54 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 70.85 | 3.77 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 70.00 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.32 | 3.59 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.15 | 3.46 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 70.68 | 4.36 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 73.05 | 4.04 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 72.71 | 3.82 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 70.17 | 2.96 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 70.34 | 2.54 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.36 | 3.07 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 3.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.66 | 3.97 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.15 | 3.37 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 68.31 | 2.40 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 68.81 | 2.42 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.34 | 3.06 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.66 | 3.26 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 68.98 | 3.04 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 4.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 68.14 | 2.60 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.97 | 3.59 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 8.47 | 28.81 | 11.86 | 5.08 | 8.47 | 8.47 | 22.03 | 16.95 | 13.56 | 6.78 | 13.05 | 7.15 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 68.31 | 3.94 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 79.66 | 69.32 | 4.88 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 70.00 | 3.04 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 68.47 | 4.10 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 79.66 | 68.64 | 5.15 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 8.47 | 25.42 | 11.86 | 5.08 | 13.56 | 6.78 | 13.56 | 13.56 | 10.17 | 5.08 | 11.36 | 5.67 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 4.35 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 79.66 | 70.51 | 5.21 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 67.80 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.97 | 3.34 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 68.14 | 3.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 68.64 | 3.33 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 67.12 | 3.49 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.63 | 4.04 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 3.79 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 71.19 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 3.47 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.51 | 4.17 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.15 | 3.37 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 67.63 | 4.32 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.97 | 4.11 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.15 | 3.01 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.78 | 2.54 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.41 | 1.83 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.92 | 2.33 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.41 | 2.71 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.73 | 1.36 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.90 | 2.04 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 84.07 | 2.86 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 82.88 | 2.78 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.39 | 1.83 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 83.22 | 2.78 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 10.17 | 25.42 | 6.78 | 28.81 | 20.34 | 6.78 | 5.08 | 21.69 | 13.53 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 85.25 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 82.88 | 3.17 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.39 | 1.66 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 82.54 | 1.09 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 83.39 | 2.92 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 10.17 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 15.25 | 25.42 | 6.78 | 30.51 | 23.73 | 3.39 | 3.39 | 20.68 | 14.69 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 82.20 | 2.04 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.58 | 2.07 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.90 | 1.56 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 85.42 | 3.14 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 2.63 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 83.05 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 85.59 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.41 | 2.25 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.58 | 2.20 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.07 | 1.89 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.10 | 3.37 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.10 | 3.01 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 83.05 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 85.93 | 2.15 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.90 | 2.31 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.58 | 2.56 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 91.53 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.73 | 3.57 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 81.86 | 2.63 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 82.20 | 3.24 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 84.75 | 74.58 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.90 | 3.88 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.53 | 1.93 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 81.19 | 3.59 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.56 | 3.13 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.92 | 3.07 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.41 | 3.11 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 10.17 | 23.73 | 5.08 | 30.51 | 18.64 | 3.39 | 20.34 | 21.19 | 11.30 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 76.27 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.24 | 3.94 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 76.27 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 3.30 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 2.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 2.01 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 91.53 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 84.58 | 3.75 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 20.34 | 42.37 | 30.51 | 11.86 | 23.73 | 6.78 | 38.98 | 18.64 | 5.08 | 22.03 | 22.03 | 11.89 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.22 | 2.78 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 82.20 | 3.15 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 79.49 | 3.43 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.24 | 2.40 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.73 | 2.17 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 84.75 | 83.05 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 80.17 | 3.94 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 85.25 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 2.14 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.07 | 2.30 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.07 | 1.73 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.58 | 1.41 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 81.36 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 85.42 | 2.75 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.07 | 1.89 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.07 | 2.30 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |72.88|69.49|64.41|66.10|64.41|71.19|74.58|66.10|69.49|69.49|68.81|3.32| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |74.58|69.49|67.80|66.10|66.10|69.49|64.41|74.58|62.71|76.27|69.15|4.41| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |64.41|66.10|66.10|66.10|62.71|69.49|71.19|64.41|67.80|66.10|66.44|2.37| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |61.02|64.41|76.27|67.80|66.10|71.19|57.63|71.19|61.02|71.19|66.78|5.53| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |74.58|67.80|67.80|69.49|69.49|67.80|71.19|66.10|69.49|66.10|68.98|2.40| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |69.49|62.71|64.41|69.49|67.80|67.80|64.41|69.49|64.41|71.19|67.12|2.75| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |67.80|67.80|66.10|64.41|71.19|69.49|66.10|72.88|67.80|72.88|68.64|2.76| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |66.10|72.88|71.19|67.80|69.49|66.10|67.80|69.49|69.49|71.19|69.15|2.12| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |66.10|67.80|67.80|69.49|69.49|69.49|71.19|67.80|67.80|67.80|68.47|1.36| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |66.10|71.19|69.49|66.10|66.10|66.10|69.49|67.80|71.19|74.58|68.81|2.75| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |67.80|69.49|66.10|59.32|66.10|64.41|67.80|67.80|66.10|67.80|66.27|2.67| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |69.49|62.71|66.10|62.71|62.71|66.10|61.02|69.49|69.49|67.80|65.76|3.11| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |69.49|64.41|71.19|69.49|62.71|66.10|67.80|71.19|71.19|67.80|68.14|2.82| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |71.19|67.80|62.71|64.41|64.41|69.49|69.49|69.49|69.49|67.80|67.63|2.67| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|74.58|69.49|72.88|69.49|71.19|72.88|71.19|67.80|67.80|70.51|2.30| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |67.80|64.41|64.41|72.88|69.49|69.49|67.80|66.10|67.80|69.49|67.97|2.45| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |64.41|64.41|61.02|62.71|67.80|64.41|66.10|67.80|67.80|67.80|65.42|2.30| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |69.49|74.58|67.80|67.80|66.10|67.80|62.71|67.80|72.88|67.80|68.47|3.14| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |69.49|72.88|69.49|69.49|72.88|71.19|66.10|69.49|66.10|71.19|69.83|2.25| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |64.41|66.10|71.19|67.80|69.49|71.19|67.80|64.41|66.10|67.80|67.63|2.33| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|67.80|69.49|61.02|67.80|69.49|64.41|62.71|66.10|67.80|66.44|2.71|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 3.22 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 63.39 | 1.73 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.88 | 1.93 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 63.39 | 2.96 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 61.53 | 3.31 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 63.56 | 2.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.03 | 2.30 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.07 | 2.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 63.05 | 3.01 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 8.47 | 13.56 | 20.34 | 6.78 | 23.73 | 8.47 | 11.86 | 6.78 | 18.64 | 5.08 | 12.37 | 6.16 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 63.73 | 3.73 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.37 | 3.92 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.88 | 2.88 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.58 | 2.67 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 63.56 | 2.76 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 8.47 | 13.56 | 22.03 | 13.56 | 22.03 | 13.56 | 11.86 | 8.47 | 15.25 | 6.78 | 13.56 | 4.97 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 63.39 | 2.75 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 63.39 | 4.23 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 4.15 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.69 | 2.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 61.19 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.53 | 3.39 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.54 | 2.78 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.03 | 3.49 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.36 | 3.11 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 67.80 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 63.05 | 4.07 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 60.85 | 4.38 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.69 | 4.30 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.03 | 3.23 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.37 | 3.54 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 60.51 | 2.40 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 57.63 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.36 | 3.46 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 4.22 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.19 | 2.88 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 2.84 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 2.27 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.53 | 2.84 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.86 | 2.43 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.88 | 2.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 61.53 | 4.68 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.53 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 60.34 | 2.96 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 3.39 | 23.73 | 15.25 | 5.08 | 16.95 | 8.47 | 11.86 | 15.25 | 6.78 | 10.17 | 11.69 | 5.89 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.19 | 2.78 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.37 | 5.24 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 61.69 | 4.23 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 60.68 | 3.20 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 61.53 | 4.36 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 3.39 | 27.12 | 15.25 | 5.08 | 15.25 | 8.47 | 10.17 | 20.34 | 5.08 | 10.17 | 12.03 | 7.13 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.20 | 2.74 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.53 | 3.72 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 60.34 | 2.