Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
1856 lines (1777 loc) · 188 KB

snips.md

File metadata and controls

1856 lines (1777 loc) · 188 KB

Results

Train/Test with CompleteTest with IncompleteTrain/Test with Incomplete

Complete

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
EmbraceBERT-bs4+Dropout0.1 98.71 99.00 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.73 0.17
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs16 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.86 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.81 0.13
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 99.00 98.80 0.16
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.29 98.86 98.86 98.73 0.21
EmbraceBERT-bs16 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.67 0.18
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.71 99.14 98.86 98.79 0.17
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.29 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.71 0.23
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.76 0.13
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.71 98.14 99.00 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.71 0.25
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.86 98.00 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.29 98.56 0.26
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 99.00 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.60 0.18
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 98.86 97.71 99.14 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.14 98.57 0.38
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 98.57 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.71 98.60 0.18
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 99.00 98.71 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.29 98.43 98.59 0.24
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 99.00 99.14 98.86 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.67 0.31
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Branches 98.86 99.14 98.43 99.00 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.00 98.70 0.32
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.57 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.83 0.15
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.43 98.86 99.00 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.73 0.21
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 99.00 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.43 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.77 0.19
EmbraceBERT-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.73 0.10
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.43 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.14 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.70 0.26
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 99.14 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.81 0.20
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 98.86 99.14 98.71 99.00 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.84 0.16
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 99.00 99.57 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.86 98.86 99.14 98.43 97.71 98.73 0.48
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.29 98.71 0.18
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 99.00 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.43 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.83 0.17
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.56 0.16
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Branches
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 98.86 99.14 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.77 0.15
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 99.00 99.43 98.57 98.14 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.14 98.57 99.14 98.67 0.39
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.86 99.29 98.86 99.00 98.57 99.14 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.80 0.29
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.89 0.14
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 99.00 98.86 98.71 99.14 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.84 0.19
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 99.57 99.14 98.86 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.89 0.28
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 98.71 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.43 98.86 99.00 98.57 99.00 99.00 98.81 0.19
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.43 99.29 98.57 99.14 98.71 98.86 99.14 98.86 99.43 98.91 0.31
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.43 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.57 99.00 98.71 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.80 0.18
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.86 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.14 99.14 98.71 98.97 0.12
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.71 98.71 99.00 99.71 98.57 98.86 99.14 98.86 98.86 98.90 0.32
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.71 99.29 98.86 98.86 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.70 0.24
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 98.29 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.57 99.14 98.86 98.86 98.14 98.57 98.71 0.30
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 97.86 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.70 0.30
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 98.86 99.57 98.57 98.71 99.00 98.71 98.43 99.00 98.71 98.14 98.77 0.36
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.14 99.14 98.86 99.00 99.14 99.00 98.86 99.01 0.10
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.86 99.00 98.14 99.29 98.57 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.83 0.29
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 99.43 99.14 98.57 99.14 99.00 99.00 99.29 98.71 99.00 98.86 99.01 0.24
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 99.00 99.14 98.86 99.00 99.00 98.91 0.11
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.86 99.00 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.57 99.14 99.00 98.84 0.19
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 99.14 98.86 99.00 98.86 98.86 99.00 99.14 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.97 0.11
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 99.14 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.00 99.57 99.00 98.86 99.00 98.86 99.04 0.19
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.86 99.00 98.86 98.43 99.14 99.00 98.86 99.29 99.00 99.71 99.01 0.32
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 99.00 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.71 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.80 0.17
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 99.14 99.00 98.57 98.71 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.71 98.79 0.25
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.66 0.17
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Branches
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 98.86 98.71 98.43 99.00 99.29 98.86 99.00 99.00 98.86 99.00 98.90 0.21
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Branches
  • Epoch 30
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.80 0.11
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 99.00 98.71 99.00 98.86 99.00 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.80 0.15
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.87 0.04
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 99.00 98.71 99.00 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.57 99.14 98.86 0.17
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.86 98.57 99.14 99.00 98.86 0.19
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 99.14 98.86 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 0.17
  • Epoch 100 - BERT
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
LOCAL - BERT-bs32 99.00 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.67 0.16
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LOCAL - BERTwithAtt-bs32 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.86 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.80 0.13
LOCAL - BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.64 0.13
LOCAL - BERTwithProjection-bs32 98.71 99.14 98.71 98.86 98.57 99.00 98.71 99.00 99.00 99.00 98.87 0.17
LOCAL - BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.74 0.12
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs32 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.73 0.12
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.86 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.86 99.00 98.43 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.79 0.17
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.67 0.14
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 99.00 98.71 99.00 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.70 0.19
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.67 0.13
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.71 98.86 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.70 0.19
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 98.86 98.71 99.14 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.14 98.70 0.27
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.64 0.16
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.71 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.74 0.14
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.29 98.71 98.71 98.71 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.69 0.17
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32 98.71 98.57 98.71 99.00 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.74 0.17
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.70 0.13
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.67 0.13
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.76 0.18
LOCAL - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.66 0.13
LOCAL - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.86 99.00 99.00 98.71 98.29 98.73 0.21
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.77 0.11
  • Epoch 100 - BERT bs48
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
LOCAL - BERT-bs48 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.67 0.11
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LOCAL - BERTwithAtt-bs48 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.71 0.16
LDS3 - BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.71 99.14 98.57 98.71 98.81 0.16
LOCAL - BERTwithProjection-bs48 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.43 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.77 0.17
LOCAL - BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 98.71 99.00 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.84 0.15
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs48 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.69 0.11
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_att_clsquery_weights 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.80 0.09
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.29 98.71 98.86 98.43 98.86 98.74 0.21
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.80 0.13
LDS1 - EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 98.86 98.57 98.86 99.14 98.43 99.00 98.71 98.29 98.86 98.86 98.76 0.25
LDS1 - EBERTconcatAtt-bs48_attclsqw 98.57 98.71 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.79 0.15
LDS1 - EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.74 0.14
LDS1 - EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48_attclsqw 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.74 0.11
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.29 98.86 98.71 0.19
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.57 99.00 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.76 0.14
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 99.14 98.29 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 0.20
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.57 99.00 98.29 98.86 98.86 99.00 98.71 99.00 99.00 98.86 98.81 0.22
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 99.00 98.57 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.81 0.13
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 99.00 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.77 0.15
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.57 99.14 98.71 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.80 0.17
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.86 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.86 99.00 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 0.17
  • Epoch 100 - RoBERTa
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.43 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.76 0.14
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 98.86 98.57 99.29 99.00 98.71 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.86 99.29 98.91 0.22

STT Error: trained with COMPLETE data and tested with INCOMPLETE data

gtts-google - Bad (Only good with BERT bs32)

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 61.71 60.57 60.86 60.71 59.71 61.43 60.57 59.43 61.43 60.14 60.66 0.71
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 60.14 61.43 60.43 59.43 61.00 59.57 61.14 58.57 60.14 59.43 60.13 0.85
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 60.71 60.00 59.00 61.71 60.43 63.14 60.29 59.00 60.86 60.29 60.54 1.16
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 61.71 60.71 60.14 60.86 60.14 60.14 59.29 59.86 58.43 59.57 60.09 0.86
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 59.57 62.29 58.00 58.71 62.57 59.86 60.29 59.57 59.14 57.57 59.76 1.55
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 59.71 61.00 59.57 59.00 61.71 62.29 58.29 61.86 61.00 62.14 60.66 1.34
EmbraceBERT-bs16 62.86 59.29 60.14 59.14 57.43 61.43 60.43 61.43 59.14 59.71 60.10 1.45
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 60.00 57.29 57.43 59.71 59.29 60.57 61.71 66.43 57.43 59.71 59.96 2.57
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 60.29 60.43 59.86 61.14 57.00 59.57 60.00 65.14 58.86 60.57 60.29 1.95
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 14.00 10.57 13.14 19.71 15.71 8.14 10.57 15.71 11.71 5.00 12.43 3.98
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 59.57 60.43 57.86 61.00 60.29 60.86 59.43 64.29 59.43 59.00 60.21 1.62
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 58.43 60.43 60.00 60.43 59.57 61.00 59.00 66.86 58.14 60.14 60.40 2.32
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 61.57 56.29 60.29 59.86 59.14 60.71 61.29 59.57 59.71 59.43 59.79 1.39
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 58.86 61.14 56.71 58.71 57.86 61.86 58.29 64.29 59.00 61.43 59.81 2.17
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 56.71 58.00 61.86 60.57 59.43 59.43 57.43 64.29 60.29 57.43 59.54 2.21
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 11.57 7.71 7.57 14.43 12.43 5.71 8.57 17.43 23.86 7.00 11.63 5.38
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 62.71 60.57 57.86 58.29 57.71 58.57 60.57 68.57 59.86 60.57 60.53 3.06
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 60.00 60.86 60.14 60.43 57.57 60.57 60.57 66.29 60.29 58.86 60.56 2.13
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 58.43 57.29 57.43 58.71 59.00 59.57 61.00 59.29 59.00 65.57 59.53 2.25
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 59.14 58.29 60.00 59.57 59.43 61.14 61.71 59.29 62.57 60.86 60.20 1.26
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 59.43 60.14 58.29 62.00 58.29 57.86 60.71 59.29 59.29 61.00 59.63 1.26
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 61.86 60.14 61.14 58.86 60.29 60.00 59.71 62.14 58.86 61.00 60.40 1.07
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 60.43 59.29 62.00 59.00 61.71 60.43 61.29 58.86 61.57 58.71 60.33 1.22
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 58.14 61.14 62.29 61.14 58.14 60.29 59.86 60.71 61.14 58.71 60.16 1.34
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 60.57 60.71 57.29 62.00 60.00 62.00 60.71 60.43 56.57 66.14 60.64 2.50
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 59.29 60.86 60.86 60.43 57.43 61.00 59.71 58.71 59.71 60.43 59.84 1.07
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 58.43 60.71 61.29 58.57 59.86 61.57 59.00 60.71 63.14 59.57 60.29 1.41
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 64.14 59.14 61.29 58.29 58.86 62.14 58.71 60.14 60.29 62.00 60.50 1.78
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 59.86 59.86 62.43 57.14 57.29 60.00 58.14 60.29 60.86 58.86 59.47 1.56
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 61.71 59.71 63.71 60.14 62.71 63.14 62.14 61.00 62.43 58.00 61.47 1.67
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 62.00 60.00 61.86 61.00 58.86 59.86 62.29 60.29 60.43 60.00 60.66 1.05
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 61.29 60.86 59.57 61.43 60.57 58.71 61.57 58.57 60.86 60.86 60.43 1.04
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 60.00 62.14 60.57 61.14 61.43 59.57 61.00 60.57 59.86 61.43 60.77 0.77
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 62.00 59.14 61.71 61.43 59.00 59.00 61.00 59.57 61.00 58.86 60.27 1.20
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 66.43 58.86 59.43 62.43 60.86 59.29 60.29 59.29 60.00 59.71 60.66 2.16
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 61.00 62.43 60.86 60.86 60.57 58.43 58.71 60.71 60.14 58.43 60.21 1.24
EmbraceBERT-bs32 59.86 60.43 58.00 59.57 58.00 60.29 60.14 61.00 61.43 60.57 59.93 1.09
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 58.43 59.29 60.29 60.57 59.29 60.86 59.86 66.00 59.86 59.00 60.34 2.01
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 60.86 60.14 62.57 59.71 57.86 59.14 58.57 60.14 59.29 58.29 59.66 1.31
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 12.00 10.14 12.00 11.14 18.14 7.43 11.14 23.71 23.86 6.71 13.63 5.85
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 61.43 61.00 59.14 58.86 59.29 60.57 59.57 69.86 60.71 59.71 61.01 3.06
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 59.57 58.43 60.14 59.29 59.57 61.14 59.71 66.71 57.86 59.86 60.23 2.32
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 60.86 60.00 60.86 57.86 57.57 60.86 59.57 60.57 57.29 57.57 59.30 1.47
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 59.14 61.00 59.43 60.00 58.57 60.14 59.57 65.71 60.00 59.57 60.31 1.90
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 57.43 59.57 58.43 60.86 58.71 61.29 57.86 66.86 60.14 59.43 60.06 2.55
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 12.29 10.00 13.00 11.00 18.57 7.57 11.57 23.71 23.14 7.14 13.80 5.67
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 61.00 62.43 58.57 59.00 60.43 59.86 58.86 60.86 57.43 66.00 60.44 2.30
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 59.43 59.00 59.86 60.86 60.71 59.43 57.57 61.43 60.29 60.00 59.86 1.04
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 57.57 60.86 58.00 59.86 59.43 61.00 59.71 65.29 59.43 61.43 60.26 2.04
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.14 59.43 58.71 60.29 57.71 60.29 60.29 60.29 60.00 57.71 59.59 1.11
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 58.71 59.29 58.00 60.86 58.86 60.43 61.71 60.29 60.14 59.14 59.74 1.07
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 59.43 58.29 60.43 60.43 61.57 60.00 59.86 68.43 58.14 60.29 60.69 2.76
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 58.71 59.00 58.57 60.43 60.57 61.14 59.43 61.29 60.14 59.14 59.84 0.95
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.57 60.57 59.14 60.57 57.71 58.57 58.43 60.14 60.71 61.00 59.74 1.11
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 58.14 62.00 61.43 60.71 59.43 59.14 58.57 63.00 59.71 59.86 60.20 1.48
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.71 56.71 60.29 60.29 59.43 62.29 60.29 62.43 59.43 58.14 60.10 1.71
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 57.14 58.86 58.00 59.43 58.43 59.29 60.57 61.86 61.71 59.29 59.46 1.45
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 58.71 58.14 59.14 60.86 59.86 60.86 58.43 58.57 59.29 62.71 59.66 1.36
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.86 59.71 61.29 57.86 59.00 60.00 59.71 64.29 58.14 60.14 60.20 1.80
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 61.14 56.86 60.00 61.57 61.00 61.14 58.00 62.57 59.57 59.86 60.17 1.63
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 61.43 61.57 62.00 62.14 61.71 60.86 61.14 62.00 61.86 61.29 61.60 0.40
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 60.14 60.71 59.86 60.29 62.71 61.00 61.14 61.14 61.86 61.86 61.07 0.84
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 60.71 61.43 60.71 61.14 60.57 61.29 60.57 60.29 60.86 62.00 60.96 0.48
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 59.57 61.57 61.00 59.71 65.14 61.57 60.14 61.29 58.71 61.00 60.97 1.66
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 59.43 60.57 59.71 61.29 59.00 61.00 60.57 60.00 60.29 62.43 60.43 0.94
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 58.14 58.86 60.86 61.00 60.71 60.86 60.14 61.43 60.43 60.71 60.31 0.97
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 62.43 59.86 58.71 60.71 61.00 61.00 61.00 60.43 61.00 60.43 60.66 0.90
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 61.00 60.14 60.86 60.71 63.71 61.86 60.57 61.00 61.14 61.14 61.21 0.93
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 61.71 61.43 61.29 61.00 60.71 61.14 59.14 60.43 59.86 61.14 60.79 0.74
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 5.14 12.57 25.00 7.43 7.57 17.29 13.57 9.86 19.14 14.29 13.19 5.78
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 59.43 60.00 59.86 60.71 62.00 61.57 59.71 60.86 59.71 60.29 60.41 0.81
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 59.29 60.86 60.43 60.43 62.00 61.71 61.71 60.71 60.57 62.00 60.97 0.83
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 61.71 61.57 61.00 60.57 59.14 61.57 59.71 58.00 58.71 61.14 60.31 1.26
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 60.00 60.14 60.00 60.57 58.57 60.57 59.43 58.43 60.14 61.43 59.93 0.87
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 60.57 59.86 60.57 61.43 60.29 61.71 62.00 59.86 60.29 63.86 61.04 1.18
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 8.14 12.29 24.86 7.43 5.71 15.00 13.57 5.43 16.86 9.14 11.84 5.72
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 61.71 58.29 61.14 60.57 60.71 58.86 64.00 63.86 60.00 61.00 61.01 1.76
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 61.57 61.57 60.14 60.86 61.00 60.57 59.43 61.57 60.14 61.00 60.79 0.68
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 60.43 62.00 59.86 61.71 59.14 60.71 60.57 61.29 62.43 61.14 60.93 0.95
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 59.71 60.43 61.00 61.14 60.14 61.71 60.71 61.29 58.86 60.57 60.56 0.79
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.86 61.14 62.00 60.86 60.71 61.71 60.29 60.29 61.00 61.43 61.03 0.53
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 62.29 61.14 62.14 60.86 62.14 61.86 60.71 62.57 60.29 62.86 61.69 0.83
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 60.57 60.43 61.00 59.29 60.71 62.29 60.57 63.00 59.29 60.14 60.73 1.11
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.86 59.71 59.14 60.29 63.43 62.14 61.43 62.43 59.71 62.86 61.20 1.41
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 60.71 60.71 59.14 62.86 61.43 61.71 60.71 61.29 62.00 60.86 61.14 0.93
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.43 64.14 59.57 60.29 59.29 59.14 58.86 62.00 60.57 59.43 60.47 1.56
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 62.00 62.00 59.29 60.86 59.57 59.86 62.86 60.86 59.71 61.00 60.80 1.14
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 60.71 61.57 61.71 63.14 60.57 61.86 60.29 65.29 60.71 60.00 61.59 1.52
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 62.57 60.14 60.86 59.71 61.57 60.71 62.29 61.29 62.00 63.71 61.49 1.14
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.86 59.86 61.00 61.00 62.57 60.14 61.43 60.57 60.86 58.86 60.71 0.93
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 60.86 61.57 61.00 61.14 62.14 61.29 63.00 62.43 62.29 63.29 61.90 0.81
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 60.57 60.43 59.14 60.86 61.57 61.14 58.57 61.43 60.57 62.00 60.63 1.01
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 61.00 61.43 58.86 61.57 62.29 60.71 59.29 61.86 59.86 60.71 60.76 1.06
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 62.00 60.43 59.14 60.00 63.43 62.43 61.00 62.43 60.71 60.86 61.24 1.24
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 60.57 61.00 58.57 60.43 60.86 62.57 59.57 60.14 60.43 62.00 60.61 1.07
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 61.00 60.86 57.14 60.14 60.71 61.29 59.00 61.71 60.57 61.00 60.34 1.27
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 61.57 61.29 59.14 63.00 60.00 60.43 61.86 63.43 61.29 61.00 61.30 1.22
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 62.86 60.86 61.43 62.00 60.57 60.29 60.43 62.71 61.00 61.71 61.39 0.87
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 60.86 60.14 62.43 62.57 60.00 60.00 61.00 60.86 61.43 60.14 60.94 0.90
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 5.43 6.86 23.57 6.57 5.43 13.29 13.14 4.57 12.71 11.00 10.26 5.53
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 62.71 59.86 60.86 62.71 60.71 61.57 62.29 63.00 61.14 61.14 61.60 0.99
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 61.43 60.00 60.57 59.71 60.29 60.86 60.29 63.00 60.57 61.43 60.81 0.90
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 61.14 60.00 60.57 60.57 58.14 62.00 61.57 63.00 60.29 62.00 60.93 1.28
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 60.86 60.29 58.71 60.71 60.86 59.14 60.14 60.14 60.43 60.00 60.13 0.67
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 59.71 59.43 61.71 60.14 61.00 60.14 60.43 61.29 61.00 63.29 60.81 1.07
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 3.71 7.29 30.71 7.00 7.29 14.43 16.29 4.29 13.00 5.86 10.99 7.75
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 61.86 60.14 62.71 61.86 61.71 61.43 60.43 62.29 60.57 59.71 61.27 0.94
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 60.86 60.57 60.71 62.43 62.00 59.86 60.43 61.14 60.71 63.29 61.20 0.99
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 62.43 60.43 61.71 61.00 61.71 60.29 66.14 60.14 60.57 61.71 61.61 1.67
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 62.43 61.29 62.00 66.86 59.14 61.71 60.86 61.86 60.14 61.29 61.76 1.93
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 61.43 61.43 60.29 61.43 60.29 62.29 63.00 61.71 61.29 61.57 61.47 0.77
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 60.00 59.71 60.43 63.86 66.43 61.71 61.14 65.86 59.86 65.29 62.43 2.53
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.57 60.86 61.00 62.14 60.86 61.71 61.71 64.14 61.00 62.86 61.79 0.99
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 61.86 60.00 62.57 60.00 60.29 63.00 62.00 62.14 60.00 62.14 61.40 1.13
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 61.43 60.00 60.71 60.86 61.57 61.43 63.00 60.43 60.71 64.29 61.44 1.23
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 61.71 63.00 61.71 62.00 59.71 59.71 59.43 61.00 63.71 60.71 61.27 1.36
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.71 60.57 60.29 62.43 62.86 60.29 62.00 61.43 64.00 59.71 61.43 1.30
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 60.86 60.29 62.29 60.43 61.86 62.00 64.71 61.86 60.14 61.57 61.60 1.27
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 59.57 60.86 61.57 60.29 60.86 63.00 60.71 61.29 60.00 61.00 60.91 0.89
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 60.29 61.43 60.86 60.43 61.57 60.86 61.86 60.43 60.00 60.86 60.86 0.57
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 61.57 60.86 60.14 59.71 60.43 59.14 62.43 60.86 59.86 59.86 60.49 0.92
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 59.57 60.71 62.14 61.71 60.29 62.29 63.00 60.57 61.57 60.71 61.26 1.00
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 62.57 60.43 61.00 60.43 62.14 60.71 61.43 61.86 61.57 61.57 61.37 0.69
BERTwithProjection-bs32 62.00 61.57 61.00 60.29 60.14 62.14 59.71 61.57 60.43 61.29 61.01 0.79
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 61.43 60.29 62.29 61.29 59.57 60.29 61.00 60.86 61.14 62.00 61.01 0.78
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 61.29 60.57 61.00 61.29 60.57 60.71 62.14 63.71 60.71 60.57 61.26 0.94
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 63.00 60.57 60.43 59.43 61.43 62.29 60.14 62.14 62.57 60.57 61.26 1.13
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 61.14 61.00 61.00 61.86 62.00 60.00 61.71 59.86 61.43 63.57 61.36 1.00
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 63.14 60.71 61.86 59.86 62.57 61.29 62.57 62.14 61.71 62.71 61.86 0.96
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 61.86 59.29 61.14 60.00 59.86 60.71 60.86 60.57 61.86 61.00 60.71 0.79
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 60.00 59.71 61.57 61.29 61.29 60.71 60.29 62.71 60.71 61.00 60.93 0.82
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 61.86 60.00 62.29 60.43 61.43 61.14 61.71 60.57 59.71 59.00 60.81 1.00
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 61.29 58.86 61.29 61.14 61.14 60.57 61.29 61.86 62.29 61.86 61.16 0.89
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 60.57 60.00 61.14 61.86 61.86 63.00 62.14 60.29 59.14 60.71 61.07 1.09
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 61.29 60.86 61.86 62.43 61.14 61.14 62.00 61.14 60.29 60.86 61.30 0.60
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 61.71 62.14 61.71 59.29 60.43 62.86 60.86 62.43 63.29 57.86 61.26 1.60
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 59.29 61.57 60.86 60.57 61.29 60.43 60.29 61.71 60.71 61.29 60.80 0.68
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 60.57 61.86 61.57 60.71 61.43 61.00 61.71 60.43 60.71 59.29 60.93 0.73
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 59.71 60.14 60.29 61.71 60.00 60.86 61.00 61.29 61.86 60.14 60.70 0.71
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 62.29 61.71 61.14 61.14 62.00 60.86 61.14 61.57 62.86 61.57 61.63 0.58
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 60.00 62.29 61.71 60.43 61.14 60.29 61.71 61.71 64.14 60.71 61.41 1.15
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 60.86 60.43 60.29 61.14 58.71 59.43 61.00 61.14 59.29 59.14 60.14 0.87
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 61.29 59.86 59.57 61.57 61.57 62.00 61.29 59.71 59.14 59.43 60.54 1.03
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 60.00 61.71 60.43 61.57 63.00 62.29 61.43 60.71 61.14 61.29 61.36 0.83
BERTwithProjection-bs48 62.43 61.57 60.86 60.71 62.00 61.43 61.43 61.43 61.00 62.71 61.56 0.62
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 61.14 61.00 58.71 59.71 60.86 63.00 61.86 61.29 60.57 62.29 61.04 1.16
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 60.57 60.43 59.86 60.71 60.14 60.71 61.57 60.71 60.29 60.86 60.59 0.44
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 63.14 59.57 60.71 61.57 60.00 59.00 59.86 61.43 60.14 60.71 60.61 1.13
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 61.29 61.00 62.14 60.71 61.29 61.43 61.29 61.29 61.43 62.14 61.40 0.42
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 58.43 60.14 61.57 60.57 61.00 61.29 62.00 63.86 61.43 61.57 61.19 1.31
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 61.00 61.43 60.43 61.00 60.71 60.29 60.29 59.71 59.86 60.71 60.54 0.51
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 62.43 59.86 61.29 61.86 59.57 61.43 61.29 60.71 61.00 60.43 60.99 0.83
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 61.43 62.29 61.86 59.14 60.71 60.43 61.57 62.71 62.14 60.71 61.30 1.01
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 60.00 60.43 60.71 61.29 61.86 62.14 61.43 61.57 60.71 60.71 61.09 0.64
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 61.14 61.86 59.86 59.43 61.43 61.00 60.86 62.29 61.29 61.14 61.03 0.81
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 61.29 59.57 61.71 60.71 60.29 60.00 59.14 60.86 60.86 61.00 60.54 0.75
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 61.29 60.43 60.57 60.71 60.43 60.57 60.43 61.86 62.43 60.86 60.96 0.65
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 59.86 60.86 62.00 60.00 60.86 61.14 61.29 62.57 62.00 66.43 61.70 1.77
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 61.57 61.86 60.29 61.57 59.29 60.29 60.86 60.29 60.14 59.43 60.56 0.84
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 60.57 59.57 61.29 60.29 60.57 62.14 60.14 60.43 62.29 61.86 60.91 0.88
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 66.57 60.00 60.29 61.29 61.57 60.43 61.14 60.86 60.29 60.86 61.33 1.81
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 61.57 60.57 61.29 60.86 61.00 60.43 61.29 61.86 62.43 60.71 61.20 0.59