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.20 | 3.31 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.36 | 3.46 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.36 | 3.01 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 60.85 | 1.60 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 3.04 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.88 | 2.88 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 61.86 | 3.33 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 60.51 | 2.40 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 4.22 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 63.22 | 3.13 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 3.03 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 58.81 | 3.39 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.78 | 2.84 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 75.93 | 3.37 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 75.76 | 2.01 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 3.56 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.07 | 3.79 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 73.73 | 3.15 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 75.59 | 2.42 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.10 | 2.33 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 73.05 | 1.60 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 10.17 | 20.34 | 23.73 | 5.08 | 6.78 | 19.83 | 9.94 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 2.27 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 75.42 | 2.54 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 73.56 | 3.32 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 1.53 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 2.84 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 25.42 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 18.64 | 15.25 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 20.34 | 3.39 | 10.17 | 19.49 | 9.26 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 73.56 | 2.30 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 73.22 | 2.60 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 81.36 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 2.40 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 2.27 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.92 | 1.83 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 76.27 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.63 | 2.37 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 81.36 | 75.93 | 3.54 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 74.75 | 3.97 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 75.59 | 2.03 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 75.93 | 3.29 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.75 | 2.20 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 76.27 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 75.76 | 2.15 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 2.73 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 73.39 | 2.84 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 75.25 | 1.12 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 75.93 | 3.70 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.41 | 2.56 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 75.42 | 2.31 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 73.56 | 3.88 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 73.73 | 4.10 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 78.98 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 79.15 | 2.15 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 78.98 | 3.23 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 25.42 | 40.68 | 32.20 | 18.64 | 15.25 | 13.56 | 25.42 | 15.25 | 3.39 | 22.03 | 21.19 | 9.95 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.80 | 2.07 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 77.63 | 2.25 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 75.25 | 2.17 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 76.44 | 2.45 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 76.61 | 2.92 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 22.03 | 40.68 | 32.20 | 16.95 | 11.86 | 16.95 | 28.81 | 15.25 | 6.78 | 23.73 | 21.53 | 9.65 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.10 | 2.67 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 75.93 | 2.12 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 79.66 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 76.78 | 3.39 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 78.81 | 1.74 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 78.31 | 2.92 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 81.36 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 75.76 | 3.39 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 86.44 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 78.98 | 3.14 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 78.31 | 1.83 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 3.22 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 75.76 | 1.70 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 72.88 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.10 | 2.67 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 77.97 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 1.86 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 76.61 | 3.01 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.10 | 1.77 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |66.10|61.02|59.32|62.71|59.32|67.80|61.02|59.32|67.80|61.02|62.54|3.26| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |57.63|59.32|57.63|59.32|59.32|59.32|55.93|62.71|54.24|67.80|59.32|3.56| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |55.93|59.32|62.71|54.24|55.93|62.71|64.41|57.63|61.02|57.63|59.15|3.26| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |57.63|57.63|62.71|61.02|62.71|62.71|54.24|57.63|54.24|61.02|59.15|3.17| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |62.71|64.41|62.71|61.02|61.02|59.32|67.80|62.71|57.63|59.32|61.86|2.76| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |64.41|55.93|61.02|61.02|57.63|61.02|57.63|64.41|64.41|62.71|61.02|2.94| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |61.02|62.71|57.63|57.63|59.32|61.02|62.71|66.10|55.93|59.32|60.34|2.86| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |64.41|66.10|62.71|69.49|69.49|61.02|61.02|64.41|61.02|64.41|64.41|3.03| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |55.93|62.71|59.32|67.80|57.63|61.02|64.41|64.41|61.02|61.02|61.53|3.31| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |59.32|62.71|55.93|55.93|57.63|55.93|62.71|57.63|61.02|66.10|59.49|3.34| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |61.02|62.71|61.02|55.93|55.93|57.63|62.71|59.32|57.63|59.32|59.32|2.40| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |62.71|59.32|59.32|57.63|55.93|59.32|54.24|61.02|62.71|59.32|59.15|2.56| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |61.02|57.63|64.41|64.41|54.24|55.93|57.63|57.63|57.63|59.32|58.98|3.20| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |64.41|54.24|55.93|61.02|59.32|59.32|64.41|61.02|59.32|55.93|59.49|3.26| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |59.32|62.71|66.10|61.02|62.71|67.80|61.02|61.02|64.41|59.32|62.54|2.67| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |62.71|62.71|59.32|62.71|66.10|61.02|61.02|57.63|62.71|61.02|61.69|2.17| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |62.71|57.63|54.24|62.71|61.02|62.71|59.32|67.80|64.41|62.71|61.53|3.56| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |61.02|61.02|55.93|59.32|61.02|59.32|50.85|59.32|61.02|57.63|58.64|3.05| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |57.63|59.32|61.02|59.32|62.71|62.71|55.93|62.71|57.63|66.10|60.51|2.94| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |59.32|59.32|62.71|55.93|61.02|61.02|59.32|59.32|59.32|57.63|59.49|1.77| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |61.02|57.63|64.41|55.93|66.10|62.71|55.93|57.63|59.32|61.02|60.17|3.33|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 34.41 | 3.79 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 28.81 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 33.22 | 4.81 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 33.39 | 3.79 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 42.37 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 33.56 | 4.34 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 25.42 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 34.07 | 5.84 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 32.71 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 33.39 | 3.72 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 23.73 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 25.42 | 32.71 | 5.14 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 32.88 | 2.42 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 11.86 | 6.78 | 18.64 | 3.39 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 18.64 | 10.17 | 22.03 | 3.39 | 11.86 | 6.06 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 33.39 | 4.49 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 23.73 | 32.20 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 34.41 | 6.57 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 33.56 | 3.01 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 22.03 | 37.29 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 31.69 | 5.42 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 32.54 | 3.29 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 11.86 | 5.08 | 16.95 | 8.47 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 16.95 | 1.69 | 20.34 | 5.08 | 11.02 | 5.68 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 25.42 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 42.37 | 30.51 | 32.71 | 5.03 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 23.73 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 33.73 | 5.00 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 37.29 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 34.07 | 3.26 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 28.81 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 23.73 | 23.73 | 38.98 | 33.22 | 6.21 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 25.42 | 42.37 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 33.22 | 5.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 35.25 | 3.11 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 28.81 | 40.68 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 25.42 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 32.54 | 4.07 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 23.73 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 32.71 | 4.29 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 42.37 | 25.42 | 37.29 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 4.97 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 25.42 | 42.37 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 32.71 | 5.25 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 27.12 | 37.29 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 4.61 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 34.92 | 2.96 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 44.07 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 25.42 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 5.92 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 40.68 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 3.87 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 33.22 | 2.65 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 27.12 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 20.34 | 23.73 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 32.03 | 6.09 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 45.76 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 40.68 | 25.42 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 34.58 | 6.12 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 40.68 | 28.81 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 33.56 | 4.54 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 33.39 | 3.31 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 34.24 | 3.92 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 42.37 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 40.68 | 25.42 | 34.75 | 5.15 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 27.12 | 35.25 | 5.35 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 40.68 | 25.42 | 40.68 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 36.10 | 5.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 33.73 | 4.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 25.42 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 28.81 | 33.22 | 4.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 30.51 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 28.81 | 25.42 | 32.71 | 3.56 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 10.17 | 13.56 | 16.95 | 8.47 | 10.17 | 6.78 | 15.25 | 13.56 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 2.94 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 35.76 | 2.88 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 33.73 | 3.43 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 23.73 | 40.68 | 25.42 | 32.54 | 5.13 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 23.73 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 32.03 | 4.18 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 28.81 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 23.73 | 37.29 | 25.42 | 31.53 | 4.68 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 10.17 | 16.95 | 20.34 | 5.08 | 5.08 | 10.17 | 16.95 | 15.25 | 11.86 | 8.47 | 12.03 | 4.94 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 32.03 | 4.32 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 2.94 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 25.42 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 42.37 | 25.42 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 23.73 | 30.51 | 31.86 | 5.66 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 33.39 | 4.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 33.05 | 2.54 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 27.12 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 22.03 | 32.20 | 32.54 | 5.07 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 32.20 | 34.92 | 3.57 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 33.39 | 3.22 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 22.03 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 18.64 | 33.90 | 30.51 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 31.86 | 7.02 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 34.24 | 4.07 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 5.52 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 42.37 | 42.37 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 30.51 | 28.81 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 35.42 | 4.58 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 27.12 | 30.51 | 34.92 | 3.41 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 27.12 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 33.73 | 3.51 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 30.51 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 32.20 | 27.12 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 3.64 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 32.20 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 44.24 | 5.89 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 47.63 | 3.51 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 48.81 | 4.00 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 33.90 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 43.39 | 4.43 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 37.29 | 49.15 | 33.90 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 45.08 | 6.03 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 57.63 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 46.61 | 5.68 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 35.59 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 46.95 | 5.20 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 46.61 | 3.06 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 35.59 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 46.10 | 4.47 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 22.03 | 18.64 | 25.42 | 20.34 | 18.64 | 15.25 | 6.78 | 1.69 | 16.95 | 6.95 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 38.98 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 47.97 | 4.92 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 46.44 | 5.04 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 32.20 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 44.41 | 4.72 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 3.03 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 44.92 | 3.41 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 11.86 | 22.03 | 23.73 | 16.95 | 16.95 | 23.73 | 13.56 | 18.64 | 6.78 | 5.08 | 15.93 | 6.26 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 45.25 | 3.31 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 45.42 | 1.83 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 44.07 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 46.78 | 4.92 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 46.78 | 3.95 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.12 | 4.47 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 44.07 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 5.31 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 46.95 | 2.94 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 37.29 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 45.59 | 4.04 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 42.37 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 45.59 | 3.75 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 47.80 | 4.07 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 48.98 | 3.51 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 44.07 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 45.59 | 3.34 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 4.08 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 46.27 | 3.22 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 46.10 | 3.11 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.59 | 2.78 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 46.44 | 2.54 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 33.90 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 45.08 | 4.68 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 46.27 | 4.29 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 45.08 | 4.50 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 44.75 | 3.32 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.59 | 1.60 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 45.08 | 2.17 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 18.64 | 11.86 | 18.64 | 20.34 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 6.78 | 6.78 | 15.76 | 5.20 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 46.10 | 4.27 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 46.44 | 3.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 37.29 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 46.61 | 6.12 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 3.71 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 46.61 | 3.81 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 13.56 | 27.12 | 18.64 | 11.86 | 15.25 | 23.73 | 11.86 | 15.25 | 5.08 | 8.47 | 15.08 | 6.32 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 44.41 | 2.49 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 45.93 | 2.88 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 42.37 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 40.68 | 40.51 | 1.93 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 46.10 | 2.92 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 46.61 | 3.33 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 40.68 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 35.59 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 3.13 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 43.73 | 1.98 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 37.29 | 47.46 | 37.29 | 44.07 | 42.71 | 3.85 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 44.07 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 2.40 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 47.12 | 2.82 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 47.12 | 4.96 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 44.07 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 45.42 | 2.71 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 44.58 | 4.01 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 45.93 | 4.18 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |42.37|28.81|38.98|37.29|33.90|28.81|32.20|35.59|47.46|28.81|35.42|5.94| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |27.12|35.59|32.20|28.81|37.29|32.20|32.20|32.20|32.20|44.07|33.39|4.49| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |35.59|30.51|40.68|37.29|35.59|33.90|30.51|32.20|30.51|35.59|34.24|3.20| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |37.29|32.20|37.29|37.29|22.03|37.29|20.34|32.20|33.90|40.68|33.05|6.44| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |32.20|35.59|30.51|30.51|30.51|30.51|28.81|33.90|33.90|32.20|31.86|1.98| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |27.12|45.76|33.90|30.51|33.90|35.59|23.73|25.42|37.29|25.42|31.86|6.47| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |42.37|30.51|38.98|28.81|35.59|35.59|32.20|28.81|37.29|32.20|34.24|4.27| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |40.68|35.59|37.29|32.20|35.59|40.68|37.29|37.29|35.59|38.98|37.12|2.45| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |27.12|37.29|33.90|35.59|33.90|35.59|33.90|28.81|28.81|28.81|32.37|3.43| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |38.98|32.20|37.29|33.90|35.59|32.20|33.90|30.51|38.98|35.59|34.92|2.75| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |30.51|37.29|25.42|30.51|38.98|27.12|33.90|33.90|27.12|30.51|31.53|4.23| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |37.29|32.20|32.20|25.42|35.59|42.37|33.90|40.68|27.12|32.20|33.90|5.08| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |30.51|30.51|33.90|32.20|30.51|30.51|27.12|30.51|38.98|32.20|31.69|2.94| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |37.29|33.90|32.20|40.68|33.90|30.51|35.59|30.51|38.98|33.90|34.75|3.24| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |38.98|42.37|30.51|47.46|32.20|33.90|30.51|35.59|32.20|28.81|35.25|5.66| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |30.51|37.29|35.59|23.73|38.98|35.59|37.29|30.51|30.51|38.98|33.90|4.67| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |40.68|32.20|28.81|40.68|32.20|30.51|33.90|33.90|35.59|42.37|35.08|4.42| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |37.29|44.07|25.42|33.90|38.98|35.59|38.98|42.37|40.68|40.68|37.80|5.03| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |33.90|30.51|28.81|38.98|25.42|32.20|38.98|33.90|27.12|32.20|32.20|4.29| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |42.37|30.51|38.98|28.81|38.98|33.90|33.90|42.37|33.90|32.20|35.59|4.55| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |40.68|32.20|32.20|32.20|30.51|30.51|37.29|37.29|27.12|35.59|33.56|3.85|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.54 | 3.29 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.36 | 3.17 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.86 | 2.86 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.07 | 2.15 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.37 | 2.40 |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 73.73 | 1.89 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.83 | 3.46 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.83 | 3.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 72.20 | 3.73 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 8.47 | 18.64 | 22.03 | 5.08 | 20.34 | 10.17 | 11.86 | 11.86 | 20.34 | 3.39 | 13.22 | 6.38 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 4.01 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.34 | 3.81 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.36 | 3.90 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.03 | 2.86 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.54 | 3.85 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | 8.47 | 16.95 | 22.03 | 3.39 | 23.73 | 8.47 | 5.08 | 10.17 | 22.03 | 5.08 | 12.54 | 7.47 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 71.69 | 4.42 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 73.39 | 3.22 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERTwithAtt-bs4 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 4.22 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 69.49 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 3.30 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 68.47 | 3.32 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 3.71 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 68.31 | 3.04 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 3.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.97 | 3.90 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 77.97 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 68.81 | 5.48 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 70.51 | 4.17 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 4.67 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 70.17 | 4.62 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 70.51 | 2.17 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 71.02 | 2.67 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.36 | 3.26 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.02 | 3.34 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.15 | 3.54 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 70.17 | 2.75 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.83 | 3.01 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.02 | 2.98 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 70.34 | 3.15 |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 70.17 | 2.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.58 | 5.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 65.25 | 3.24 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 65.59 | 4.29 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 5.08 | 23.73 | 10.17 | 3.39 | 13.56 | 13.56 | 23.73 | 16.95 | 11.86 | 6.78 | 12.88 | 6.70 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 66.27 | 4.32 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 77.97 | 66.95 | 4.93 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 68.31 | 3.13 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 66.78 | 5.15 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 67.97 | 4.64 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | 5.08 | 25.42 | 11.86 | 3.39 | 18.64 | 6.78 | 11.86 | 13.56 | 8.47 | 6.78 | 11.19 | 6.40 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 3.71 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 79.66 | 68.98 | 5.03 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.24 | 3.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 65.93 | 4.51 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 65.08 | 4.30 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 2.94 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 64.24 | 4.58 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.75 | 3.70 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 81.36 | 67.63 | 6.09 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 70.85 | 3.37 |
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 3.22 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 67.29 | 4.49 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 3.87 |
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.32 | 2.98 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 63.56 | 3.15 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 1.69 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 82.54 | 2.40 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 82.71 | 2.71 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 80.51 | 2.04 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 81.86 | 3.04 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 81.69 | 2.71 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 74.58 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 3.64 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 82.37 | 3.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 82.37 | 2.54 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 25.42 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 1.69 | 20.34 | 10.17 | 27.12 | 23.73 | 1.69 | 6.78 | 19.15 | 12.77 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.73 | 2.75 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 82.20 | 2.04 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 80.85 | 2.52 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.69 | 1.66 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 82.20 | 2.04 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 11.86 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 5.08 | 18.64 | 8.47 | 28.81 | 23.73 | 3.39 | 6.78 | 18.81 | 13.44 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 82.20 | 2.18 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 82.71 | 1.66 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 82.37 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.07 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 3.03 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.56 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 82.54 | 3.22 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 83.39 | 2.82 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 2.01 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.92 | 3.17 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.73 | 3.05 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.90 | 1.56 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 2.01 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.73 | 1.55 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 80.00 | 2.92 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 88.14 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 80.51 | 3.81 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 80.68 | 2.30 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 83.05 | 76.27 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 80.68 | 2.30 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 79.49 | 2.45 |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 84.75 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 79.49 | 2.98 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.69 | 3.46 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 82.37 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.02 | 3.20 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | 28.81 | 38.98 | 27.12 | 5.08 | 20.34 | 6.78 | 30.51 | 20.34 | 8.47 | 16.95 | 20.34 | 10.67 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 74.58 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.53 | 3.51 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.69 | 2.37 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 82.54 | 2.94 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.86 | 2.84 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 81.69 | 2.25 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 15.25 | 42.37 | 30.51 | 5.08 | 15.25 | 8.47 | 38.98 | 20.34 | 10.17 | 15.25 | 20.17 | 12.21 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 82.20 | 3.65 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 80.51 | 2.65 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 84.75 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 77.29 | 4.87 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 2.27 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 82.20 | 2.18 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 83.05 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 84.75 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 77.63 | 4.66 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 81.02 | 3.62 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 84.75 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 2.63 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.22 | 1.77 |
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 82.88 | 2.33 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.22 | 2.88 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 82.71 | 1.98 |