gtts-sphinx - not good with any

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 83.14 83.86 84.00 83.00 80.14 84.00 83.71 80.86 83.43 83.00 82.91 1.27
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 83.71 85.43 83.71 79.43 83.86 83.00 85.43 79.29 84.43 81.29 82.96 2.12
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 84.29 80.29 81.71 86.43 80.57 81.57 82.71 78.29 84.71 82.29 82.29 2.26
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 82.43 81.86 82.71 83.71 81.29 82.71 79.57 83.14 80.43 81.86 81.97 1.20
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 81.86 84.71 77.43 80.57 82.71 82.43 84.14 81.29 81.14 81.29 81.76 1.92
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 81.43 87.43 80.57 79.86 82.43 84.00 76.43 83.29 83.00 84.57 82.30 2.83
EmbraceBERT-bs16 85.14 80.29 84.14 82.43 74.57 83.00 83.71 83.14 80.57 78.00 81.50 3.06
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 83.14 77.71 78.43 82.71 81.43 83.29 85.43 84.86 80.00 83.57 82.06 2.48
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 82.71 84.00 85.29 81.00 74.86 80.71 81.86 82.71 80.71 84.00 81.79 2.73
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 14.29 8.43 8.86 13.71 11.71 9.43 4.43 19.43 12.29 5.29 10.79 4.25
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 82.29 81.86 80.86 82.57 81.43 82.71 80.86 82.57 82.14 80.29 81.76 0.81
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 83.57 81.71 81.57 86.00 79.86 81.29 79.14 82.71 80.71 81.71 81.83 1.84
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 80.71 69.71 82.14 82.00 80.00 81.86 85.14 81.14 79.29 80.00 80.20 3.82
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 81.00 81.29 82.00 80.43 79.86 83.14 80.71 83.00 82.29 84.57 81.83 1.38
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 77.43 77.86 85.29 81.00 83.57 81.29 78.71 81.14 83.71 79.86 80.99 2.48
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 15.14 5.29 6.29 11.14 11.29 6.14 4.71 19.14 23.86 6.29 10.93 6.24
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 84.43 80.86 76.86 77.57 78.57 77.14 81.43 82.57 80.71 81.71 80.19 2.41
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 84.43 84.29 83.43 81.14 75.86 80.86 80.71 85.86 83.00 80.57 82.01 2.69
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 81.57 72.57 79.14 78.29 81.29 81.00 84.71 80.57 79.29 81.29 79.97 2.98
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 83.00 80.14 78.43 80.29 76.86 83.43 82.00 81.57 83.43 85.29 81.44 2.42
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 83.86 80.43 76.86 83.43 80.29 80.14 84.71 81.71 82.14 82.43 81.60 2.16
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 84.71 82.00 82.43 79.43 82.43 81.14 82.71 84.00 79.57 83.86 82.23 1.69
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 85.43 83.00 77.00 79.71 85.14 80.86 82.57 80.00 83.29 79.43 81.64 2.56
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.00 81.71 84.00 84.57 77.00 81.43 80.29 82.14 84.86 80.86 82.09 2.29
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 85.00 80.14 78.00 83.71 79.43 83.86 82.00 84.43 75.57 84.57 81.67 3.07
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 84.00 85.00 82.14 84.57 77.43 82.57 79.14 82.14 83.57 82.29 82.29 2.25
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 81.00 84.29 81.71 76.29 79.43 83.86 79.14 84.14 83.14 82.14 81.51 2.46
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 85.14 81.57 82.71 76.57 80.00 83.29 79.43 82.86 78.43 80.14 81.01 2.44
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 84.00 84.29 79.57 78.57 80.29 81.43 82.43 81.43 82.86 82.14 81.70 1.75
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 85.57 84.14 82.14 83.00 82.29 84.29 83.29 83.00 87.29 75.29 83.03 2.98
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 83.57 83.43 84.00 81.00 80.43 82.86 84.29 83.43 82.00 83.86 82.89 1.25
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 83.43 82.86 82.29 82.43 82.00 81.86 84.71 80.86 80.86 84.86 82.61 1.32
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 83.43 83.00 84.00 82.57 82.86 81.43 83.86 84.29 82.43 84.00 83.19 0.85
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 84.29 81.29 84.43 82.00 81.00 81.57 82.00 81.86 83.57 83.14 82.51 1.18
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 85.14 81.57 79.43 83.00 83.57 82.57 82.14 80.14 85.86 85.71 82.91 2.10
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 83.86 85.43 81.29 80.14 81.29 81.00 80.00 82.14 83.86 81.29 82.03 1.69
EmbraceBERT-bs32 83.14 83.14 80.14 79.57 78.71 80.71 82.43 80.43 82.00 81.71 81.20 1.44
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 82.29 81.00 83.14 85.14 81.14 80.14 84.57 86.43 82.71 79.71 82.63 2.11
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 84.29 80.00 82.71 83.14 79.43 78.00 79.00 82.14 84.57 80.71 81.40 2.18
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 15.57 9.57 7.43 5.71 17.71 10.14 5.43 24.71 27.14 6.00 12.94 7.59
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 84.57 83.57 82.00 80.57 81.29 79.14 83.14 86.43 83.14 82.43 82.63 1.96
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 83.29 78.43 84.14 79.71 83.14 81.71 81.71 83.14 79.86 82.14 81.73 1.76
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 83.57 82.14 84.43 78.29 78.14 79.43 80.00 80.71 77.57 78.71 80.30 2.25
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 83.14 82.57 80.71 79.86 78.00 81.86 81.14 82.43 81.00 80.29 81.10 1.44
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 82.43 79.14 83.86 82.00 77.00 82.43 76.86 83.29 83.14 79.29 80.94 2.50
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 16.00 9.43 7.43 5.86 16.86 9.86 5.43 25.00 27.71 6.14 12.97 7.70
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 83.14 83.86 80.57 77.29 81.86 80.14 81.57 80.86 79.14 80.71 80.91 1.79
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 83.57 81.71 81.43 81.86 82.14 80.29 78.86 80.86 81.14 83.29 81.51 1.31
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 79.86 83.86 77.86 82.00 81.71 82.14 82.57 83.43 81.71 81.14 81.63 1.65
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 84.71 84.00 78.43 84.14 80.29 81.43 79.43 85.86 81.57 80.57 82.04 2.36
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 82.29 81.29 79.14 82.00 81.00 81.14 84.29 83.86 82.43 80.43 81.79 1.46
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 83.86 82.86 82.14 80.57 82.14 81.57 81.14 82.14 77.71 83.57 81.77 1.66
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 81.71 83.00 77.71 83.57 81.43 83.86 78.57 85.14 83.29 81.86 82.01 2.21
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.29 83.71 79.43 83.71 78.00 79.43 78.00 81.14 81.86 82.57 81.21 2.26
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 81.00 84.29 83.43 81.57 80.86 78.71 80.86 84.71 80.71 80.71 81.69 1.78
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 83.43 75.57 78.57 79.43 82.43 82.00 81.00 86.57 81.00 79.14 80.91 2.85
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 78.86 80.57 73.29 80.86 79.29 79.14 81.29 85.57 82.57 79.00 80.04 2.98
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 81.71 77.14 79.14 83.57 84.71 83.71 78.43 80.00 80.14 84.71 81.33 2.60
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 86.57 83.71 82.14 76.71 77.14 80.71 81.43 84.86 77.71 82.57 81.36 3.16
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 83.57 79.29 78.57 82.86 81.43 80.57 74.57 86.14 81.29 78.71 80.70 3.02
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 84.71 83.57 84.14 85.14 85.43 85.71 84.43 84.57 84.86 85.14 84.77 0.60
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 80.57 85.43 85.86 79.14 84.57 83.00 83.00 82.14 85.00 80.29 82.90 2.22
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 85.86 85.29 84.86 80.00 81.00 83.14 84.14 83.00 84.29 83.43 83.50 1.75
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 80.57 82.57 83.57 76.00 84.00 84.43 83.43 84.86 79.57 83.14 82.21 2.60
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 80.57 82.71 80.57 82.14 81.86 81.86 82.43 80.71 81.29 81.71 81.59 0.73
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 80.86 79.00 82.29 80.14 84.86 81.00 82.00 81.71 81.86 82.00 81.57 1.46
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 83.00 82.29 83.14 80.71 82.14 84.43 82.14 81.71 80.00 83.71 82.33 1.26
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 84.43 82.43 81.29 79.71 84.71 81.43 82.71 82.29 82.86 83.71 82.56 1.44
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 85.00 82.00 83.57 85.14 82.43 83.00 82.71 79.43 82.71 80.57 82.66 1.67
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 3.86 8.86 28.57 13.86 6.43 24.00 10.71 11.71 14.29 16.29 13.86 7.21
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 84.14 83.00 82.43 83.29 82.14 75.86 83.29 80.71 82.43 84.43 82.17 2.33
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 82.57 82.86 86.29 83.57 83.43 84.57 84.00 83.29 79.86 84.14 83.46 1.55
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 86.43 83.71 82.00 81.29 81.14 83.71 82.00 80.29 81.43 82.86 82.49 1.68
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 84.14 81.71 81.00 83.86 81.00 82.43 83.14 81.71 81.29 78.86 81.91 1.48
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 83.29 80.29 84.14 80.71 83.29 82.00 83.57 80.00 79.71 84.00 82.10 1.68
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 3.57 14.43 28.71 13.29 3.14 23.71 12.29 7.86 17.43 8.29 13.27 7.86
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 82.57 77.43 84.29 78.71 82.43 81.00 83.57 82.43 83.71 85.00 82.11 2.30
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 82.00 83.86 80.00 83.86 82.57 81.14 80.86 85.14 80.71 84.00 82.41 1.65
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 81.57 83.43 83.00 82.43 83.14 83.00 84.00 84.29 84.14 85.29 83.43 1.00
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 82.43 82.14 83.29 82.29 82.86 82.71 83.00 83.00 82.57 79.71 82.40 0.96
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.29 77.86 83.29 82.57 83.00 83.14 84.14 84.86 82.14 84.29 82.96 1.88
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 81.71 84.43 83.00 83.43 82.57 84.00 80.14 87.29 79.14 83.86 82.96 2.17
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 81.71 83.29 84.71 82.43 85.57 84.57 82.43 81.29 83.71 83.71 83.34 1.31
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 82.29 83.71 81.00 83.00 83.43 83.14 84.43 86.43 82.14 82.86 83.24 1.39
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 80.00 82.43 78.86 84.00 83.29 85.00 85.00 81.71 84.43 82.00 82.67 1.98
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 80.71 81.43 82.14 82.86 78.86 82.71 82.86 85.86 82.71 82.86 82.30 1.71
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.14 80.14 79.14 83.43 82.71 79.43 85.71 82.43 82.57 85.57 82.53 2.23
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 83.57 82.86 82.71 81.00 82.86 84.43 82.43 84.29 82.29 84.00 83.04 1.00
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 83.43 85.00 85.00 82.29 82.43 81.29 81.71 85.00 83.71 83.71 83.36 1.32
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.14 85.14 84.00 81.57 81.14 84.71 82.86 82.86 83.29 81.14 83.09 1.37
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 85.29 83.29 84.57 85.43 85.29 85.29 84.43 84.71 84.86 86.14 84.93 0.72
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 82.29 83.29 79.43 83.14 83.29 82.57 82.86 82.71 84.57 84.14 82.83 1.31
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 81.14 82.57 80.71 81.29 83.43 80.86 79.71 84.14 85.00 79.71 81.86 1.74
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 84.29 80.57 82.14 79.57 84.29 81.71 83.00 83.29 82.71 83.43 82.50 1.46
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 82.14 83.14 81.71 83.29 82.00 83.00 83.14 81.43 84.86 82.57 82.73 0.94
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 84.86 83.43 81.43 80.14 83.14 82.43 83.00 84.57 81.86 82.14 82.70 1.35
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 84.29 83.71 83.43 82.14 84.71 83.29 83.57 85.14 83.29 83.71 83.73 0.79
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 85.57 81.86 83.57 84.14 85.43 82.71 81.71 83.29 83.00 82.43 83.37 1.27
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 84.43 79.86 84.14 85.14 81.43 83.14 83.71 82.29 79.86 81.57 82.56 1.77
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 7.86 3.57 27.43 13.57 3.71 15.86 8.71 5.00 12.29 11.14 10.91 6.79
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 83.57 83.14 83.86 83.29 82.71 85.71 84.14 84.57 82.57 84.43 83.80 0.91
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 85.29 81.57 82.14 83.14 82.14 83.71 81.86 82.86 84.43 84.00 83.11 1.16
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 83.86 82.14 84.86 82.57 82.14 83.57 83.29 81.57 81.14 83.00 82.81 1.07
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 82.71 79.14 82.29 82.43 80.71 83.29 82.57 80.29 81.57 84.29 81.93 1.44
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 82.14 78.86 84.29 82.57 82.29 80.71 81.71 84.43 79.86 81.14 81.80 1.68
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 2.43 2.86 32.57 13.00 5.43 17.71 8.43 5.00 7.71 4.57 9.97 8.77
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 81.14 82.29 83.14 82.86 83.00 84.14 82.57 84.57 82.43 84.14 83.03 0.98
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 84.00 81.86 83.57 81.14 85.14 84.71 82.57 81.71 85.14 81.71 83.16 1.46
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 85.43 85.14 83.43 84.86 84.57 81.86 82.00 82.00 84.57 84.86 83.87 1.35
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 85.57 82.00 85.14 84.29 83.14 80.57 77.86 84.00 82.57 83.86 82.90 2.19
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 83.86 78.57 83.57 83.57 82.00 85.43 82.57 84.29 81.71 86.00 83.16 2.00
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 81.43 79.71 81.00 85.14 83.57 83.29 81.43 84.00 82.86 83.00 82.54 1.54
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 82.29 83.29 79.86 82.71 82.43 83.14 85.86 83.43 82.57 86.00 83.16 1.68
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 84.71 83.86 85.00 79.43 82.86 84.29 84.14 83.86 80.86 84.57 83.36 1.73
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 84.14 82.57 82.71 84.00 84.57 78.86 82.71 81.14 82.29 84.43 82.74 1.66
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 85.71 82.86 83.29 79.43 83.14 83.29 80.14 82.43 83.86 83.43 82.76 1.71
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 82.71 81.57 81.00 82.86 80.57 82.14 81.00 83.00 84.43 80.00 81.93 1.28
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 84.86 82.29 83.57 81.86 83.14 84.86 83.86 82.14 84.14 83.29 83.40 1.02
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 81.43 82.86 83.00 82.00 82.43 83.00 83.71 83.43 83.29 83.29 82.84 0.67
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 82.71 82.00 83.43 83.29 82.71 81.43 80.86 83.43 79.71 85.57 82.51 1.54
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 82.86 85.57 84.29 83.71 84.71 81.71 85.43 84.29 81.14 83.29 83.70 1.40
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 82.43 83.86 83.29 84.00 83.86 83.14 87.43 82.57 85.71 83.29 83.96 1.45
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 85.71 82.71 83.86 83.57 82.57 84.86 85.71 84.86 85.71 84.29 84.39 1.13
BERTwithProjection-bs32 84.29 84.43 85.14 82.29 84.00 84.14 81.14 86.86 84.29 84.43 84.10 1.45
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 84.43 85.71 84.14 83.86 84.29 82.57 85.57 83.43 83.57 85.14 84.27 0.94
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 82.86 84.29 85.00 83.57 83.29 84.00 84.29 86.57 83.00 84.14 84.10 1.03
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 82.86 84.43 83.00 83.00 84.29 85.43 82.00 83.57 83.71 81.71 83.40 1.07
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 84.14 83.57 84.43 84.57 86.86 83.71 84.43 83.14 85.86 84.86 84.56 1.05
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 86.14 84.29 84.00 83.14 86.00 84.00 82.57 84.29 83.29 83.00 84.07 1.14
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 82.14 81.29 83.14 83.29 82.86 83.86 83.14 81.86 84.71 83.14 82.94 0.94
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 84.43 82.86 84.00 84.86 84.29 84.14 85.57 81.14 82.14 85.00 83.84 1.31
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 84.86 84.29 86.00 83.14 83.29 82.71 84.43 83.86 83.14 83.14 83.89 0.96
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 82.29 83.57 82.14 84.43 83.86 83.86 83.14 85.14 86.57 84.86 83.99 1.27
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 83.43 84.57 82.14 84.71 83.29 85.71 85.43 83.43 83.14 83.71 83.96 1.06
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 82.86 85.00 82.86 86.57 84.43 83.29 83.86 84.14 84.00 84.86 84.19 1.07
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 85.86 86.57 83.71 83.43 84.71 84.86 84.71 86.43 87.00 83.57 85.09 1.25
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 84.43 84.29 84.14 86.00 84.43 85.57 82.00 84.71 82.86 84.00 84.24 1.10
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 82.29 84.43 83.29 83.43 85.00 84.71 85.14 82.43 86.43 82.00 83.91 1.38
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 84.86 82.43 83.71 84.14 82.43 81.86 82.86 84.86 85.71 84.14 83.70 1.20
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 84.71 84.43 84.29 83.57 83.43 85.00 85.29 85.71 85.00 85.29 84.67 0.71
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 82.43 84.14 82.71 81.71 84.57 84.71 84.43 85.29 87.14 84.43 84.16 1.48
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 81.86 82.86 83.00 82.86 80.14 83.14 83.71 84.57 80.00 82.71 82.49 1.38
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 84.29 83.14 84.86 85.14 82.43 85.00 83.57 83.00 83.57 84.14 83.91 0.87
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 85.14 82.29 83.43 83.14 85.14 84.86 85.43 86.57 82.86 84.00 84.29 1.28
BERTwithProjection-bs48 83.29 84.14 83.86 84.00 85.00 86.57 84.14 86.00 84.14 84.00 84.51 0.98
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 82.86 82.86 82.43 84.14 81.57 83.29 86.57 84.29 83.71 83.43 83.51 1.27
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 82.43 81.43 83.29 82.14 81.71 84.43 83.29 83.29 81.14 82.57 82.57 0.96
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 83.14 81.71 85.29 85.00 78.86 81.86 84.43 83.86 84.71 83.14 83.20 1.86
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 84.43 85.43 84.86 83.00 84.86 84.57 84.14 82.71 85.86 85.00 84.49 0.94
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 84.00 82.86 83.29 85.00 86.29 83.57 84.29 86.86 84.86 84.43 84.54 1.20
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 83.57 82.14 85.86 81.71 84.00 80.00 82.71 83.14 81.14 82.71 82.70 1.54
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 83.00 83.86 85.00 84.57 82.14 84.43 83.29 84.57 86.14 85.14 84.21 1.11
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 86.00 86.00 87.00 82.86 83.14 82.71 84.00 85.00 86.00 83.71 84.64 1.47
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 84.00 83.57 83.29 85.43 85.14 83.14 83.86 84.29 85.86 81.71 84.03 1.16
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 83.57 83.57 85.14 82.43 83.71 83.71 83.14 84.57 86.43 84.29 84.06 1.06
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 82.43 82.86 85.14 82.86 82.00 84.43 80.71 82.43 83.14 83.00 82.90 1.16
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 84.43 84.43 85.29 83.14 83.57 85.71 85.14 83.86 86.57 85.29 84.74 1.00
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 85.14 84.29 84.57 83.29 83.00 84.57 85.00 86.29 83.29 84.29 84.37 0.95
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 83.00 86.14 82.71 84.71 83.29 82.29 83.71 82.43 81.86 81.71 83.19 1.30
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 80.71 85.14 82.71 84.00 82.14 86.71 84.14 81.14 84.86 84.29 83.59 1.78
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 84.71 82.43 83.29 85.29 85.43 84.86 82.43 83.29 83.14 86.14 84.10 1.27
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 85.57 84.57 83.29 82.00 82.43 82.43 82.43 83.29 85.29 81.14 83.24 1.39

gtts-witai - not good with any

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 98.86 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.14 98.14 98.57 98.00 98.57 98.39 0.25
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.86 98.29 98.71 98.29 98.29 98.86 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.56 0.23
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.71 98.29 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.00 98.57 98.29 98.46 0.23
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 98.57 98.29 98.14 98.14 98.00 98.43 98.29 98.43 97.71 98.43 98.24 0.24
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.43 98.14 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.44 0.20
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.57 98.14 99.00 98.43 98.14 98.14 98.00 98.57 98.29 98.37 0.28
EmbraceBERT-bs16 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.14 97.71 98.57 98.14 98.43 98.57 98.00 98.33 0.30
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.43 97.43 98.14 98.57 98.29 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.46 0.41
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.00 98.71 98.29 98.43 97.71 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.36 0.29
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 15.57 3.14 9.00 15.29 12.43 9.57 0.71 18.86 7.43 1.14 9.31 5.98
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.29 98.29 97.71 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.29 98.57 98.57 97.86 98.29 0.28
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.71 97.57 98.29 98.14 98.43 98.14 98.71 98.71 98.00 98.31 0.35
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 99.00 96.71 99.14 98.57 98.14 98.29 98.71 97.86 98.43 97.86 98.27 0.66
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.14 98.71 97.86 98.43 98.14 98.43 98.14 98.86 98.00 98.57 98.33 0.31
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.00 98.57 98.57 98.14 98.43 98.00 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.36 0.22
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 11.71 0.43 5.86 13.00 11.57 5.14 1.71 19.86 20.86 1.29 9.14 7.06
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.43 97.43 98.14 97.43 98.14 97.86 98.57 98.14 98.29 98.11 0.41
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.43 97.86 98.14 97.71 98.71 98.29 98.14 98.33 0.35
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 98.14 97.71 97.86 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.86 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.29 0.33
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.29 98.00 98.43 98.14 98.57 98.57 98.29 99.43 98.86 98.51 0.38
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.14 97.43 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.14 98.37 0.39
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 98.43 98.86 99.00 98.14 98.29 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.00 98.57 98.46 0.29
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.71 99.00 98.00 97.86 98.57 98.00 98.43 98.57 98.71 97.86 98.37 0.39
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.71 98.00 98.14 98.29 97.71 98.00 97.86 98.57 98.29 98.14 98.17 0.29
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 98.43 98.57 96.86 98.43 97.71 98.86 98.14 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.21 0.53
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.57 97.29 98.29 97.86 98.86 98.57 99.14 98.37 0.49
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.14 98.86 98.29 98.43 98.14 98.43 98.00 98.86 99.29 98.14 98.46 0.39
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.14 98.43 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.29 97.86 98.40 0.25
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.29 98.71 98.00 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.86 98.00 98.37 0.26
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.86 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.14 98.71 98.57 98.00 99.00 97.43 98.40 0.43
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 99.00 98.29 98.43 98.14 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.29 98.57 98.47 0.24
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.71 98.00 98.43 98.14 98.57 98.71 98.14 98.43 98.57 98.43 0.24
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.86 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.29 98.00 98.57 98.86 98.43 98.29 98.44 0.25
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 99.00 98.14 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.50 0.22
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.29 98.57 98.14 98.86 98.14 98.29 98.57 98.14 98.57 98.29 98.39 0.23
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.86 97.71 98.86 98.29 99.00 98.14 98.14 99.00 98.00 98.43 0.44
EmbraceBERT-bs32 98.71 98.43 98.00 98.43 98.14 98.29 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.40 0.25
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.43 98.29 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.00 98.29 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.49 0.24
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.43 97.71 98.29 98.00 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.37 0.31
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 10.29 9.00 6.43 2.00 15.43 9.14 2.86 27.00 29.71 1.14 11.30 9.48
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 99.14 98.43 98.29 98.29 98.71 98.57 99.00 97.86 97.43 98.43 0.48
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.00 98.14 98.40 0.18
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 98.71 98.29 98.00 98.43 98.00 98.14 98.00 98.43 98.14 98.14 98.23 0.22
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.14 98.29 98.14 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.29 98.43 98.33 0.13
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.29 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.57 98.43 98.50 0.16
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 10.86 8.71 6.43 2.43 16.29 9.57 3.00 26.43 30.14 1.00 11.49 9.46
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.43 98.00 97.71 98.29 98.57 98.00 97.71 97.86 98.86 98.20 0.38
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.86 98.29 98.71 98.29 98.86 97.57 98.29 97.86 98.43 98.37 0.39
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 98.00 98.57 97.57 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.29 98.36 0.32
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.71 98.43 98.14 98.43 98.29 98.71 98.43 99.00 98.43 98.43 98.50 0.23
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.14 97.86 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.29 99.14 98.86 98.71 98.49 0.35
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 98.29 99.00 98.29 98.14 98.57 98.14 98.29 98.14 98.29 98.14 98.33 0.26
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.57 99.00 98.14 97.86 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.14 98.53 0.35
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.57 99.00 98.14 98.29 98.43 98.29 97.57 98.29 98.14 98.00 98.27 0.35
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 98.14 98.43 98.14 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.14 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.44 0.24
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.00 98.14 97.71 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.29 98.31 0.30
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.14 98.57 97.29 98.43 98.00 98.29 98.29 99.00 98.29 98.14 98.24 0.41
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 98.14 98.43 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.57 97.00 98.71 98.14 98.00 98.21 0.45
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.57 98.29 98.00 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.43 0.21
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.00 97.71 98.00 98.14 98.00 98.43 98.86 98.43 98.00 98.21 0.33
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 98.00 97.57 98.14 97.86 98.43 98.29 97.86 98.14 97.57 98.14 98.00 0.27
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 97.43 98.29 97.71 96.86 96.86 97.86 96.86 97.14 98.00 97.00 97.40 0.51
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.00 98.29 98.14 96.86 97.71 98.00 97.86 97.71 98.43 97.43 97.84 0.43
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 96.71 98.00 97.29 97.14 97.43 96.71 96.57 98.14 96.43 98.14 97.26 0.63
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.00 98.43 97.57 97.71 97.43 97.71 98.14 97.43 97.86 97.71 97.70 0.37
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 97.86 95.57 98.29 97.14 98.00 97.86 98.14 98.43 98.14 96.86 97.63 0.83
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 97.86 98.00 97.71 98.57 96.86 98.43 98.43 97.86 97.00 97.71 97.84 0.54
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 97.14 97.86 98.00 96.86 98.29 97.71 98.00 96.57 97.43 97.71 97.56 0.52
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 97.14 96.71 98.14 98.29 97.29 98.00 97.86 96.29 97.86 98.00 97.56 0.63
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 2.14 4.29 28.00 14.86 1.29 25.71 4.71 8.43 12.29 16.00 11.77 8.97
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 97.86 97.86 96.86 98.14 97.14 97.71 98.43 97.57 97.71 97.86 97.71 0.43
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 97.71 97.29 97.86 98.00 97.43 98.29 98.43 97.43 96.71 97.43 97.66 0.48
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 97.57 97.43 98.00 97.43 98.14 98.00 97.86 98.29 98.29 98.71 97.97 0.39
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.14 98.29 96.86 97.86 97.71 98.00 97.57 98.43 96.71 97.43 97.60 0.55
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 97.43 97.86 98.29 97.43 97.29 97.71 98.71 97.43 96.71 97.14 97.60 0.55
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 0.71 17.43 29.14 14.57 0.57 24.29 7.00 5.00 12.71 4.29 11.57 9.33
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.86 98.00 98.14 96.43 98.71 97.43 97.43 97.14 97.57 97.43 97.61 0.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 97.14 98.29 97.86 98.43 97.71 97.71 97.71 97.00 98.57 98.29 97.87 0.50
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 98.43 98.14 98.14 98.00 97.86 97.86 98.29 98.14 97.29 97.86 98.00 0.30
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.29 97.57 97.00 98.00 97.29 98.14 98.43 97.43 97.71 97.86 97.77 0.43
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 97.14 97.29 97.71 98.00 97.57 98.14 98.43 97.71 98.29 98.29 97.86 0.42
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 96.57 98.14 98.00 98.14 97.29 97.71 98.14 98.71 97.00 97.86 97.76 0.60
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 97.86 98.00 98.29 98.14 98.57 98.00 98.00 97.86 98.43 96.71 97.99 0.48
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 97.86 97.86 98.14 97.29 97.86 97.57 98.29 98.71 97.29 97.43 97.83 0.44
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 97.57 98.57 97.86 97.86 97.57 98.29 97.43 98.00 98.57 96.71 97.84 0.54
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 96.43 96.71 97.86 97.86 97.86 98.14 98.00 98.00 98.14 97.71 97.67 0.57
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 97.29 97.86 97.86 97.14 97.43 97.71 98.00 98.14 97.57 97.86 97.69 0.31
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 97.29 98.43 96.86 97.00 97.86 97.71 98.43 97.86 97.14 98.00 97.66 0.54
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 96.86 98.57 98.00 98.14 97.71 98.00 97.86 97.57 98.43 97.57 97.87 0.46
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.00 98.14 97.86 98.29 96.86 96.86 96.86 97.14 97.86 97.71 97.56 0.54
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 98.43 97.86 98.14 98.14 98.43 98.14 98.00 98.00 98.14 98.43 98.17 0.19
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 97.86 98.43 97.29 97.14 97.57 97.86 97.86 98.14 98.14 98.29 97.86 0.40
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 96.29 97.86 98.00 97.14 97.86 98.00 98.00 98.14 98.14 97.14 97.66 0.58
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 97.86 98.14 97.00 97.71 97.14 96.57 98.29 96.71 98.14 98.00 97.56 0.61
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.57 98.14 98.29 98.14 97.14 97.14 98.00 96.57 98.00 98.29 97.73 0.56
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 97.71 97.57 97.86 98.00 97.43 97.86 98.00 97.86 96.71 97.71 97.67 0.36
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 98.43 97.71 98.00 97.29 98.57 97.71 98.29 97.29 97.86 98.00 97.91 0.42
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.14 97.86 98.29 98.00 98.14 97.29 98.00 98.71 97.43 97.86 97.97 0.39
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.29 97.57 98.29 98.00 97.43 97.57 97.57 97.14 96.71 97.29 97.59 0.47
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 10.86 1.00 27.43 14.71 1.57 15.14 2.71 1.14 8.29 9.00 9.19 7.96
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 97.00 98.57 97.43 97.29 97.86 98.14 97.43 97.71 98.14 97.71 97.73 0.44
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 97.71 97.86 97.71 97.57 98.00 97.86 98.14 97.43 97.71 97.71 97.77 0.19
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 98.14 98.00 98.43 96.71 97.86 97.71 97.43 97.57 97.29 97.57 97.67 0.46
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.86 97.86 97.57 97.57 98.14 97.86 98.00 97.29 94.71 97.86 97.47 0.95
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 97.71 98.00 97.43 98.00 98.00 98.00 97.71 98.14 97.57 94.86 97.54 0.92
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 1.71 0.14 37.29 14.43 3.43 19.43 4.86 0.86 8.43 1.57 9.21 11.13
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 97.00 98.14 98.00 97.29 97.57 97.71 98.00 98.00 97.29 97.71 97.67 0.36
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 98.00 98.43 98.00 97.86 98.29 97.43 97.71 96.86 98.00 96.14 97.67 0.66
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 97.71 97.71 97.86 98.29 97.86 96.57 95.71 97.29 98.57 98.14 97.57 0.81
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.43 98.57 98.29 97.43 97.86 97.00 97.43 98.43 98.43 97.57 97.94 0.53
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 97.86 98.14 98.29 97.71 98.14 98.00 98.14 98.57 97.00 98.14 98.00 0.40
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 98.14 98.29 98.14 98.29 97.86 97.71 97.71 97.57 98.00 97.14 97.89 0.34
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 97.29 98.00 97.29 96.86 96.43 98.57 97.71 97.43 97.29 98.57 97.54 0.65
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.14 98.57 97.86 97.00 97.71 97.43 98.43 97.14 97.71 98.29 97.83 0.51
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 97.86 98.43 97.86 98.43 98.00 97.57 97.43 96.43 98.00 98.00 97.80 0.55
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 98.29 98.00 98.43 96.71 98.00 98.00 98.00 97.43 97.71 97.71 97.83 0.46
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.29 97.00 96.86 97.57 98.14 98.14 97.29 97.29 97.57 97.64 0.51
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 98.14 97.86 97.86 98.29 97.57 98.00 97.86 96.57 97.86 97.57 97.76 0.45
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 97.71 97.86 98.57 98.00 97.29 98.71 98.43 97.14 97.57 98.00 97.93 0.50
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 98.00 98.00 98.14 98.14 98.00 97.00 98.43 97.00 98.29 98.29 97.93 0.48
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.29 98.14 98.14 98.43 98.71 98.43 98.39 0.17
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 98.57 97.86 98.43 98.00 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.29 98.34 0.23
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.29 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.53 0.19
BERTwithProjection-bs32 98.71 98.71 98.14 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.60 0.21
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.59 0.12
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.00 98.57 98.71 98.41 0.21
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.00 98.86 98.43 98.29 98.50 0.26
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.86 98.57 98.00 98.43 98.50 0.20
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 99.00 98.57 98.57 98.14 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.59 0.23
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.46 0.11
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.47 0.16
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 98.71 98.43 99.00 98.29 98.29 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.29 98.56 0.23
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 98.71 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.00 98.43 98.86 98.51 0.24
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.69 0.12
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 97.86 98.57 98.71 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.54 0.28
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.71 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.57 98.57 98.14 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.63 0.20
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.57 98.57 98.29 98.14 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.86 98.51 0.21
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.14 98.71 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.57 98.29 98.71 98.71 98.46 0.22
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.14 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.29 98.49 0.19
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.71 98.57 98.60 0.17
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.71 98.57 98.29 98.86 98.14 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.29 98.57 0.24
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 98.00 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.00 98.29 98.29 98.43 98.14 98.29 98.29 0.19
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 98.00 98.29 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.14 98.29 98.71 98.86 98.49 0.28
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 98.71 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.14 98.57 98.61 0.19
BERTwithProjection-bs48 98.71 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.51 0.11
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 98.43 98.86 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.29 98.57 98.14 98.43 98.49 0.19
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 98.29 98.71 98.29 98.29 98.71 98.71 98.00 98.43 98.86 98.43 98.47 0.26
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.86 98.14 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.47 0.21
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.00 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.47 0.20
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 98.71 98.71 98.57 99.14 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.70 0.17
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 98.57 98.14 98.71 99.00 98.43 99.00 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.71 98.60 0.26
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.29 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.29 98.46 0.12
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.57 0.13
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.29 98.71 98.43 98.56 0.17
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.43 98.14 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.29 98.14 98.57 98.14 98.86 98.47 0.26
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.29 98.29 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.86 98.51 0.22
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 99.00 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.66 0.17
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.71 98.43 98.00 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.43 98.56 0.24
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.00 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.00 98.53 0.29
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.14 98.29 99.00 98.71 98.29 98.43 98.29 98.51 0.26
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 98.29 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.71 99.00 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.67 0.20
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 98.71 98.43 98.14 98.14 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.51 0.21