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 82.37 | 2.42 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |74.58|71.19|67.80|69.49|67.80|72.88|72.88|66.10|69.49|72.88|70.51|2.65| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |69.49|67.80|64.41|62.71|66.10|64.41|72.88|71.19|54.24|72.88|66.61|5.36| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |61.02|62.71|61.02|62.71|55.93|69.49|69.49|59.32|64.41|62.71|62.88|3.97| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |61.02|66.10|74.58|67.80|62.71|71.19|50.85|72.88|55.93|72.88|65.59|7.51| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |72.88|69.49|66.10|67.80|67.80|64.41|72.88|72.88|64.41|62.71|68.14|3.62| | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |69.49|61.02|64.41|67.80|66.10|64.41|69.49|69.49|59.32|71.19|66.27|3.75| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |72.88|66.10|66.10|62.71|67.80|71.19|67.80|72.88|66.10|77.97|69.15|4.27| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |69.49|67.80|69.49|72.88|64.41|74.58|67.80|71.19|64.41|71.19|69.32|3.17| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |62.71|71.19|74.58|66.10|69.49|69.49|71.19|64.41|62.71|66.10|67.80|3.79| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |67.80|69.49|66.10|66.10|67.80|59.32|62.71|67.80|67.80|77.97|67.29|4.55| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |64.41|64.41|67.80|55.93|64.41|61.02|66.10|64.41|64.41|67.80|64.07|3.29| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |66.10|62.71|61.02|61.02|57.63|62.71|61.02|66.10|66.10|62.71|62.71|2.63| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |64.41|62.71|69.49|71.19|61.02|64.41|66.10|64.41|67.80|67.80|65.93|2.98| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |67.80|64.41|64.41|66.10|64.41|61.02|72.88|72.88|67.80|67.80|66.95|3.58| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |64.41|76.27|67.80|71.19|72.88|66.10|67.80|71.19|67.80|67.80|69.32|3.34| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |64.41|62.71|67.80|67.80|76.27|66.10|69.49|62.71|69.49|66.10|67.29|3.79| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |62.71|66.10|57.63|62.71|66.10|62.71|62.71|66.10|69.49|67.80|64.41|3.22| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |66.10|69.49|64.41|64.41|64.41|62.71|59.32|66.10|72.88|62.71|65.25|3.58| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |64.41|66.10|66.10|67.80|76.27|69.49|62.71|67.80|64.41|69.49|67.46|3.62| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |61.02|66.10|69.49|69.49|66.10|72.88|66.10|64.41|61.02|64.41|66.10|3.56| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|69.49|69.49|59.32|66.10|66.10|67.80|57.63|61.02|64.41|64.92|4.01|
TODO: redo webapplications ep100, bs16 (bertquery, bertKeyVal -> deleted by mistake)
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.69 | 2.86 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 2.27 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 59.32 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 58.64 | 2.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.80 | 2.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 60.51 | 3.13 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 58.81 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 58.47 | 3.15 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 65.25 | 1.37 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 62.71 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.86 | 2.31 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 53.22 | 3.49 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 51.86 | 4.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 55.93 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 52.71 | 4.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 55.93 | 52.71 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 53.39 | 6.62 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 55.08 | 4.24 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 53.39 | 5.79 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 61.19 | 2.88 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.80 | 2.88 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.03 | 3.57 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 61.53 | 4.61 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 61.69 | 4.10 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 60.00 | 5.32 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 32.20 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 58.64 | 10.00 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 60.51 | 5.67 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 4.01 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 65.25 | 2.31 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 2.94 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 58.14 | 2.84 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 56.44 | 2.63 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 44.07 | 45.76 | 37.29 | 47.46 | 37.29 | 59.32 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 57.63 | 45.93 | 7.09 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 52.54 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 37.29 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 46.95 | 4.97 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 37.29 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 4.61 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 27.12 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 40.51 | 5.75 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 2.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 61.02 | 62.71 | 50.85 | 67.80 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 59.83 | 5.47 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 64.24 | 2.33 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 59.32 | 65.42 | 4.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 61.69 | 4.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 63.22 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 61.02 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.20 | 2.15 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 2.84 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.86 | 2.31 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 62.54 | 3.51 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 65.42 | 2.03 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 61.53 | 2.52 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 60.34 | 4.62 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 60.34 | 4.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 63.05 | 2.71 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 60.68 | 3.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.88 | 2.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 61.02 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.53 | 3.64 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.54 | 3.17 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.19 | 2.88 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 60.34 | 2.30 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.83 | 2.63 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.83 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.15 | 2.07 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 58.14 | 2.01 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 3.71 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 61.69 | 3.57 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 2.84 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 56.95 | 3.57 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 3.22 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.95 | 4.37 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 66.10 | 68.31 | 4.22 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 67.80 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 72.88 | 59.32 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 67.12 | 5.26 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 66.44 | 4.41 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 67.12 | 3.57 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 65.93 | 5.05 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 67.80 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 68.98 | 5.57 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.88 | 2.56 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 63.73 | 1.89 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 62.71 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 60.85 | 3.07 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 69.49 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.69 | 3.41 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 64.58 | 3.82 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.54 | 3.17 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.07 | 2.37 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 72.88 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.27 | 3.75 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |64.41|67.80|61.02|59.32|62.71|57.63|64.41|59.32|64.41|67.80|62.88|3.34| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |61.02|62.71|57.63|71.19|61.02|59.32|59.32|61.02|67.80|61.02|62.20|3.94| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |54.24|61.02|59.32|59.32|52.54|64.41|64.41|64.41|61.02|64.41|60.51|4.09| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |55.93|61.02|67.80|59.32|66.10|59.32|57.63|62.71|54.24|54.24|59.83|4.42| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |57.63|66.10|62.71|62.71|61.02|64.41|62.71|57.63|61.02|55.93|61.19|3.07| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |61.02|62.71|59.32|66.10|57.63|62.71|61.02|59.32|61.02|59.32|61.02|2.27| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |62.71|59.32|57.63|64.41|62.71|61.02|57.63|59.32|64.41|55.93|60.51|2.84| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |57.63|59.32|64.41|62.71|59.32|59.32|64.41|64.41|61.02|61.02|61.36|2.37| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |52.54|61.02|57.63|62.71|66.10|61.02|66.10|61.02|62.71|66.10|61.69|4.03| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |64.41|62.71|61.02|61.02|57.63|52.54|61.02|64.41|62.71|66.10|61.36|3.70| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |64.41|66.10|59.32|57.63|66.10|54.24|64.41|57.63|64.41|64.41|61.86|4.03| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |64.41|57.63|62.71|64.41|61.02|57.63|62.71|62.71|61.02|55.93|61.02|2.84| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |59.32|59.32|57.63|54.24|69.49|59.32|61.02|64.41|59.32|64.41|60.85|4.04| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |59.32|64.41|57.63|59.32|59.32|52.54|61.02|67.80|61.02|64.41|60.68|4.00| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |62.71|57.63|62.71|57.63|61.02|62.71|62.71|57.63|61.02|62.71|60.85|2.20| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |66.10|62.71|67.80|57.63|61.02|62.71|61.02|57.63|66.10|67.80|63.05|3.62| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |66.10|62.71|57.63|62.71|64.41|62.71|62.71|62.71|61.02|61.02|62.37|2.12| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |61.02|59.32|50.85|64.41|61.02|54.24|64.41|57.63|62.71|64.41|60.00|4.37| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |66.10|59.32|61.02|59.32|66.10|61.02|61.02|66.10|57.63|66.10|62.37|3.20| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |57.63|59.32|61.02|64.41|55.93|59.32|66.10|59.32|57.63|61.02|60.17|2.96| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |64.41|57.63|62.71|61.02|61.02|57.63|61.02|64.41|61.02|62.71|61.36|2.25|
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 56.10 | 3.67 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.59 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.92 | 1.36 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 52.54 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 55.59 | 2.82 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 2.63 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 55.08 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.29 | 4.07 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 53.39 | 3.73 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 49.66 | 4.42 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 46.27 | 2.74 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 49.15 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.83 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 44.07 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 49.83 | 3.32 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 50.17 | 4.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 49.49 | 3.20 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.29 | 2.60 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 52.54 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.42 | 2.01 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 70.00 | 2.84 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 68.64 | 4.56 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.15 | 2.12 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 67.80 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 3.22 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 70.51 | 2.17 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.46 | 2.92 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 70.34 | 3.15 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.36 | 2.88 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.97 | 2.49 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 56.44 | 2.40 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 49.15 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 46.61 | 3.65 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 47.46 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 46.10 | 5.76 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 37.29 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 48.14 | 5.21 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 68.64 | 2.86 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.15 | 2.92 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 58.47 | 3.73 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 58.14 | 2.40 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.42 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.59 | 3.54 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.76 | 2.88 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 59.32 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 55.42 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.25 | 2.75 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 55.25 | 3.41 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 58.31 | 3.49 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 55.93 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.76 | 2.78 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.42 | 2.63 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 56.44 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 56.27 | 2.12 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 55.08 | 3.49 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 57.46 | 3.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 55.93 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 55.25 | 3.14 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 56.61 | 2.54 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 56.27 | 1.66 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 56.27 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 54.41 | 3.75 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 56.27 | 2.37 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.59 | 2.49 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 58.31 | 1.89 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 1.31 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.59 | 2.60 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 56.27 | 3.37 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.69 | 3.04 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 4.48 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.03 | 1.74 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.53 | 2.37 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 70.51 | 2.03 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.54 | 2.12 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.20 | 1.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 70.51 | 2.42 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.32 | 2.88 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 68.47 | 3.57 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 72.88 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 70.00 | 3.39 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.83 | 1.98 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 3.56 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 70.85 | 2.49 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |59.32|50.85|59.32|61.02|50.85|57.63|55.93|59.32|57.63|59.32|57.12|3.39| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |52.54|55.93|52.54|57.63|54.24|52.54|62.71|57.63|59.32|59.32|56.44|3.31| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |57.63|50.85|55.93|55.93|54.24|57.63|54.24|52.54|54.24|59.32|55.25|2.42| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |55.93|55.93|59.32|61.02|57.63|59.32|52.54|55.93|50.85|52.54|56.10|3.17| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |55.93|54.24|61.02|59.32|55.93|59.32|57.63|55.93|57.63|55.93|57.29|1.98| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |45.76|55.93|59.32|59.32|55.93|57.63|57.63|59.32|50.85|55.93|55.76|4.11| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |55.93|54.24|50.85|55.93|57.63|52.54|54.24|57.63|52.54|50.85|54.24|2.40| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |61.02|54.24|57.63|55.93|50.85|54.24|52.54|55.93|52.54|59.32|55.42|3.04| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |57.63|57.63|50.85|49.15|55.93|52.54|54.24|54.24|55.93|50.85|53.90|2.82| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |55.93|54.24|52.54|55.93|61.02|52.54|55.93|52.54|50.85|54.24|54.58|2.71| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |50.85|59.32|52.54|61.02|54.24|57.63|52.54|55.93|59.32|59.32|56.27|3.37| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |57.63|52.54|59.32|50.85|52.54|49.15|52.54|57.63|55.93|55.93|54.41|3.17| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |55.93|52.54|55.93|55.93|54.24|55.93|54.24|54.24|49.15|59.32|54.75|2.52| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |62.71|52.54|49.15|55.93|55.93|50.85|57.63|55.93|59.32|52.54|55.25|3.88| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |61.02|55.93|54.24|61.02|62.71|55.93|64.41|50.85|55.93|55.93|57.80|4.04| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |54.24|52.54|54.24|62.71|61.02|54.24|55.93|49.15|52.54|50.85|54.75|4.01| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |55.93|55.93|49.15|54.24|55.93|59.32|54.24|54.24|49.15|50.85|53.90|3.11| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |50.85|59.32|50.85|55.93|52.54|57.63|50.85|50.85|55.93|55.93|54.07|3.07| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |50.85|52.54|62.71|50.85|52.54|57.63|55.93|54.24|54.24|57.63|54.92|3.49| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |55.93|61.02|57.63|54.24|50.85|54.24|57.63|57.63|54.24|50.85|55.42|3.04| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |59.32|54.24|50.85|54.24|54.24|59.32|54.24|61.02|57.63|59.32|56.44|3.13|