macsay-google - good with all but RoBERTa bs16

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 73.71 74.43 75.43 75.43 72.00 75.86 75.86 73.43 72.71 75.14 74.40 1.30
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 74.14 77.86 76.29 72.29 74.43 77.71 75.14 70.86 74.43 74.14 74.73 2.08
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 76.14 72.43 73.43 78.43 73.14 77.29 74.00 72.00 74.57 77.71 74.91 2.20
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 71.86 75.14 76.43 76.43 73.00 75.57 73.14 75.86 71.29 72.71 74.14 1.85
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 71.86 75.57 71.43 70.29 78.43 75.00 77.29 74.86 72.71 72.71 74.01 2.51
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 72.71 77.14 74.43 71.43 74.71 77.86 71.14 75.57 73.43 77.29 74.57 2.28
EmbraceBERT-bs16 76.57 71.14 73.86 74.71 68.57 74.86 75.00 73.86 73.14 70.71 73.24 2.29
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 74.43 71.14 70.14 73.14 74.14 74.43 75.00 74.43 71.00 72.86 73.07 1.64
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 74.14 75.29 77.29 75.00 70.86 74.43 73.86 75.29 72.43 73.86 74.24 1.65
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 13.71 10.43 11.57 15.14 11.00 11.71 8.14 18.43 13.86 8.29 12.23 2.99
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 73.14 76.29 74.43 73.43 74.29 76.71 73.71 75.71 73.71 73.00 74.44 1.27
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 71.00 74.00 77.14 76.14 73.00 75.00 71.29 77.57 72.43 75.71 74.33 2.23
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 73.00 68.71 74.29 74.86 71.29 75.29 78.00 73.29 73.43 72.14 73.43 2.36
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 72.86 75.57 72.14 70.57 70.86 78.00 73.00 74.29 71.43 75.71 73.44 2.29
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 68.29 70.57 77.86 71.14 73.00 72.43 72.00 74.14 73.71 69.00 72.21 2.61
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 12.00 7.43 7.14 11.57 9.86 7.86 7.14 17.00 28.71 10.00 11.87 6.31
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 79.43 76.29 74.00 69.57 71.00 72.29 73.57 79.86 74.57 71.43 74.20 3.28
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 75.71 76.57 77.43 76.14 68.29 72.86 74.71 78.29 75.71 74.29 75.00 2.68
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 72.29 69.86 72.43 72.71 72.57 75.00 75.57 70.57 71.43 73.86 72.63 1.71
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 72.43 70.00 73.86 73.29 73.29 78.29 74.71 72.00 77.14 78.14 74.31 2.62
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.43 74.57 72.14 76.57 73.29 72.71 74.43 73.43 73.00 76.14 74.07 1.37
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 76.29 72.86 75.29 71.14 73.71 72.43 75.29 76.14 72.14 75.57 74.09 1.76
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 74.57 76.57 75.86 73.29 76.43 72.57 73.71 71.43 72.86 70.71 73.80 1.93
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 72.57 78.57 77.86 76.71 71.29 75.14 71.29 74.57 74.71 74.43 74.71 2.39
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 75.43 72.57 71.14 77.14 75.86 76.14 76.14 75.57 69.43 76.00 74.54 2.43
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 75.00 76.29 77.43 76.29 71.14 73.29 72.29 71.86 73.86 74.29 74.17 1.98
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.29 75.86 75.57 72.71 73.57 75.43 69.86 75.00 76.86 77.00 74.61 2.04
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 78.86 76.57 76.14 72.57 73.43 76.71 73.14 74.43 74.86 76.00 75.27 1.84
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 73.71 76.71 75.43 70.29 73.29 74.14 72.57 75.00 76.29 74.57 74.20 1.79
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.71 74.86 79.29 74.57 76.29 76.43 75.57 76.43 77.29 71.86 75.73 1.86
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 75.86 75.00 75.71 72.71 72.43 74.57 76.57 73.57 72.71 76.71 74.59 1.56
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 73.29 74.14 75.57 73.57 74.86 72.71 75.71 75.00 73.57 77.43 74.59 1.34
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 73.29 78.57 77.14 74.29 76.14 74.43 74.86 77.14 72.57 75.71 75.41 1.78
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 75.57 74.00 76.00 73.57 72.14 73.71 74.00 72.14 73.57 74.43 73.91 1.18
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 81.29 72.00 73.00 76.43 74.57 75.57 73.00 73.00 74.00 76.43 74.93 2.57
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 72.86 77.00 74.14 73.29 73.86 72.57 74.57 75.71 72.00 76.57 74.26 1.62
EmbraceBERT-bs32 73.57 75.00 74.29 72.43 68.57 73.14 74.14 72.71 77.29 74.86 73.60 2.13
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 70.57 72.14 74.57 76.14 73.43 75.86 76.71 79.43 74.71 71.14 74.47 2.59
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 75.57 72.14 79.14 72.86 73.00 70.57 71.00 72.29 73.43 73.57 73.36 2.34
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 13.57 10.57 9.43 11.14 16.71 12.00 7.86 25.29 29.57 9.71 14.59 6.89
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 76.57 75.43 74.71 72.86 72.71 73.14 75.14 83.86 77.43 76.71 75.86 3.10
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 75.86 71.57 76.29 72.29 74.29 74.43 72.14 76.57 72.00 75.14 74.06 1.82
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 74.43 73.00 77.14 70.43 69.86 73.86 72.14 73.00 71.14 71.71 72.67 2.03
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 73.14 73.86 72.71 73.43 72.43 72.71 76.14 74.71 74.14 71.29 73.46 1.28
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 73.86 71.86 73.71 74.43 71.00 71.86 70.57 74.86 74.57 71.86 72.86 1.51
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 14.29 11.43 9.57 9.57 17.29 12.00 9.14 25.14 28.57 10.71 14.77 6.52
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 75.29 75.43 73.00 72.00 71.57 72.43 75.00 74.00 69.71 72.29 73.07 1.75
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 75.43 72.71 74.14 74.14 73.00 72.57 73.71 77.29 73.86 75.29 74.21 1.37
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 72.71 73.29 71.57 73.00 70.86 72.71 73.57 73.43 75.14 76.29 73.26 1.49
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 76.14 73.14 72.14 74.14 74.43 72.57 74.29 76.86 73.43 72.57 73.97 1.47
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.00 75.29 73.29 73.43 72.86 74.14 77.14 72.43 72.71 74.43 73.97 1.34
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 74.71 72.71 73.43 73.29 75.71 73.86 73.43 78.14 69.71 74.29 73.93 2.05
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 73.43 74.57 71.29 76.43 73.86 76.29 72.29 73.57 74.43 74.43 74.06 1.50
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 76.29 74.86 72.57 75.00 73.86 71.86 70.43 71.43 73.00 77.29 73.66 2.09
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 74.29 77.29 77.14 72.43 71.71 71.43 70.86 78.43 74.00 71.71 73.93 2.64
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 75.29 68.57 74.00 71.29 74.29 79.29 72.71 78.86 72.57 70.43 73.73 3.25
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 70.57 72.14 72.00 70.71 72.57 72.29 73.71 74.57 73.71 72.29 72.46 1.21
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 72.71 70.86 73.57 76.71 74.71 77.00 74.14 72.71 72.00 79.43 74.39 2.49
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 80.00 77.71 74.29 69.71 72.43 74.29 72.57 78.29 71.71 75.86 74.69 3.09
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.00 70.29 72.86 76.57 75.00 77.00 69.29 78.00 74.00 73.57 74.06 2.65
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 77.43 75.43 75.86 76.29 75.71 77.00 77.43 74.43 74.71 75.71 76.00 0.99
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 73.29 76.86 74.14 71.57 79.29 72.71 73.00 74.57 75.43 74.57 74.54 2.12
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 74.43 74.00 73.43 73.14 72.29 71.43 77.29 72.86 74.86 75.43 73.91 1.60
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 73.71 73.43 73.57 70.14 79.86 73.43 75.71 74.43 68.71 73.29 73.63 2.83
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 75.00 73.29 72.29 73.14 72.29 74.57 75.00 75.00 72.00 76.86 73.94 1.50
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 70.43 69.14 73.43 72.14 73.57 74.57 73.43 74.86 69.86 73.57 72.50 1.91
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 75.14 74.43 73.00 71.86 72.29 73.86 74.14 73.71 72.00 76.43 73.69 1.38
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 75.43 71.29 73.71 75.29 78.14 77.43 78.29 72.00 73.14 74.57 74.93 2.34
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 75.71 72.86 73.57 75.57 78.43 75.00 73.57 71.14 74.00 79.00 74.89 2.30
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 7.29 11.57 30.57 9.86 5.29 24.14 13.29 11.43 20.14 16.00 14.96 7.49
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 71.29 75.00 73.86 71.14 75.71 75.71 73.57 76.29 73.14 75.71 74.14 1.77
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 71.43 75.71 74.00 76.14 75.00 75.71 76.57 74.00 75.43 77.14 75.11 1.56
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 75.86 74.71 74.57 75.29 72.29 76.29 75.00 70.71 72.00 74.29 74.10 1.73
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 73.00 72.14 72.57 74.71 72.14 73.71 74.00 72.43 70.29 76.71 73.17 1.65
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 74.43 72.43 72.43 74.57 75.86 74.00 75.00 72.86 73.57 79.43 74.46 1.97
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 7.86 12.57 30.86 6.71 3.57 22.00 16.29 4.86 17.71 10.14 13.26 8.13
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 74.43 69.71 74.14 70.86 73.00 71.00 79.29 79.00 71.71 74.14 73.73 3.10
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 75.71 76.00 71.71 73.14 74.71 72.57 72.57 79.71 72.00 74.14 74.23 2.32
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 71.57 77.00 73.43 75.00 73.86 73.00 73.29 75.00 78.86 77.00 74.80 2.12
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 71.57 74.00 76.14 76.14 74.00 75.00 73.71 74.43 72.71 72.86 74.06 1.39
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.57 73.14 73.86 74.14 75.86 74.57 74.86 73.14 73.43 75.00 74.26 0.84
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 76.71 75.43 77.14 71.71 75.14 75.00 71.86 74.86 73.14 77.00 74.80 1.88
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 71.43 74.29 73.71 72.57 75.29 76.71 72.86 76.71 71.71 77.14 74.24 2.03
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 72.57 76.86 71.86 75.57 77.29 77.71 74.14 74.86 73.29 78.57 75.27 2.19
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 72.14 73.14 72.14 75.43 75.43 75.43 75.29 73.00 80.57 77.86 75.04 2.52
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 69.29 77.14 72.00 78.29 74.57 73.00 71.14 75.00 72.86 72.57 73.59 2.58
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.57 71.86 70.14 75.00 73.14 69.14 78.14 73.14 72.86 74.29 73.23 2.42
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 72.29 71.29 75.86 77.57 71.00 72.86 72.86 79.57 75.00 74.86 74.31 2.64
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 75.71 71.86 76.00 72.43 71.00 76.29 77.71 73.86 77.14 78.29 75.03 2.44
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 73.57 75.57 75.57 72.71 76.29 75.57 75.29 77.14 72.86 70.57 74.51 1.91
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 75.86 75.29 74.86 74.57 75.71 74.29 77.29 74.71 75.57 75.43 75.36 0.81
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 73.57 73.00 68.86 71.86 74.29 73.00 71.71 73.29 72.43 74.00 72.60 1.48
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 73.57 73.57 69.57 72.71 74.71 74.71 71.57 75.43 73.29 71.86 73.10 1.66
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 74.29 71.43 71.14 72.86 79.86 77.00 72.14 74.29 73.43 76.29 74.27 2.60
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 73.29 75.86 71.14 77.00 76.00 77.14 71.71 72.86 71.86 76.57 74.34 2.27
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 74.71 72.86 71.71 73.00 73.71 72.43 73.71 77.29 70.57 73.86 73.39 1.72
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 72.71 75.29 71.71 77.43 73.71 76.00 76.14 81.29 72.57 74.29 75.11 2.68
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 75.71 71.57 74.57 74.71 74.14 71.00 74.00 77.14 72.57 74.29 73.97 1.75
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 75.86 73.86 75.71 75.71 72.86 73.00 74.00 74.00 70.43 72.29 73.77 1.64
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 7.00 5.71 28.71 9.71 3.86 14.71 11.29 2.29 14.00 11.00 10.83 7.13
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 76.71 75.00 75.86 75.57 74.29 76.57 76.29 78.14 73.71 77.14 75.93 1.27
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 76.00 72.71 74.71 72.57 73.14 74.00 72.43 76.86 73.29 75.43 74.11 1.48
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 73.29 72.14 73.14 70.86 74.00 77.43 75.57 74.43 72.43 74.00 73.73 1.75
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 72.14 72.00 71.43 73.71 72.29 73.43 77.86 73.29 73.71 76.29 73.61 1.91
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 71.00 70.29 76.71 74.71 73.29 75.71 75.14 76.71 74.43 77.00 74.50 2.22
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 4.43 4.43 36.00 10.29 7.14 15.00 12.29 3.86 14.57 6.14 11.41 9.11
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 75.43 76.71 76.00 76.43 76.57 74.00 75.29 78.71 75.86 72.43 75.74 1.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 72.14 73.71 75.29 77.00 77.29 76.86 74.14 77.00 75.86 77.86 75.71 1.76
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 76.14 73.86 74.29 75.71 76.86 76.86 78.71 72.14 71.71 73.29 74.96 2.15
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 76.00 73.86 77.86 77.57 73.86 74.43 72.43 74.29 71.00 75.71 74.70 2.04
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 76.86 76.43 72.14 74.43 73.14 75.86 77.00 72.29 73.71 77.14 74.90 1.89
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 70.29 71.29 75.29 78.71 76.86 75.29 77.00 77.57 74.57 77.57 75.44 2.62
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 74.00 74.71 73.14 74.14 72.43 73.57 77.00 79.29 74.57 78.29 75.11 2.17
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 79.43 76.86 76.86 70.86 71.29 78.29 75.57 75.71 73.00 76.43 75.43 2.71
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 73.86 74.14 73.14 74.14 73.57 75.14 78.86 72.86 73.00 79.00 74.77 2.17
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 77.57 77.57 74.00 75.14 72.86 71.43 71.43 75.71 76.43 75.43 74.76 2.16
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 74.71 75.00 76.43 78.14 76.00 73.29 72.71 75.71 80.14 72.00 75.41 2.35
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 74.71 75.43 74.43 74.57 75.00 75.00 78.43 76.43 73.71 74.14 75.19 1.29
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 72.57 76.14 74.29 70.29 71.86 73.14 74.29 76.14 72.86 74.86 73.64 1.77
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 72.00 76.43 78.00 71.71 73.29 74.14 73.71 78.14 71.71 75.29 74.44 2.32
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 75.29 75.43 74.43 73.43 75.00 74.14 76.00 77.14 71.57 75.71 74.81 1.46
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 73.00 74.71 76.71 75.57 74.29 75.57 77.86 74.14 76.14 76.14 75.41 1.34
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 78.86 73.86 76.71 74.43 75.86 75.71 78.29 76.86 77.29 73.57 76.14 1.71
BERTwithProjection-bs32 75.71 73.43 75.86 76.00 75.29 76.00 74.00 75.14 75.86 76.14 75.34 0.88
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 76.29 75.43 75.00 72.43 76.00 75.57 77.00 73.71 75.29 75.14 75.19 1.23
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 75.29 73.14 76.00 76.43 73.00 73.86 76.57 79.00 73.00 75.71 75.20 1.86
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 76.00 78.00 74.71 75.29 74.71 79.43 72.29 75.29 76.43 73.00 75.51 2.02
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 76.14 75.57 76.57 76.57 76.86 76.14 75.71 75.86 77.43 78.86 76.57 0.93
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 77.14 76.14 76.71 73.29 76.29 77.14 74.57 76.14 75.43 77.43 76.03 1.23
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 74.86 72.14 74.57 75.00 73.00 76.29 72.71 74.71 77.71 73.71 74.47 1.60
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 75.57 72.86 76.43 77.29 73.86 75.86 74.14 73.86 75.71 76.71 75.23 1.39
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 78.57 73.00 76.14 73.43 75.00 75.29 74.00 78.29 74.00 75.00 75.27 1.81
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 73.43 75.71 74.29 74.86 73.86 74.71 73.57 77.71 79.43 76.14 75.37 1.84
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 73.71 75.86 73.86 77.14 75.71 79.14 76.14 73.29 73.29 73.57 75.17 1.87
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 76.29 75.29 76.29 76.71 77.29 74.14 73.43 74.71 73.14 76.00 75.33 1.35
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 78.00 78.00 75.43 75.00 75.86 75.14 76.86 78.14 80.29 76.86 76.96 1.59
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 75.14 77.14 72.57 74.86 75.57 76.86 73.43 76.14 76.00 74.29 75.20 1.39
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 74.43 75.00 76.86 75.00 75.00 75.57 76.00 74.57 75.86 74.00 75.23 0.81
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 75.43 76.00 74.14 76.57 74.00 75.57 74.86 74.71 76.43 74.43 75.21 0.88
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 76.29 74.43 72.43 75.43 74.00 76.00 75.14 78.14 74.57 74.57 75.10 1.45
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 73.86 75.71 75.43 74.71 74.57 77.57 76.86 75.71 79.29 73.57 75.73 1.67
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 75.14 73.43 74.14 75.71 72.71 74.14 75.00 75.86 71.71 76.14 74.40 1.38
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 73.71 72.86 75.00 75.71 72.14 75.71 76.86 73.43 72.86 74.71 74.30 1.45
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 77.14 74.29 72.43 72.71 79.43 75.71 78.00 75.57 74.14 77.71 75.71 2.22
BERTwithProjection-bs48 73.00 73.57 75.29 76.00 75.71 78.86 76.43 76.14 76.71 76.14 75.79 1.55
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 77.29 73.29 72.86 75.29 75.57 77.43 77.29 74.86 73.29 76.57 75.37 1.68
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 74.86 71.71 75.71 75.57 72.00 75.00 76.71 73.29 74.57 75.57 74.50 1.57
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 78.29 72.86 75.57 74.71 73.43 73.14 72.71 75.14 76.29 76.00 74.81 1.71
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 77.43 76.00 76.43 75.14 76.43 77.57 75.14 73.00 77.43 77.14 76.17 1.36
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 75.14 71.86 73.14 74.43 76.29 75.57 75.14 80.00 75.14 77.29 75.40 2.11
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 76.57 76.71 76.29 76.29 75.71 72.86 73.57 73.00 75.00 76.14 75.21 1.44
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 77.86 73.86 76.43 76.00 73.14 77.86 73.57 74.00 77.29 75.14 75.51 1.73
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 78.71 77.14 78.29 73.86 75.43 73.71 74.14 78.86 77.00 74.14 76.13 2.00
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 75.86 75.43 74.14 76.43 76.14 74.57 75.57 75.29 78.00 73.29 75.47 1.24
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 74.14 77.00 75.43 74.57 75.14 75.57 77.00 77.14 77.00 74.29 75.73 1.15
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 74.57 75.43 76.57 74.71 72.00 74.00 72.71 74.86 76.29 75.57 74.67 1.38
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 76.43 76.43 77.86 75.86 77.71 75.00 75.43 77.71 78.57 75.00 76.60 1.23
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 72.86 76.14 73.14 72.29 72.29 75.43 76.00 77.71 76.71 75.71 74.83 1.89
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 75.14 76.86 73.14 76.29 72.57 73.57 73.86 75.43 74.86 73.86 74.56 1.32
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 72.71 76.71 74.29 73.71 74.29 77.57 74.14 74.00 76.71 74.86 74.90 1.48
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 76.86 75.29 75.71 76.14 77.00 77.57 74.71 74.86 73.29 78.14 75.96 1.40
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 74.29 76.57 75.00 74.86 75.86 77.57 74.57 76.00 77.14 72.43 75.43 1.45

macsay-sphinx - only good with RoBERTa bs32

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 47.71 46.57 47.57 45.86 44.86 49.00 48.00 47.57 46.43 47.86 47.14 1.14
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 48.29 49.86 46.29 44.71 46.29 46.00 50.57 46.14 45.71 47.71 47.16 1.80
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 47.86 45.71 46.29 50.71 44.86 46.00 48.43 43.86 47.57 49.14 47.04 1.98
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 50.00 46.14 46.00 49.14 45.71 46.71 45.43 47.86 42.14 46.86 46.60 2.06
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 47.86 49.57 43.43 44.71 47.71 44.29 46.71 45.57 44.86 46.86 46.16 1.81
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 47.57 52.43 42.14 43.71 48.29 48.57 41.00 47.43 46.43 50.00 46.76 3.36
EmbraceBERT-bs16 47.14 45.57 50.14 45.14 38.14 48.29 48.29 46.86 49.57 45.14 46.43 3.22
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 45.43 41.14 39.71 45.57 45.43 48.43 50.29 50.29 46.86 47.00 46.01 3.29
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 47.29 48.86 48.00 43.00 39.14 46.29 44.57 47.14 49.86 49.14 46.33 3.11
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 12.57 13.57 12.29 12.29 14.29 14.14 9.00 18.71 15.57 9.86 13.23 2.63
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 49.00 44.00 45.14 46.71 47.86 46.14 44.57 46.43 44.86 42.57 45.73 1.80
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 45.71 47.29 45.29 49.14 48.71 46.43 43.00 47.00 45.71 44.29 46.26 1.79
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 49.14 39.14 45.29 49.43 42.71 45.29 48.29 46.14 44.14 42.71 45.23 3.07
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 45.14 46.00 43.86 48.71 49.00 48.00 44.14 49.86 46.71 48.57 47.00 2.03
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 44.43 41.00 45.57 47.43 47.86 47.71 43.57 47.43 49.29 44.29 45.86 2.40
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 11.57 9.43 9.86 12.14 14.71 11.86 9.00 14.71 20.43 10.43 12.41 3.27
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 49.43 46.86 40.00 45.43 44.29 40.43 46.29 44.43 42.71 43.43 44.33 2.74
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 48.71 48.86 43.86 45.29 46.14 45.57 44.71 49.43 44.57 45.57 46.27 1.89
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 43.43 40.71 40.29 41.29 43.29 41.71 49.57 44.57 46.00 43.43 43.43 2.65
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 49.43 44.29 43.29 44.00 42.00 50.00 49.00 44.29 48.71 47.14 46.21 2.80
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 48.71 43.43 40.57 47.29 44.71 44.86 47.86 45.14 47.57 47.00 45.71 2.34
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 49.00 48.14 46.00 44.43 46.43 44.71 46.71 48.43 41.71 46.43 46.20 2.06
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 50.43 45.43 40.57 42.29 49.29 45.29 46.71 42.43 47.57 43.14 45.31 3.06
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 51.43 45.29 46.29 47.43 44.43 47.43 46.71 46.43 48.57 46.71 47.07 1.82
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 48.71 46.57 40.29 49.86 43.43 47.86 45.57 48.00 40.29 47.43 45.80 3.22
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 45.00 49.43 46.14 49.71 41.00 47.29 42.71 46.29 49.57 49.43 46.66 2.90
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 44.71 48.57 45.43 42.29 45.29 52.29 45.57 48.43 49.00 44.29 46.59 2.77
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 48.29 41.71 47.14 39.00 43.29 48.14 45.00 44.86 41.57 45.00 44.40 2.88
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 45.43 44.71 42.43 44.00 44.57 48.14 46.86 43.29 46.00 44.14 44.96 1.61
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 48.86 46.71 47.29 46.14 47.71 47.29 50.00 46.86 53.14 41.14 47.51 2.89
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 46.71 46.14 47.43 43.86 43.86 47.14 47.71 48.71 45.57 48.57 46.57 1.64
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 48.57 44.86 44.71 47.00 45.57 49.00 50.57 43.43 43.29 51.00 46.80 2.71
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 46.86 46.57 46.14 49.00 48.14 46.14 48.71 49.43 44.71 50.57 47.63 1.73
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 47.29 45.29 50.00 46.43 45.29 45.00 46.29 47.57 48.14 47.57 46.89 1.47
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 48.57 47.86 42.14 46.86 47.14 46.71 49.14 43.71 48.43 48.57 46.91 2.16
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 45.00 50.14 45.14 43.57 43.86 45.71 44.29 45.57 48.57 44.00 45.59 2.04
EmbraceBERT-bs32 46.00 46.86 40.00 44.14 42.57 46.57 46.14 46.14 44.86 45.00 44.83 2.02
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 46.29 46.71 47.71 48.29 44.71 44.71 47.86 48.71 45.86 44.57 46.54 1.48
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 46.43 45.57 44.71 48.71 39.00 45.43 43.14 47.00 45.71 46.00 45.17 2.47
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 16.00 13.71 11.57 10.71 17.00 12.71 8.57 25.00 23.29 10.57 14.91 5.21
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 48.14 45.86 44.14 43.29 46.29 45.29 47.14 50.86 44.29 47.86 46.31 2.15
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 45.86 41.14 47.00 46.14 48.00 45.86 46.43 46.71 43.00 46.00 45.61 1.92
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 48.29 45.00 47.00 40.29 44.00 44.86 46.29 44.71 42.86 43.29 44.66 2.15
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 45.57 44.57 45.14 43.57 41.71 45.86 48.14 47.71 42.14 45.43 44.99 1.99
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 45.71 42.57 47.43 44.14 41.86 45.00 41.86 48.14 47.43 46.14 45.03 2.23
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 16.86 14.29 11.00 10.00 17.14 12.29 9.00 25.43 22.86 10.43 14.93 5.33
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 46.00 46.71 42.29 41.86 44.57 45.57 47.00 45.14 43.43 44.29 44.69 1.66
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 46.00 44.86 43.00 45.86 48.14 45.29 42.14 40.43 46.71 46.14 44.86 2.21
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 44.14 48.00 38.71 44.57 45.57 43.43 47.00 47.43 45.14 43.43 44.74 2.53
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 52.29 49.71 41.86 46.57 44.14 47.00 46.86 47.00 47.00 45.86 46.83 2.67
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 46.57 44.71 42.14 44.86 46.43 44.29 48.71 48.00 47.29 46.29 45.93 1.85
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 48.29 48.86 44.43 44.29 48.29 43.43 44.71 44.29 42.43 45.86 45.49 2.13
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 46.71 45.71 41.71 47.71 45.43 47.14 42.71 44.71 48.14 44.14 45.41 2.01
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 48.86 44.86 44.29 47.14 42.86 45.86 42.00 45.29 45.29 47.57 45.40 1.99
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 45.71 46.86 46.14 44.86 41.43 42.57 47.00 46.86 43.57 47.86 45.29 2.02
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 48.57 40.14 41.86 46.86 42.86 45.29 45.57 50.43 45.86 44.43 45.19 2.91
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 41.71 47.43 37.57 48.14 44.29 43.43 47.57 50.14 46.57 47.86 45.47 3.55
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 45.43 40.71 41.86 47.43 48.57 46.29 44.57 43.00 45.29 50.00 45.31 2.78
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 49.00 44.71 47.29 42.14 42.00 48.43 46.00 45.00 44.57 48.00 45.71 2.35
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 48.29 38.29 45.57 46.00 44.29 45.71 41.29 51.00 46.71 43.86 45.10 3.35
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 51.86 48.86 50.14 49.57 48.57 49.86 49.71 48.86 50.86 49.14 49.74 0.96
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 47.57 51.14 50.57 44.71 49.86 49.00 50.43 50.00 50.71 45.43 48.94 2.17
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 47.86 52.86 50.00 45.86 49.14 47.86 47.57 48.29 50.29 49.71 48.94 1.82
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 46.86 49.29 49.43 45.86 47.71 49.29 51.14 48.71 45.71 50.71 48.47 1.79
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 46.57 47.57 45.00 48.43 49.00 48.00 48.43 46.71 44.86 45.71 47.03 1.41
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 47.71 46.71 48.43 47.43 47.71 48.43 47.71 46.71 48.29 47.00 47.61 0.62
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 46.14 44.71 48.86 47.86 48.71 48.57 51.00 49.57 49.57 51.57 48.66 1.95
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 48.14 49.29 46.86 41.43 52.14 47.57 47.29 47.29 48.29 49.29 47.76 2.56
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 48.14 47.29 48.86 48.86 44.71 48.71 47.71 45.71 45.57 45.29 47.09 1.53
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 7.43 11.71 25.86 10.29 11.29 19.29 15.14 13.29 12.71 16.00 14.30 4.95
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 49.43 48.71 47.43 50.00 49.00 49.00 49.57 44.43 50.29 46.71 48.46 1.70
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 49.43 44.57 49.14 48.14 46.71 51.57 47.57 48.71 46.00 47.71 47.96 1.85
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 50.57 47.00 46.57 46.71 45.43 48.86 49.86 45.71 45.57 48.86 47.51 1.78
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 46.71 45.29 46.57 47.86 45.14 45.57 49.71 48.29 48.14 44.00 46.73 1.67
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 49.29 45.86 47.86 47.86 48.14 49.00 46.71 47.29 45.43 47.86 47.53 1.18
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 9.43 15.43 25.71 10.29 8.86 18.14 14.00 14.43 8.86 11.14 13.63 5.01
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 45.00 43.86 48.29 47.71 52.57 45.71 48.14 46.29 50.57 50.29 47.84 2.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 45.57 45.86 47.29 51.00 48.00 46.71 48.29 49.29 47.14 50.71 47.99 1.77
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 48.86 48.00 48.00 47.57 48.29 48.14 50.57 51.00 49.43 49.71 48.96 1.12
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 50.86 46.14 48.57 50.00 49.29 47.43 48.57 50.86 48.14 47.57 48.74 1.45
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 49.43 45.29 50.00 49.00 48.57 49.43 47.43 51.29 45.86 47.57 48.39 1.77
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 46.29 48.86 47.29 49.14 50.57 50.00 46.57 51.71 44.29 47.00 48.17 2.16
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 48.14 50.43 51.57 47.29 49.86 50.57 51.14 46.00 50.71 48.43 49.41 1.75
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 46.57 45.57 48.86 46.57 47.57 45.86 48.86 50.00 48.29 48.29 47.64 1.38
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 46.29 49.00 46.57 48.14 47.14 51.71 51.43 48.71 47.86 48.57 48.54 1.74
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 48.86 47.86 46.57 48.00 45.00 48.43 46.71 50.57 50.86 48.14 48.10 1.68
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 51.71 47.43 45.43 48.71 47.29 44.71 49.43 51.29 47.00 48.14 48.11 2.15
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 46.57 46.86 48.57 47.43 50.43 50.29 47.14 48.71 48.57 47.86 48.24 1.27
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 47.29 50.14 49.14 48.00 48.57 47.71 46.71 51.57 49.86 45.29 48.43 1.74
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 48.86 45.71 48.71 48.86 47.43 48.86 46.00 48.86 48.71 44.29 47.63 1.61
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 50.29 45.86 51.29 50.29 50.00 47.71 50.86 47.57 47.43 48.71 49.00 1.71
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 47.00 48.71 46.71 47.86 46.71 52.43 49.57 47.86 52.14 50.14 48.91 2.01
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 45.14 49.86 45.29 47.00 50.43 50.14 48.43 50.29 53.14 45.86 48.56 2.53
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 47.29 48.43 46.29 47.43 48.86 43.86 49.43 50.71 49.14 49.71 48.11 1.88
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 46.29 47.57 47.57 45.29 47.43 48.29 49.86 45.43 48.43 48.43 47.46 1.36
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 49.14 48.71 45.57 46.57 46.29 47.14 45.00 50.71 47.43 44.14 47.07 1.91
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 50.29 49.57 46.29 49.86 49.14 48.29 50.29 46.71 48.43 47.43 48.63 1.37
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 48.29 50.71 48.14 50.29 49.43 48.29 48.29 47.86 49.71 49.86 49.09 0.98
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 48.86 49.43 47.00 49.14 48.29 48.00 49.86 48.57 48.57 47.00 48.47 0.90
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 7.71 11.43 26.14 12.29 11.14 17.29 10.71 11.71 11.14 12.57 13.21 4.85
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 48.71 47.00 48.57 48.14 52.14 51.43 48.71 47.71 50.14 49.00 49.16 1.54
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 47.29 44.71 47.00 50.57 51.57 51.14 46.00 49.29 50.00 49.00 48.66 2.19
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 47.57 48.57 49.29 49.43 47.00 47.14 49.57 49.00 47.43 51.71 48.67 1.38
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 47.57 46.43 49.00 44.57 52.00 48.57 47.29 49.14 49.57 47.86 48.20 1.89
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 45.14 47.29 49.57 45.57 48.14 47.43 49.43 49.57 47.57 47.29 47.70 1.47
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 7.29 11.57 23.00 9.29 10.43 17.00 12.00 9.43 7.00 11.00 11.80 4.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 45.29 47.43 46.29 51.43 47.43 47.43 48.29 48.14 44.57 50.14 47.64 1.95
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 46.71 48.71 47.71 50.00 49.71 47.57 47.71 45.00 47.71 49.29 48.01 1.42
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 46.14 48.43 49.71 47.71 50.14 45.71 49.57 47.86 47.14 48.14 48.06 1.40
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 49.57 49.43 48.14 49.86 46.86 43.43 44.71 49.57 49.57 50.57 48.17 2.29
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 46.43 47.43 48.43 48.86 46.71 51.43 48.29 50.00 47.71 51.43 48.67 1.69
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 46.86 45.57 49.00 51.43 50.00 53.14 46.14 46.57 48.57 47.00 48.43 2.35
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 51.29 48.00 47.57 49.71 48.29 52.57 47.57 47.86 49.00 50.29 49.21 1.63
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 50.71 48.57 50.00 46.86 50.14 48.86 49.86 50.14 47.14 52.57 49.49 1.61
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 45.57 47.00 50.14 51.00 50.71 45.29 47.57 47.86 45.29 49.29 47.97 2.11
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 47.71 49.43 50.00 44.57 47.43 50.29 46.57 47.29 49.43 48.57 48.13 1.68
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 47.57 49.57 43.29 49.29 43.43 46.71 51.43 45.00 49.14 48.00 47.34 2.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 50.14 47.29 49.00 49.43 52.00 49.29 50.29 44.57 47.43 48.86 48.83 1.92
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 47.29 46.00 49.29 49.00 46.71 50.43 50.00 52.57 48.57 47.00 48.69 1.90
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 45.14 49.57 45.57 50.71 50.43 45.57 49.29 49.57 44.86 50.14 48.09 2.33
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 49.43 48.86 46.57 49.86 49.57 48.43 52.43 50.00 46.14 48.00 48.93 1.71
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 50.00 50.57 47.71 50.14 46.71 49.00 52.43 46.71 49.14 49.14 49.16 1.69
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 50.71 46.14 49.86 47.57 47.29 49.14 51.00 52.57 52.00 50.14 49.64 1.99
BERTwithProjection-bs32 50.29 50.14 47.71 48.43 49.43 47.43 49.43 51.86 48.71 51.14 49.46 1.36
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 48.43 53.71 48.43 49.43 47.71 48.71 50.43 47.86 48.14 50.86 49.37 1.76
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 47.00 54.29 45.43 48.71 49.86 46.29 49.29 51.43 45.71 49.43 48.74 2.63
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 44.29 48.29 48.14 50.00 50.71 48.14 47.57 48.00 49.29 46.00 48.04 1.76
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 51.57 50.00 52.57 48.14 52.29 48.29 52.86 49.57 52.71 49.29 50.73 1.78
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 53.00 48.86 52.57 49.43 52.57 49.43 49.43 48.29 50.00 49.86 50.34 1.62
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 46.29 44.43 47.00 47.29 49.29 48.71 49.00 47.43 50.00 48.57 47.80 1.57
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 49.71 49.14 47.29 47.43 47.71 47.14 49.14 46.57 47.14 49.57 48.09 1.11
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 51.57 50.00 54.43 49.14 49.86 48.86 52.57 49.43 48.43 51.86 50.61 1.82
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 49.43 50.71 50.71 50.57 48.57 50.86 50.29 47.86 52.00 50.86 50.19 1.16
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 51.71 50.29 43.71 48.43 49.00 51.14 50.29 50.14 48.57 47.57 49.09 2.17
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 49.57 46.71 49.14 51.86 48.29 49.29 52.57 47.00 49.86 49.14 49.34 1.75
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 51.71 52.29 49.86 48.00 50.86 50.00 52.57 52.86 52.71 49.71 51.06 1.55
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 48.43 50.43 48.43 51.00 51.43 48.57 49.29 48.14 48.86 53.00 49.76 1.55
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 50.29 50.71 46.71 48.14 48.43 50.00 51.71 48.29 51.57 49.57 49.54 1.54
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 48.00 46.14 48.14 50.71 46.57 46.71 47.29 51.14 51.86 47.86 48.44 1.95
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 53.29 52.14 48.57 50.86 48.43 51.00 51.29 52.29 50.43 50.00 50.83 1.48
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 48.71 50.86 49.43 49.57 49.00 50.29 50.86 51.00 51.29 51.14 50.21 0.91
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 45.57 49.43 49.00 48.00 44.43 48.29 52.00 49.29 43.71 46.86 47.66 2.41
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 50.43 49.00 49.86 47.29 47.29 49.00 45.43 48.43 47.86 47.14 48.17 1.40
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 47.57 48.00 50.29 49.00 52.71 51.29 48.71 51.00 48.00 49.00 49.56 1.60
BERTwithProjection-bs48 50.86 47.86 46.43 48.86 48.86 53.00 52.14 49.71 49.14 52.71 49.96 2.06
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 47.14 46.86 49.14 51.14 44.57 46.57 51.14 51.43 47.14 47.71 48.29 2.21
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 47.29 49.57 47.71 46.00 48.14 46.29 47.86 45.86 46.43 46.86 47.20 1.10
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 48.14 42.71 48.86 50.57 43.57 49.57 48.14 51.43 50.29 46.57 47.99 2.76
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 52.43 49.86 53.14 46.14 53.43 48.14 49.14 49.14 51.29 50.29 50.30 2.20
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 49.00 50.43 48.86 48.00 49.29 48.86 48.00 51.00 51.43 50.71 49.56 1.18
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 46.00 47.57 48.43 44.71 46.29 43.86 45.86 44.86 47.14 44.00 45.87 1.45
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 45.00 47.71 48.00 50.43 48.86 49.29 49.14 47.57 51.00 50.00 48.70 1.64
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 53.00 50.14 50.00 49.00 47.29 51.00 51.29 50.14 50.14 47.29 49.93 1.66
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 48.86 47.57 50.71 51.29 50.00 50.00 51.86 50.14 49.00 48.57 49.80 1.24
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 50.14 46.57 49.14 47.86 47.57 46.00 45.00 48.71 51.00 49.57 48.16 1.81
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 49.57 46.57 51.14 50.14 47.14 47.00 45.71 50.00 46.14 47.00 48.04 1.85
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 49.71 49.71 51.29 48.86 47.86 51.71 51.71 52.00 49.57 50.14 50.26 1.31
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 52.86 50.57 50.00 51.29 49.29 49.00 52.43 49.57 49.14 47.86 50.20 1.51
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 44.14 50.14 48.00 47.00 48.00 48.29 46.14 45.71 45.00 46.43 46.89 1.68
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 46.71 49.29 46.29 45.86 45.71 49.71 49.86 42.14 50.71 47.71 47.40 2.46
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 47.86 49.86 48.00 48.43 47.14 50.86 47.14 49.43 47.57 53.71 49.00 1.95
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 51.86 52.14 49.14 49.29 48.29 45.71 48.29 48.14 52.57 45.86 49.13 2.31