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 68.14 | 1.83 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.97 | 1.19 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 70.68 | 3.39 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 70.68 | 2.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 3.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 70.85 | 2.49 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 70.34 | 2.04 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.37 | 2.63 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.66 | 4.78 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.83 | 5.09 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 67.80 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.92 | 3.64 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 69.49 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 63.73 | 4.10 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.92 | 4.22 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 65.93 | 4.45 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 68.81 | 2.54 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 70.17 | 2.17 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 85.08 | 1.83 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.41 | 2.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 84.75 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 83.73 | 2.17 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 89.83 | 77.97 | 81.69 | 3.77 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 82.71 | 4.07 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 83.73 | 3.23 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 87.12 | 1.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 86.78 | 2.49 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.32 | 3.59 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 68.14 | 4.41 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 3.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.36 | 2.92 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.53 | 2.40 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 84.24 | 2.84 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 91.53 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 3.87 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.69 | 2.40 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 70.51 | 2.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 74.07 | 2.52 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.69 | 3.39 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 71.69 | 2.74 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.03 | 2.54 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.86 | 1.73 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 79.66 | 72.54 | 3.85 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.37 | 3.13 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 73.05 | 3.17 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.02 | 2.33 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 3.47 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.86 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 70.51 | 4.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 64.41 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 70.51 | 3.23 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.15 | 2.71 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 68.81 | 2.30 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.36 | 3.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 69.83 | 3.46 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.36 | 3.67 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 79.66 | 70.17 | 3.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 70.51 | 2.96 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 70.34 | 2.65 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 68.81 | 2.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.15 | 3.20 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.95 | 2.15 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 86.10 | 1.98 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 88.14 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 1.69 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 89.83 | 86.61 | 1.60 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 85.93 | 2.01 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 85.76 | 2.30 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 86.44 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 86.10 | 1.27 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.41 | 2.12 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 1.69 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 91.53 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 89.83 | 88.14 | 87.46 | 2.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 87.46 | 1.36 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 88.14 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 86.44 | 86.78 | 3.20 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 91.53 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.95 | 2.15 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 89.83 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 86.78 | 2.37 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |72.88|69.49|67.80|67.80|69.49|71.19|72.88|69.49|71.19|69.49|70.17|1.73| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |66.10|76.27|67.80|67.80|67.80|76.27|67.80|72.88|69.49|72.88|70.51|3.57| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |64.41|72.88|67.80|66.10|61.02|67.80|69.49|67.80|66.10|67.80|67.12|2.96| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |59.32|72.88|76.27|69.49|71.19|72.88|62.71|71.19|61.02|71.19|68.81|5.42| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |67.80|67.80|69.49|67.80|69.49|69.49|71.19|69.49|69.49|71.19|69.32|1.19| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |69.49|69.49|69.49|69.49|74.58|67.80|67.80|69.49|67.80|72.88|69.83|2.12| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |71.19|67.80|74.58|67.80|69.49|72.88|69.49|74.58|71.19|76.27|71.53|2.82| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |64.41|71.19|67.80|72.88|69.49|69.49|67.80|67.80|66.10|71.19|68.81|2.42| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |67.80|66.10|69.49|67.80|67.80|67.80|69.49|64.41|67.80|66.10|67.46|1.48| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |69.49|72.88|69.49|71.19|67.80|66.10|66.10|69.49|71.19|72.88|69.66|2.33| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |71.19|72.88|66.10|61.02|66.10|71.19|64.41|77.97|71.19|72.88|69.49|4.73| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |67.80|66.10|61.02|67.80|67.80|64.41|62.71|69.49|69.49|67.80|66.44|2.71| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |66.10|69.49|67.80|66.10|71.19|62.71|67.80|71.19|67.80|72.88|68.31|2.84| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |71.19|57.63|69.49|71.19|72.88|76.27|71.19|64.41|76.27|67.80|69.83|5.30| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|72.88|69.49|76.27|69.49|76.27|71.19|67.80|69.49|67.80|70.85|3.11| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |71.19|67.80|66.10|71.19|71.19|67.80|69.49|67.80|71.19|67.80|69.15|1.83| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |69.49|67.80|66.10|71.19|67.80|69.49|69.49|67.80|66.10|64.41|67.97|1.93| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |69.49|69.49|72.88|69.49|64.41|71.19|67.80|67.80|74.58|66.10|69.32|2.88| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |71.19|74.58|66.10|71.19|71.19|74.58|69.49|74.58|71.19|71.19|71.53|2.49| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |69.49|61.02|71.19|72.88|67.80|69.49|69.49|67.80|64.41|62.71|67.63|3.59| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |71.19|66.10|67.80|71.19|67.80|71.19|69.49|62.71|69.49|71.19|68.81|2.65|
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 49.15 | 57.29 | 3.46 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 55.76 | 3.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 57.63 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 56.95 | 2.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 54.24 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.12 | 2.84 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 58.14 | 2.84 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 58.64 | 4.17 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 54.24 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.29 | 4.60 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 51.02 | 4.45 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 49.66 | 2.15 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 53.05 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 54.24 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 53.05 | 3.87 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 52.88 | 4.21 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 56.61 | 2.65 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 52.54 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 4.29 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.92 | 2.71 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 73.56 | 2.65 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 72.88 | 71.19 | 59.32 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 70.51 | 5.73 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 70.51 | 3.05 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 70.17 | 5.04 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 75.42 | 2.65 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 73.56 | 1.73 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.88 | 4.51 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 60.85 | 5.44 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 54.24 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 49.32 | 5.44 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 50.85 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 50.00 | 5.43 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.71 | 1.93 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.71 | 3.17 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 58.81 | 3.39 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 58.98 | 3.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 58.14 | 2.52 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.83 | 3.04 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 56.95 | 3.81 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 55.93 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 56.61 | 2.03 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 58.64 | 2.75 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 60.00 | 3.49 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 54.24 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.46 | 2.78 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 5.08 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 55.42 | 5.20 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 60.00 | 2.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 56.44 | 5.31 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 60.34 | 2.96 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 61.02 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 57.97 | 3.70 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 58.14 | 2.63 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 58.98 | 3.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 57.12 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 55.59 | 2.25 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.46 | 3.26 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 55.93 | 59.49 | 4.38 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 54.24 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 2.63 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.76 | 2.45 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 54.92 | 3.73 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.44 | 2.88 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 75.76 | 3.22 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 76.27 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 74.24 | 2.25 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 3.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 77.46 | 2.74 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.24 | 2.25 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 2.94 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 3.56 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 72.88 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 75.59 | 3.05 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 73.90 | 3.14 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 73.73 | 2.54 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 75.76 | 2.63 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |57.63|61.02|57.63|52.54|59.32|61.02|59.32|59.32|66.10|61.02|59.49|3.26| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |55.93|62.71|55.93|62.71|52.54|62.71|55.93|64.41|52.54|64.41|58.98|4.60| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |52.54|57.63|59.32|57.63|52.54|67.80|66.10|54.24|52.54|55.93|57.63|5.20| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |57.63|55.93|64.41|50.85|54.24|66.10|54.24|59.32|50.85|61.02|57.46|5.00| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |57.63|67.80|57.63|57.63|55.93|57.63|55.93|61.02|52.54|54.24|57.80|3.97| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |57.63|57.63|55.93|62.71|57.63|59.32|54.24|52.54|49.15|54.24|56.10|3.59| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |54.24|50.85|54.24|59.32|54.24|59.32|57.63|62.71|54.24|57.63|56.44|3.31| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |55.93|57.63|54.24|66.10|59.32|59.32|61.02|62.71|61.02|62.71|60.00|3.32| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |52.54|57.63|55.93|55.93|55.93|61.02|64.41|59.32|52.54|52.54|56.78|3.73| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |67.80|62.71|50.85|59.32|55.93|54.24|54.24|55.93|54.24|54.24|56.95|4.75| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |49.15|55.93|55.93|61.02|54.24|52.54|54.24|57.63|57.63|52.54|55.08|3.15| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |50.85|47.46|55.93|61.02|55.93|54.24|62.71|54.24|61.02|52.54|55.59|4.60| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |50.85|55.93|55.93|61.02|54.24|59.32|55.93|64.41|59.32|61.02|57.80|3.75| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |49.15|57.63|59.32|50.85|55.93|54.24|57.63|57.63|61.02|54.24|55.76|3.51| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |54.24|59.32|54.24|52.54|52.54|66.10|64.41|52.54|52.54|49.15|55.76|5.33| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |61.02|61.02|62.71|54.24|57.63|55.93|55.93|55.93|57.63|64.41|58.64|3.23| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |62.71|52.54|50.85|64.41|61.02|55.93|59.32|57.63|62.71|61.02|58.81|4.29| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |55.93|52.54|52.54|59.32|62.71|61.02|54.24|52.54|54.24|57.63|56.27|3.54| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |55.93|57.63|57.63|57.63|57.63|55.93|57.63|52.54|59.32|55.93|56.78|1.74| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |57.63|55.93|55.93|59.32|57.63|61.02|55.93|57.63|55.93|59.32|57.63|1.69| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |57.63|54.24|57.63|54.24|59.32|57.63|61.02|57.63|59.32|54.24|57.29|2.25|
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 42.88 | 4.09 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 33.90 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 37.29 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 4.79 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 38.98 | 35.59 | 33.90 | 42.37 | 28.81 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 42.37 | 38.81 | 4.76 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 37.29 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 35.59 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 5.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 28.81 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 39.49 | 5.25 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 4.73 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 45.76 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 42.88 | 4.55 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 35.59 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 30.51 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 35.76 | 4.76 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 25.42 | 27.12 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 34.24 | 4.78 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 35.59 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 37.29 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 32.20 | 38.98 | 36.27 | 3.57 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 37.29 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 28.81 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 25.42 | 37.29 | 35.76 | 5.38 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 35.59 | 45.76 | 37.29 | 38.98 | 30.51 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 27.12 | 37.29 | 36.95 | 4.90 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 35.59 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 37.29 | 42.37 | 33.90 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 43.73 | 6.69 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 38.98 | 40.68 | 30.51 | 42.37 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 33.90 | 44.07 | 40.17 | 4.92 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 3.79 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 47.29 | 2.33 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 47.46 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 47.63 | 3.17 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 50.85 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 46.61 | 4.30 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.49 | 3.29 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 4.29 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 52.54 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.71 | 2.98 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 35.59 | 45.76 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 4.42 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 39.32 | 2.37 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 27.12 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 37.29 | 23.73 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 33.39 | 4.49 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 32.20 | 35.59 | 40.68 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 32.20 | 30.51 | 35.59 | 32.20 | 33.90 | 2.73 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 50.00 | 4.75 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 52.54 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 4.35 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 4.91 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 48.31 | 6.08 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 28.81 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 55.93 | 42.88 | 7.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 57.63 | 43.22 | 5.88 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 45.76 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 44.58 | 1.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 45.76 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 3.47 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 28.81 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 44.58 | 5.73 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 51.02 | 4.70 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 45.76 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 45.25 | 4.42 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 45.59 | 3.75 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 37.29 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 4.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 55.93 | 37.29 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 37.29 | 45.08 | 6.44 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 45.42 | 3.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 45.59 | 6.41 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 42.37 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 38.98 | 59.32 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 45.93 | 7.41 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 32.20 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 45.25 | 6.95 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 37.29 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 33.90 | 49.15 | 35.59 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 44.58 | 8.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 33.90 | 47.46 | 33.90 | 37.29 | 38.98 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 37.29 | 35.59 | 49.15 | 40.34 | 5.46 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 35.59 | 42.37 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 33.90 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 5.67 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 32.20 | 45.76 | 32.20 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 47.46 | 40.51 | 5.05 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 48.47 | 4.62 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 35.59 | 42.37 | 23.73 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 42.88 | 8.37 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 44.92 | 3.15 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 40.68 | 47.46 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 38.98 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 43.56 | 4.42 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 52.20 | 3.62 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 51.19 | 3.37 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 52.54 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 53.56 | 3.32 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 54.41 | 2.98 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.75 | 4.09 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 55.93 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.92 | 3.41 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 3.56 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 53.05 | 4.97 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 55.93 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 52.03 | 4.16 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 53.90 | 3.29 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 53.22 | 4.03 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 54.92 | 4.23 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |38.98|50.85|55.93|54.24|40.68|44.07|45.76|44.07|52.54|52.54|47.97|5.67| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |44.07|47.46|45.76|52.54|45.76|44.07|49.15|47.46|45.76|52.54|47.46|2.94| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |42.37|42.37|44.07|38.98|42.37|47.46|45.76|40.68|40.68|44.07|42.88|2.40| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |44.07|45.76|44.07|40.68|50.85|47.46|49.15|45.76|35.59|40.68|44.41|4.27| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |49.15|50.85|44.07|45.76|38.98|45.76|47.46|40.68|45.76|38.98|44.75|3.88| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |40.68|42.37|40.68|42.37|44.07|40.68|47.46|42.37|44.07|49.15|43.39|2.75| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |47.46|44.07|45.76|44.07|50.85|40.68|42.37|49.15|44.07|38.98|44.75|3.49| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |42.37|44.07|30.51|47.46|38.98|45.76|44.07|45.76|40.68|40.68|42.03|4.60| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |52.54|45.76|49.15|42.37|47.46|47.46|38.98|44.07|44.07|47.46|45.93|3.59| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |44.07|38.98|37.29|54.24|40.68|44.07|42.37|40.68|42.37|47.46|43.22|4.56| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |52.54|37.29|38.98|45.76|52.54|49.15|38.98|37.29|38.98|44.07|43.56|5.82| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |54.24|37.29|49.15|44.07|38.98|42.37|44.07|44.07|42.37|49.15|44.58|4.80| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |44.07|42.37|38.98|40.68|42.37|47.46|38.98|42.37|52.54|45.76|43.56|3.94| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |38.98|54.24|47.46|52.54|52.54|37.29|42.37|55.93|44.07|47.46|47.29|6.18| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |42.37|45.76|44.07|45.76|42.37|38.98|52.54|37.29|38.98|40.68|42.88|4.22| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |37.29|40.68|52.54|40.68|49.15|44.07|45.76|37.29|45.76|40.68|43.39|4.75| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |44.07|44.07|38.98|40.68|44.07|42.37|45.76|40.68|49.15|45.76|43.56|2.84| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |38.98|38.98|44.07|49.15|40.68|52.54|52.54|44.07|35.59|45.76|44.24|5.54| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |42.37|45.76|50.85|45.76|45.76|47.46|38.98|44.07|35.59|42.37|43.90|4.11| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |40.68|40.68|42.37|37.29|37.29|37.29|42.37|37.29|44.07|40.68|40.00|2.42| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |49.15|37.29|50.85|45.76|35.59|52.54|49.15|54.24|45.76|45.76|46.61|5.79|
- Epoch 30
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.12 | 3.14 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.92 | 2.40 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-WRONG | 72.88 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 66.44 | 3.46 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 72.88 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 79.66 | 65.59 | 6.82 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 66.44 | 2.92 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.53 | 2.71 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 70.17 | 2.96 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 54.07 | 5.11 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 53.22 | 4.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG | 50.85 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 55.42 | 4.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 55.93 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 55.08 | 4.44 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 56.95 | 4.23 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 65.76 | 2.92 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 72.88 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 65.76 | 4.47 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 76.27 | 81.86 | 2.15 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 81.19 | 1.77 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 84.75 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 76.27 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 79.32 | 3.70 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.63 | 4.96 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 79.32 | 2.92 |
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 82.54 | 1.86 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 81.36 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.22 | 3.17 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.07 | 3.29 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.03 | 2.65 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 61.02 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 57.46 | 3.17 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 56.61 | 4.81 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 79.83 | 2.88 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 86.44 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 89.83 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 81.36 | 82.71 | 4.66 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 71.53 | 2.92 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.36 | 2.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 70.51 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 71.02 | 5.05 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 54.24 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.97 | 5.54 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 68.14 | 3.77 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 81.36 | 73.05 | 4.04 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs4-ep100 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 73.56 | 4.62 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.37 | 4.49 |
FrozenEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.66 | 4.51 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 81.36 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 68.31 | 5.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 61.02 | 72.88 | 59.32 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.97 | 4.76 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 71.36 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.15 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 68.98 | 3.94 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 68.14 | 3.11 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 68.47 | 2.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.97 | 3.75 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 66.27 | 4.11 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.61 | 4.29 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 70.68 | 2.63 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 68.98 | 2.84 |
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 65.25 | 3.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | ||||||||||||
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 57.63 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 64.24 | 3.82 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs4 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 84.75 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 1.69 |
RoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 83.56 | 3.22 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4-WRONG | 86.44 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 77.97 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 86.44 | 77.97 | 86.44 | 83.05 | 83.56 | 3.56 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 84.24 | 2.94 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs4+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 88.14 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 83.90 | 2.54 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100-WRONG | 86.44 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 79.66 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 89.83 | 84.75 | 86.44 | 84.75 | 84.92 | 2.98 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs4-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
RoBERTa-bs16 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 80.00 | 2.12 |
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 84.75 | 79.66 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 81.36 | 83.05 | 79.49 | 3.26 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG | 86.44 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 89.83 | 79.66 | 84.75 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 83.22 | 3.75 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG | 77.97 | 81.36 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 83.05 | 88.14 | 83.05 | 82.37 | 3.41 |
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3-WRONG | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | 84.75 | 84.75 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 79.66 | 81.36 | 77.97 | 81.53 | 2.20 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG | 84.75 | 79.66 | 83.05 | 77.97 | 81.36 | 91.53 | 81.36 | 86.44 | 89.83 | 83.05 | 83.90 | 4.10 |
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 | ||||||||||||
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | BERT-bs8 |71.19|74.58|72.88|74.58|66.10|61.02|74.58|69.49|72.88|71.19|70.85|4.14| | BERTwithAtt-bs8 |72.88|64.41|69.49|72.88|66.10|72.88|66.10|64.41|69.49|71.19|68.98|3.31| | BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 |54.24|59.32|62.71|55.93|66.10|72.88|64.41|57.63|62.71|61.02|61.69|5.15| | BERTwithProjection-bs8 |55.93|62.71|72.88|64.41|71.19|71.19|55.93|66.10|64.41|64.41|64.92|5.57| | BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 |64.41|77.97|64.41|72.88|69.49|74.58|64.41|67.80|69.49|61.02|68.64|5.04| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8 |69.49|66.10|69.49|66.10|66.10|69.49|74.58|69.49|72.88|71.19|69.49|2.73| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights |67.80|57.63|72.88|64.41|67.80|67.80|66.10|74.58|61.02|77.97|67.80|5.82| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 |62.71|66.10|67.80|67.80|59.32|71.19|66.10|67.80|67.80|69.49|66.61|3.22| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw |55.93|62.71|67.80|67.80|64.41|67.80|62.71|59.32|62.71|64.41|63.56|3.65| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 |69.49|64.41|69.49|71.19|61.02|61.02|72.88|59.32|61.02|47.46|63.73|7.16| | EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw |72.88|66.10|62.71|57.63|57.63|64.41|69.49|69.49|66.10|66.10|65.25|4.69| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 |66.10|61.02|62.71|62.71|61.02|66.10|62.71|61.02|64.41|66.10|63.39|2.03| | EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw |61.02|67.80|67.80|55.93|55.93|66.10|66.10|64.41|67.80|67.80|64.07|4.54| | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |59.32|64.41|62.71|62.71|71.19|66.10|69.49|59.32|64.41|64.41|64.41|3.64| | EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |66.10|69.49|67.80|61.02|67.80|76.27|71.19|69.49|69.49|72.88|69.15|3.85| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |66.10|57.63|69.49|64.41|71.19|61.02|71.19|61.02|69.49|67.80|65.93|4.51| | EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |67.80|66.10|57.63|67.80|64.41|64.41|62.71|62.71|62.71|62.71|63.90|2.84| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |67.80|59.32|66.10|62.71|61.02|69.49|61.02|71.19|64.41|72.88|65.59|4.42| | EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |61.02|72.88|64.41|69.49|67.80|64.41|64.41|66.10|69.49|66.10|66.61|3.22| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery |59.32|47.46|67.80|64.41|62.71|67.80|66.10|71.19|67.80|62.71|63.73|6.31| | EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw |66.10|66.10|66.10|59.32|61.02|72.88|64.41|59.32|66.10|69.49|65.08|4.10|
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.07 | 2.37 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 65.25 | 2.43 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.54 | 2.88 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 63.90 | 2.63 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.92 | 2.52 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 66.10 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 65.08 | 3.23 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 3.03 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 4.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 60.68 | 5.19 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 62.03 | 3.73 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 58.81 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.53 | 3.48 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 63.56 | 4.10 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 64.92 | 2.15 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.92 | 1.32 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.54 | 2.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 63.56 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.49 | 2.45 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 59.49 | 3.90 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 60.17 | 3.24 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 58.81 | 3.31 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 60.68 | 3.29 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.24 | 2.88 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 63.90 | 2.01 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 65.25 | 3.49 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 63.22 | 4.61 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 64.92 | 2.84 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 64.92 | 2.40 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 63.22 | 2.28 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 65.93 | 3.67 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 65.25 | 2.65 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 50.85 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 61.86 | 5.21 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 67.80 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.88 | 3.97 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 65.42 | 2.30 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 64.75 | 3.29 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 16.95 | 10.17 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 27.12 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 51.53 | 22.26 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 64.41 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.58 | 2.33 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 67.80 | 67.80 | 8.47 | 66.10 | 11.86 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 1.69 | 48.81 | 27.26 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 69.49 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 65.42 | 2.96 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 28.81 | 67.80 | 15.25 | 15.25 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 15.25 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 67.80 | 36.95 | 23.50 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 62.71 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.07 | 2.49 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 72.88 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 6.78 | 32.20 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 11.86 | 61.02 | 20.34 | 48.14 | 25.71 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 62.71 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.58 | 2.78 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 45.76 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 57.46 | 6.04 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 57.97 | 3.37 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 59.32 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 56.95 | 3.05 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 57.29 | 2.49 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 57.63 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 56.61 | 3.05 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 59.32 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 56.27 | 3.20 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 2.84 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 55.76 | 2.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 56.44 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 54.24 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 55.59 | 4.47 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 49.15 | 64.41 | 56.44 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 54.92 | 5.37 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 54.24 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 55.42 | 2.94 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.97 | 3.37 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 56.27 | 2.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 53.73 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 55.59 | 2.92 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 54.75 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.59 | 2.60 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 56.44 | 3.22 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 55.08 | 3.15 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 56.27 | 4.07 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.12 | 2.94 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 54.24 | 66.10 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 58.47 | 3.65 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 59.15 | 2.20 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 66.10 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 4.91 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 57.46 | 2.98 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 54.75 | 2.28 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 57.63 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 55.76 | 4.11 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 59.49 | 2.98 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 55.93 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 58.14 | 2.52 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 55.76 | 4.82 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 52.54 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 54.75 | 3.72 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 59.32 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.12 | 1.86 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 50.85 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 56.95 | 3.65 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 20.34 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 15.25 | 20.34 | 52.54 | 18.64 | 40.00 | 17.60 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 59.32 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 55.42 | 5.09 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 57.63 | 57.63 | 8.47 | 6.78 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 28.81 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 8.47 | 40.85 | 23.43 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 58.64 | 1.89 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 13.56 | 10.17 | 52.54 | 18.64 | 54.24 | 20.34 | 8.47 | 49.15 | 15.25 | 61.02 | 30.34 | 19.97 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 61.02 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 13.56 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 27.12 | 10.17 | 20.34 | 57.63 | 42.37 | 20.51 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 59.32 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.49 | 3.07 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 73.05 | 2.56 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 79.66 | 72.71 | 3.75 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.03 | 3.24 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 73.22 | 3.46 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 74.58 | 79.66 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.20 | 3.88 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 71.19 | 64.41 | 81.36 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 72.71 | 4.18 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.69 | 2.15 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 64.41 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 70.85 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 72.54 | 4.21 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 71.36 | 3.51 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 76.27 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.54 | 2.49 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.03 | 3.33 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 2.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.02 | 3.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.86 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 2.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 68.81 | 2.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.83 | 4.14 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.66 | 1.77 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 70.34 | 3.24 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 71.36 | 2.78 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.03 | 4.37 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.53 | 1.83 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 61.02 | 69.49 | 81.36 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 68.81 | 5.32 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.71 | 3.07 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.20 | 2.86 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 70.34 | 3.24 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.02 | 2.33 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 2.14 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 68.98 | 2.74 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 76.27 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.20 | 2.75 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 67.97 | 1.93 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 70.17 | 3.05 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 69.49 | 13.56 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 10.17 | 18.64 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 52.88 | 25.51 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.69 | 1.32 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 13.56 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 67.80 | 28.81 | 5.08 | 71.19 | 1.69 | 47.12 | 29.26 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 70.00 | 2.52 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 69.49 | 10.17 | 76.27 | 16.95 | 8.47 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 16.95 | 18.64 | 42.37 | 28.37 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 74.58 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 71.53 | 3.11 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 71.19 | 67.80 | 22.03 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 3.39 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 27.12 | 11.86 | 48.64 | 27.24 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 70.85 | 2.25 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 62.20 | 5.25 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 62.54 | 4.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 62.03 | 3.