macsay-witai - not good

  • Epoch 100
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 94.71 94.71 94.43 93.86 94.29 94.71 94.57 94.43 94.14 94.57 94.44 0.27
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 94.43 94.86 95.00 93.43 94.71 94.43 95.14 94.29 94.43 94.86 94.56 0.46
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 94.00 94.29 94.57 94.43 94.29 94.86 94.71 93.86 94.71 94.71 94.44 0.32
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 93.71 93.71 94.00 94.14 93.71 93.43 92.71 94.29 92.71 94.57 93.70 0.58
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 94.14 94.00 93.86 94.00 94.43 94.57 94.14 94.29 94.00 93.71 94.11 0.25
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 93.43 94.43 94.14 94.14 94.14 94.14 94.14 94.57 93.86 94.29 94.13 0.30
EmbraceBERT-bs16 94.86 93.29 94.29 94.43 92.86 94.43 93.86 94.00 93.86 94.43 94.03 0.57
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 94.29 92.57 93.29 94.57 94.14 94.29 94.43 94.14 94.00 94.43 94.01 0.59
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 93.14 95.14 94.14 94.00 93.00 93.57 95.00 94.29 93.86 94.71 94.09 0.69
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 16.00 4.43 10.00 15.71 12.14 9.29 1.71 19.29 8.43 2.57 9.96 5.63
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 93.71 93.71 92.86 94.71 93.57 93.71 94.57 94.14 94.86 94.14 94.00 0.58
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 93.43 94.57 93.57 94.57 92.71 94.00 94.29 93.71 94.29 94.71 93.99 0.60
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100 93.43 90.86 93.71 94.00 94.00 94.29 94.86 93.57 93.29 92.71 93.47 1.03
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 93.71 94.43 93.71 93.71 92.86 94.71 93.86 93.14 93.29 94.71 93.81 0.61
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 92.57 94.00 94.71 93.57 93.43 94.29 94.57 94.29 93.86 93.00 93.83 0.65
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100 13.14 1.86 6.00 12.00 11.86 6.43 3.00 20.14 21.14 2.29 9.79 6.69
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 94.29 93.71 93.57 94.14 93.14 92.43 94.14 94.29 93.86 94.29 93.79 0.58
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 94.14 95.00 94.86 94.29 92.00 94.00 94.00 94.00 94.00 93.29 93.96 0.80
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 94.43 92.71 93.29 94.57 93.57 94.14 94.71 93.86 94.43 94.71 94.04 0.64
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 93.00 93.14 93.29 93.29 94.29 95.00 94.43 94.29 94.14 95.14 94.00 0.74
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.14 94.29 93.71 94.43 94.29 92.86 94.57 92.71 94.43 94.71 94.01 0.67
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 94.57 94.57 94.86 94.29 94.00 94.86 94.00 95.00 93.57 95.14 94.49 0.48
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.57 94.57 93.71 94.29 94.29 93.71 94.71 93.14 94.14 92.71 93.99 0.62
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.29 94.14 93.86 95.00 92.86 94.14 92.71 93.86 94.43 93.86 93.91 0.65
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches 93.71 93.43 92.57 94.86 93.14 93.86 94.29 94.14 93.29 94.29 93.76 0.64
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.00 93.29 93.57 94.00 93.00 94.43 93.14 92.57 93.86 95.71 93.76 0.84
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.57 94.14 94.29 93.29 94.00 94.29 93.14 94.29 95.71 94.14 94.09 0.68
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches 95.00 93.43 94.00 93.43 93.29 94.14 93.86 93.29 94.14 93.00 93.76 0.56
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.14 95.00 94.57 93.14 93.71 94.57 93.57 93.71 94.43 93.57 94.04 0.56
FrozenCEBERT-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.86 94.71 93.86 93.86 93.00 94.00 94.43 94.29 94.14 92.57 93.87 0.61
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 94.71 94.86 94.57 94.00 94.43 94.43 94.71 94.71 94.14 94.71 94.53 0.26
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 93.43 94.43 94.29 94.00 94.29 94.14 94.86 94.14 94.71 93.86 94.21 0.39
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 94.43 95.00 94.43 94.29 94.14 94.43 94.71 94.43 94.29 94.71 94.49 0.24
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 94.71 94.29 94.71 94.14 94.43 94.29 94.57 94.29 94.57 94.86 94.49 0.22
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 94.86 94.43 94.29 94.29 94.43 94.43 93.43 94.29 94.71 94.57 94.37 0.36
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 94.14 94.57 94.14 93.71 94.29 93.71 94.14 94.86 94.00 94.43 94.20 0.34
EmbraceBERT-bs32 94.71 94.57 94.00 94.14 93.29 94.00 94.14 95.14 93.71 94.57 94.23 0.51
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 94.14 93.57 94.57 94.86 94.43 94.29 94.57 95.29 94.14 93.57 94.34 0.50
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 94.43 94.14 94.57 94.43 93.14 94.00 93.14 94.14 94.57 94.29 94.09 0.50
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 11.86 9.43 7.43 3.00 16.14 8.57 3.57 26.57 27.43 3.00 11.70 8.60
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 95.00 94.86 94.29 94.29 94.57 94.29 94.71 95.57 93.86 93.29 94.47 0.60
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 94.57 93.86 94.14 94.57 93.86 95.14 94.29 94.57 94.00 94.14 94.31 0.38
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100 94.00 94.86 93.57 93.57 92.43 94.29 94.00 93.86 93.14 94.00 93.77 0.62
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 94.57 94.57 92.29 93.86 93.86 94.29 93.14 94.43 93.43 93.86 93.83 0.68
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 93.71 95.00 93.86 94.86 93.86 94.57 92.86 94.57 94.71 94.14 94.21 0.62
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100 12.29 8.71 7.57 3.71 18.00 9.57 3.86 25.71 27.71 3.14 12.03 8.49
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 93.86 94.43 93.29 93.57 94.57 94.00 93.29 94.00 93.29 94.00 93.83 0.44
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 94.29 94.00 94.14 94.71 93.57 94.71 93.29 94.00 94.43 94.29 94.14 0.43
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 93.57 95.00 91.71 94.14 94.00 94.29 94.29 94.43 94.57 93.57 93.96 0.85
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.00 94.00 93.71 94.71 94.29 94.86 93.71 94.71 93.43 94.14 94.16 0.46
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.29 93.14 93.29 94.71 94.29 94.86 94.71 95.57 94.71 94.43 94.40 0.69
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 94.57 95.14 93.57 94.29 95.00 94.29 94.43 94.86 94.00 93.86 94.40 0.48
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 92.86 94.29 92.86 94.14 94.00 94.29 93.71 93.71 93.86 94.14 93.79 0.50
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.86 94.29 93.86 94.29 93.43 93.43 93.71 94.43 94.57 94.00 94.09 0.46
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches 93.43 95.00 93.86 94.00 93.14 93.57 92.86 94.71 94.00 93.43 93.80 0.63
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 93.71 93.43 93.43 94.00 95.00 94.00 92.86 94.57 93.71 93.29 93.80 0.60
FrozenEmbraceBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 92.57 94.14 91.86 93.71 93.86 94.14 94.57 95.14 93.43 93.29 93.67 0.90
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches 93.86 93.43 93.00 93.86 94.29 94.86 92.71 94.43 92.86 94.14 93.74 0.68
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.86 94.43 94.29 93.00 93.43 94.57 94.57 94.29 92.43 94.71 94.06 0.78
FrozenCEBERT-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.57 93.57 92.43 93.86 94.00 93.86 92.14 94.43 93.71 94.00 93.66 0.75
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 93.57 93.57 94.00 94.00 94.86 94.29 93.14 94.00 93.86 93.86 93.91 0.43
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 92.86 93.71 93.71 91.57 93.00 93.29 92.86 92.14 94.43 92.71 93.03 0.78
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 93.57 94.43 93.71 92.43 93.29 92.29 93.71 92.86 93.86 93.00 93.31 0.64
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 92.43 93.57 92.86 92.86 92.86 91.29 92.57 94.43 91.29 92.86 92.70 0.89
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 92.00 92.86 92.71 92.86 92.57 92.57 93.86 93.71 93.29 93.71 93.01 0.58
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 92.71 90.29 94.14 91.57 93.86 93.29 94.14 93.29 93.14 92.43 92.89 1.15
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 92.71 94.86 92.86 94.00 92.14 93.57 93.57 92.86 91.86 93.71 93.21 0.86
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 92.43 92.86 92.71 91.29 94.00 93.00 94.29 92.57 93.86 92.71 92.97 0.84
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 92.29 91.71 93.86 94.29 92.29 93.00 94.14 92.14 94.14 94.00 93.19 0.95
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 3.29 5.00 27.57 15.57 3.86 25.57 6.29 8.29 11.29 15.00 12.17 8.28
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 93.00 93.71 92.00 93.57 92.43 91.86 93.00 93.14 93.43 94.29 93.04 0.73
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 91.71 92.71 93.86 93.71 93.57 93.14 94.14 92.71 91.43 92.14 92.91 0.89
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 94.43 94.14 93.14 92.86 94.14 94.43 93.57 93.14 93.00 93.57 93.64 0.57
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 92.57 93.86 92.71 93.14 93.57 94.00 92.43 93.29 91.86 93.29 93.07 0.64
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 92.86 93.29 94.00 92.57 92.57 93.29 94.00 93.00 91.00 93.86 93.04 0.85
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100 1.29 17.71 28.14 14.86 2.00 23.00 7.86 6.14 12.00 5.43 11.84 8.55
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1 93.14 93.57 94.29 91.14 94.29 93.00 93.43 92.43 93.00 93.14 93.14 0.86
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.3 92.14 93.43 93.14 93.43 92.57 93.14 93.86 93.00 93.71 94.71 93.31 0.67
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 93.29 93.71 92.86 93.43 92.86 93.43 93.29 93.71 92.43 93.57 93.26 0.40
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 93.57 93.14 92.71 93.71 92.86 93.86 94.29 93.00 92.86 93.14 93.31 0.49
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 92.71 91.86 93.00 92.71 92.86 93.43 93.57 93.57 94.14 94.57 93.24 0.74
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 92.43 93.71 93.29 93.14 93.00 93.57 93.43 93.86 92.43 93.57 93.24 0.47
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 93.14 92.86 94.14 94.14 94.29 93.57 92.57 93.43 94.14 91.86 93.41 0.77
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.14 93.71 93.14 93.14 93.71 93.86 93.43 93.43 91.71 93.71 93.30 0.59
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches 92.57 93.29 92.57 93.00 93.00 93.71 93.71 92.86 94.43 92.29 93.14 0.62
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 90.71 92.43 93.43 93.71 93.00 93.86 93.57 93.43 92.43 93.71 93.03 0.91
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.14 92.86 92.86 92.29 91.71 92.00 93.57 92.57 93.43 93.14 92.76 0.58
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches 93.00 93.57 92.43 91.57 92.57 92.71 93.14 93.00 93.43 94.29 92.97 0.69
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.1 92.29 94.14 93.71 94.00 93.29 93.43 92.57 92.57 93.00 93.14 93.21 0.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.14 92.57 92.57 92.86 91.86 92.86 92.71 92.43 93.14 94.00 92.81 0.53
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 93.86 94.29 93.29 94.14 94.29 93.71 93.57 93.57 93.43 94.00 93.81 0.34
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 93.29 94.29 92.00 92.43 93.71 92.86 93.57 94.29 93.29 93.43 93.31 0.70
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 91.86 93.29 93.57 92.57 93.86 92.57 93.43 94.29 92.57 91.29 92.93 0.88
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 92.86 93.14 92.43 92.71 93.29 92.57 94.00 92.14 92.57 94.14 92.99 0.63
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 92.57 93.29 93.57 93.57 93.14 92.29 93.14 91.86 93.29 94.57 93.13 0.72