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 61.19 | 3.82 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 62.54 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 67.80 | 47.46 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 61.53 | 6.11 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 56.10 | 3.34 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 50.85 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 57.12 | 4.09 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 55.59 | 5.24 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 57.46 | 2.67 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 47.46 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 56.27 | 4.96 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 60.17 | 4.44 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.20 | 2.01 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 61.19 | 3.75 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 60.85 | 2.98 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 60.68 | 2.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 62.88 | 3.43 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 54.75 | 3.79 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.76 | 2.45 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.15 | 4.38 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 54.58 | 4.21 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 58.14 | 4.68 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 60.68 | 2.37 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.07 | 4.14 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 62.03 | 3.88 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 54.24 | 61.02 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 61.86 | 4.69 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.37 | 3.92 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 67.80 | 55.93 | 55.93 | 59.32 | 57.63 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 61.19 | 4.11 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 55.93 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 60.00 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 57.63 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.37 | 2.71 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.54 | 2.07 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.86 | 1.89 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 64.41 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 61.02 | 3.79 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 57.63 | 61.02 | 2.40 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 55.93 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 62.54 | 4.04 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 16.95 | 64.41 | 20.34 | 15.25 | 23.73 | 59.32 | 55.93 | 43.39 | 20.07 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 61.02 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 62.71 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 62.03 | 2.75 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 62.71 | 62.71 | 11.86 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 15.25 | 62.71 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 53.56 | 20.13 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 64.41 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 63.56 | 1.56 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 11.86 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 54.24 | 15.25 | 18.64 | 64.41 | 13.56 | 43.22 | 23.43 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.07 | 2.49 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 59.32 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 57.63 | 59.32 | 61.02 | 28.81 | 59.32 | 28.81 | 64.41 | 54.24 | 12.89 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 62.71 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 54.24 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 63.05 | 4.07 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 57.63 | 57.63 | 52.54 | 53.56 | 2.86 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 50.85 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 53.22 | 3.73 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 48.47 | 3.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 37.29 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 61.02 | 38.98 | 50.85 | 45.59 | 6.76 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 45.76 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 49.83 | 4.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 52.54 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 51.02 | 3.82 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 37.29 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 45.08 | 3.95 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 40.68 | 37.29 | 40.68 | 52.54 | 45.42 | 5.66 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 47.46 | 37.29 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 4.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 33.90 | 38.98 | 43.90 | 5.33 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 46.10 | 3.37 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 47.63 | 4.18 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 45.76 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 52.54 | 57.63 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 49.83 | 5.68 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 64.41 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 4.42 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 55.93 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 51.36 | 3.72 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 55.93 | 33.90 | 52.54 | 45.25 | 6.07 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 49.15 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 32.20 | 49.15 | 46.27 | 6.34 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 57.63 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 33.90 | 44.07 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 44.24 | 6.09 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 44.92 | 3.15 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 44.07 | 32.20 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 35.59 | 47.46 | 33.90 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 41.36 | 5.26 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 38.98 | 40.68 | 42.37 | 40.68 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 3.47 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 44.07 | 32.20 | 44.07 | 44.07 | 35.59 | 50.85 | 33.90 | 35.59 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 40.51 | 5.59 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 42.37 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 54.24 | 50.51 | 4.90 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 44.07 | 59.32 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 54.24 | 47.46 | 52.54 | 62.71 | 52.54 | 50.85 | 52.54 | 5.08 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 49.15 | 3.39 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 50.85 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 49.49 | 4.66 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 40.68 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 54.24 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 42.37 | 50.17 | 5.88 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 54.24 | 42.37 | 49.15 | 46.95 | 4.29 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 47.46 | 38.98 | 45.76 | 42.37 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 40.68 | 44.07 | 45.42 | 3.77 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 55.93 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 3.56 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 52.54 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.46 | 48.81 | 2.25 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 48.14 | 2.96 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 49.15 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 47.46 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 47.46 | 50.51 | 3.77 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 50.85 | 38.98 | 54.24 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 47.97 | 4.22 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 44.07 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 40.68 | 50.85 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 48.14 | 4.23 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 20.34 | 50.85 | 18.64 | 49.15 | 18.64 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 44.07 | 39.15 | 13.29 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 40.68 | 45.76 | 49.15 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 44.07 | 49.15 | 49.15 | 59.32 | 47.46 | 48.31 | 4.63 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 18.64 | 11.86 | 10.17 | 49.15 | 44.07 | 10.17 | 54.24 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 50.85 | 33.90 | 17.68 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 49.15 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 42.37 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 49.15 | 47.80 | 3.46 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 52.54 | 44.07 | 13.56 | 18.64 | 1.69 | 55.93 | 45.76 | 16.95 | 25.42 | 10.17 | 28.47 | 18.41 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 52.54 | 45.76 | 40.68 | 49.15 | 55.93 | 57.63 | 54.24 | 50.85 | 45.76 | 57.63 | 51.02 | 5.38 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 47.46 | 50.85 | 42.37 | 42.37 | 52.54 | 47.46 | 45.76 | 45.76 | 47.46 | 50.85 | 47.29 | 3.26 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 50.85 | 49.15 | 52.54 | 49.15 | 45.76 | 52.54 | 44.07 | 52.54 | 52.54 | 54.24 | 50.34 | 3.13 |
- Epoch 100
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs4 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 73.39 | 1.86 |
BERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 79.66 | 79.66 | 74.92 | 3.01 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4 | 76.27 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.69 | 3.79 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.37 | 2.74 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_selfatt | 77.97 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 3.94 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_att_clsquery_weights | 72.88 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 73.90 | 3.57 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ0 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 62.71 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.53 | 4.14 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 57.63 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 68.14 | 5.19 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 81.36 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 68.31 | 5.25 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 70.17 | 3.23 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 79.66 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 68.47 | 5.42 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 69.15 | 3.92 |
EmbraceBERT-bs4-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 79.66 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 76.27 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 77.97 | 77.97 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 3.79 |
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
BERT-bs16 | 76.27 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.54 | 2.25 |
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 77.97 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 73.05 | 2.07 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.36 | 3.17 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 77.97 | 72.20 | 2.65 |
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 | ||||||||||||
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 | ||||||||||||
----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 61.02 | 67.80 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 66.10 | 66.10 | 64.07 | 4.47 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ3+Dropout0.1 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 64.41 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 65.25 | 3.65 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertquery_epQ10 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.46 | 4.27 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ3 | 62.71 | 55.93 | 72.88 | 61.02 | 64.41 | 64.41 | 55.93 | 61.02 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 62.88 | 4.70 |
EmbraceBERT-bs16-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyVal_epQ10 | 61.02 | 71.19 | 61.02 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 59.32 | 64.41 | 72.88 | 65.25 | 4.37 |
- Epoch 100 - bs8
Model | Run1 | Run2 | Run3 | Run4 | Run5 | Run6 | Run7 | Run8 | Run9 | Run10 | Mean | Std |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERT-bs8 | 77.97 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 73.39 | 2.40 |
BERTwithAtt-bs8 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 70.00 | 2.28 |
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs8 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 66.95 | 3.73 |
BERTwithProjection-bs8 | 59.32 | 62.71 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 61.02 | 74.58 | 59.32 | 71.19 | 67.46 | 6.24 |
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs8 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 70.51 | 3.49 |
--------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8 | 76.27 | 67.80 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 3.47 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_att_clsquery_weights | 69.49 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.86 | 2.17 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.69 | 2.28 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_attclsqw | 74.58 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 70.68 | 2.63 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 59.32 | 69.49 | 69.49 | 77.97 | 67.80 | 70.17 | 4.62 |
EBERTconcatAtt-bs8_attclsqw | 76.27 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 64.41 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 69.32 | 3.59 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8 | 69.49 | 66.10 | 64.41 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 62.71 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 67.80 | 67.63 | 2.88 |
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs8_attclsqw | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 71.19 | 71.53 | 1.66 |
------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 25.42 | 11.86 | 16.95 | 66.10 | 11.86 | 74.58 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 62.71 | 48.64 | 26.68 |
EmbraceBERT-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 77.97 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 76.27 | 69.49 | 73.56 | 2.54 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 72.88 | 64.41 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 74.58 | 66.10 | 72.88 | 67.80 | 70.00 | 3.13 |
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 69.49 | 71.19 | 66.10 | 71.19 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 74.58 | 71.36 | 2.45 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 71.19 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 71.19 | 10.17 | 28.81 | 64.41 | 22.03 | 20.34 | 71.19 | 50.34 | 24.95 |
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 72.88 | 76.27 | 72.88 | 71.19 | 79.66 | 76.27 | 62.71 | 67.80 | 69.49 | 74.58 | 72.37 | 4.61 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery | 72.88 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 71.19 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 74.58 | 69.49 | 67.80 | 72.88 | 71.36 | 2.33 |
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs8-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw | 69.49 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 66.10 | 67.80 | 71.19 | 72.88 | 69.49 | 72.88 | 72.88 | 70.68 | 2.28 |