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 93.14 92.71 93.14 93.00 92.86 92.43 93.14 92.86 92.43 94.00 92.97 0.43
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 93.29 93.14 93.57 93.29 94.43 93.00 93.29 93.86 93.57 93.86 93.53 0.40
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 94.14 93.43 93.86 94.00 93.71 92.57 93.86 94.14 92.57 94.29 93.66 0.59
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 93.57 92.43 93.43 93.14 93.00 94.00 93.57 93.00 91.71 92.71 93.06 0.62
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 9.86 3.29 27.29 15.14 2.71 15.00 4.71 1.86 8.00 9.43 9.73 7.39
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 92.29 93.86 93.29 92.57 93.29 94.29 92.57 94.00 93.43 93.14 93.27 0.62
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 93.43 94.00 93.43 92.43 92.57 93.86 93.86 92.00 92.86 93.71 93.21 0.66
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 93.29 93.29 94.29 92.29 93.29 93.43 92.86 93.29 92.71 92.86 93.16 0.50
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 93.71 94.00 93.14 94.14 93.71 93.71 94.29 91.71 90.29 93.86 93.26 1.21
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 93.00 92.57 93.43 93.43 93.29 93.71 92.86 92.86 93.00 90.71 92.89 0.79
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100 1.71 2.00 36.71 15.14 3.86 19.57 6.14 1.43 7.86 2.71 9.71 10.71
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1 93.00 94.43 94.00 92.71 93.71 94.00 94.00 93.00 93.14 92.71 93.47 0.59
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.3 93.00 93.86 93.57 92.86 93.43 93.57 94.00 92.57 94.14 91.57 93.26 0.74
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 93.86 93.71 92.86 94.00 93.14 93.29 91.71 93.29 93.57 93.43 93.29 0.62
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 94.57 93.57 94.71 92.00 93.71 92.57 91.86 93.86 93.57 93.14 93.36 0.92
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.43 93.57 93.71 92.71 93.43 93.00 92.86 92.57 92.57 93.00 93.09 0.40
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 93.71 94.00 93.71 92.71 92.86 93.14 93.29 93.14 93.57 93.14 93.33 0.39
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 92.86 93.14 93.43 92.29 91.86 94.14 94.00 92.29 92.43 94.29 93.07 0.82
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.00 93.43 93.71 93.29 92.29 93.29 93.43 92.14 93.14 93.29 93.20 0.55
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches 92.86 93.71 92.86 93.57 93.71 93.00 93.86 92.14 92.86 94.00 93.26 0.57
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 93.43 93.43 94.14 92.29 92.86 92.29 93.43 92.86 92.57 93.43 93.07 0.57
FrozenEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 93.57 92.71 93.00 92.14 93.86 93.14 92.71 93.29 93.00 93.57 93.10 0.48
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches 94.43 92.29 93.29 93.57 92.14 93.29 92.86 91.57 93.00 93.14 92.96 0.76
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.1 92.71 92.57 94.14 92.57 92.43 93.71 94.14 92.86 93.29 93.57 93.20 0.63
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32+Branches+Dropout0.3 94.14 93.29 93.86 93.29 93.86 92.71 93.00 93.14 94.14 93.29 93.47 0.47
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 94.71 94.14 94.43 92.57 94.29 93.29 93.86 94.43 93.00 93.86 93.86 0.66
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 92.86 94.00 94.00 93.00 94.00 94.29 94.71 94.43 94.86 94.29 94.04 0.62
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 95.57 94.29 93.57 94.43 94.57 94.14 94.71 93.57 93.71 93.57 94.21 0.61
BERTwithProjection-bs32 94.43 93.43 93.86 93.86 93.86 93.29 94.14 94.00 94.57 94.43 93.99 0.40
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 94.57 94.43 93.43 94.14 94.86 94.43 93.86 93.71 94.43 94.57 94.24 0.42
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 93.71 92.71 93.57 93.57 93.00 94.29 94.14 94.43 93.14 94.29 93.69 0.57
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 94.29 94.00 93.86 94.00 94.14 94.00 93.29 94.29 94.43 93.43 93.97 0.35
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 94.29 94.00 94.43 93.57 94.00 93.71 94.14 93.00 93.71 94.43 93.93 0.42
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 94.00 94.29 94.00 94.14 94.29 93.00 93.57 94.71 94.71 94.57 94.13 0.50
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32 94.57 93.14 94.57 94.00 94.29 94.71 93.57 93.86 93.86 94.43 94.10 0.48
EBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 94.14 93.71 93.29 94.00 94.00 94.29 93.00 93.43 94.71 94.29 93.89 0.50
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 93.71 94.00 94.57 94.14 94.29 93.71 94.00 94.57 94.14 93.86 94.10 0.29
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 94.14 93.57 92.57 94.86 93.57 93.86 93.86 94.29 94.29 94.29 93.93 0.58
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.00 94.43 94.00 94.00 94.71 94.14 94.57 93.14 94.29 93.86 94.11 0.42
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 94.14 94.57 94.57 94.00 94.14 94.57 94.29 93.43 93.57 94.29 94.16 0.38
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.57 94.14 93.86 93.71 92.71 94.57 93.71 94.43 93.86 92.86 93.84 0.61
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 93.29 93.71 94.14 93.14 93.57 94.43 93.71 94.29 94.43 94.14 93.89 0.44
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 93.00 93.86 94.29 93.29 94.29 93.29 94.57 93.43 94.71 93.43 93.81 0.58
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 93.86 94.29 93.43 94.43 94.57 93.86 94.29 94.14 94.14 93.71 94.07 0.33
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.57 93.29 93.00 94.71 93.71 94.57 94.14 94.00 94.00 94.14 94.01 0.53
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs32-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 94.71 95.14 94.00 94.00 94.29 94.86 94.43 93.86 94.57 93.43 94.33 0.49
  • Epoch 100 - bs48 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 94.00 94.57 94.57 94.29 94.00 94.29 94.71 94.71 94.00 94.57 94.37 0.28
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 93.57 94.57 93.86 94.57 93.86 94.29 94.29 93.71 94.00 94.14 94.09 0.33
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 95.00 94.00 94.14 93.86 93.71 94.71 94.57 93.71 94.00 94.57 94.23 0.43
BERTwithProjection-bs48 94.43 93.57 94.29 94.14 94.14 93.86 94.57 93.71 94.71 94.71 94.21 0.38
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 94.71 94.00 93.71 94.14 94.43 94.57 94.29 93.57 93.86 94.14 94.14 0.35
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 94.00 93.43 93.14 94.14 94.00 93.43 93.71 93.00 94.14 94.29 93.73 0.43
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 94.14 93.86 94.57 93.86 93.86 94.57 94.29 94.43 94.57 94.43 94.26 0.29
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 94.86 94.43 94.57 94.14 93.71 94.43 93.57 94.29 94.00 94.43 94.24 0.37
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 94.29 94.29 93.71 95.00 94.71 94.00 94.71 94.43 94.71 94.43 94.43 0.36
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48 94.00 94.00 93.86 94.86 94.14 93.86 94.57 94.00 95.14 94.57 94.30 0.43
EBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 94.00 94.29 94.57 94.00 93.86 94.43 93.71 94.57 94.29 94.29 94.20 0.28
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 94.71 94.71 94.57 94.14 94.00 93.29 93.71 95.29 94.57 94.57 94.36 0.55
EBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 93.71 94.29 93.00 93.57 94.29 94.71 94.29 93.86 93.86 94.29 93.99 0.46
------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.71 93.71 94.00 94.14 94.86 94.29 94.14 93.86 94.43 93.86 94.20 0.36
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 94.00 94.14 94.57 93.43 94.00 94.14 94.43 93.43 94.29 94.29 94.07 0.36
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.71 94.71 94.14 94.29 94.29 95.00 94.14 94.14 95.14 94.00 94.46 0.38
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 93.71 93.86 93.43 95.00 93.14 95.00 93.00 94.86 94.43 94.71 94.11 0.74
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.14 94.00 94.14 94.14 93.00 94.43 94.71 94.14 94.00 94.14 94.09 0.42
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 94.29 94.57 94.14 94.00 94.00 94.43 93.86 94.14 93.86 95.00 94.23 0.34
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 94.00 93.00 93.86 94.14 94.57 94.86 94.29 94.14 94.00 94.43 94.13 0.47
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 94.86 94.43 94.00 93.43 94.14 94.86 93.57 93.86 93.43 93.43 94.00 0.53

STT Error: trained and tested with INCOMPLETE data

gtts-google

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 75.14 74.71 75.71 75.43 75.00 75.57 76.00 75.86 75.43 75.57 75.44 0.37
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 75.14 74.86 75.43 75.43 75.29 74.29 75.00 75.57 75.00 75.14 75.11 0.35
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 75.43 75.57 75.00 76.14 75.14 74.86 75.29 75.43 74.71 76.00 75.36 0.44
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 76.29 74.57 75.14 75.29 75.43 74.86 75.29 76.00 74.86 75.71 75.34 0.51
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 75.43 75.00 75.71 75.29 74.43 75.57 75.29 75.57 75.29 75.57 75.31 0.35
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 75.71 75.14 75.57 75.86 75.14 75.14 74.29 75.00 74.00 75.29 75.11 0.56
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 75.86 74.29 74.71 74.71 71.14 75.71 74.57 74.57 74.71 75.43 74.57 1.25
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 75.14 74.00 76.14 75.29 74.71 75.00 75.00 75.00 74.57 74.57 74.94 0.53
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 75.00 75.00 75.14 75.43 74.43 74.29 75.43 75.57 75.43 75.14 75.09 0.41
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 75.00 74.86 75.43 76.00 75.57 75.00 75.57 75.57 74.57 75.29 75.29 0.40
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 74.71 74.86 74.43 75.43 74.43 75.14 74.86 75.71 74.57 75.86 75.00 0.49
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 74.57 75.00 74.71 75.14 75.14 75.14 75.43 74.86 75.14 75.00 75.01 0.23
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 75.14 74.57 75.00 77.00 74.86 75.00 75.14 75.00 74.71 75.00 75.14 0.64
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 75.14 75.14 75.00 77.00 74.14 75.57 75.14 75.57 74.71 75.29 75.27 0.70
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 75.14 75.00 75.43 75.14 74.71 75.00 75.43 75.29 75.00 75.00 75.11 0.21
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 74.57 75.14 75.00 75.29 72.43 74.86 74.71 75.14 75.00 72.14 74.43 1.09
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 75.29 74.71 75.71 75.71 74.14 75.29 74.00 71.71 73.86 74.57 74.50 1.13
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 75.57 76.57 76.57 76.00 74.86 75.14 75.29 75.71 75.57 75.43 75.67 0.54
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 75.57 74.86 75.57 75.86 75.43 75.43 75.71 75.14 76.14 75.00 75.47 0.37
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 75.71 75.00 75.29 74.86 75.00 75.29 76.00 75.71 75.29 76.00 75.41 0.40
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 76.14 76.00 76.00 76.00 75.14 75.43 75.00 74.86 75.14 75.71 75.54 0.46
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 75.29 75.29 75.86 74.71 74.71 75.00 75.43 75.29 74.86 75.86 75.23 0.39
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 75.00 75.43 75.71 74.43 75.00 75.14 74.86 74.86 75.57 75.14 75.11 0.36
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 75.00 75.71 74.71 71.29 74.29 75.86 74.71 75.29 74.57 74.86 74.63 1.21
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 71.43 71.86 75.71 74.86 74.71 75.71 74.71 75.29 75.29 75.00 74.46 1.45
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 74.86 75.29 75.86 75.43 74.57 76.14 75.57 74.86 75.86 74.29 75.27 0.58
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 72.00 75.71 75.57 76.00 75.57 75.57 75.71 74.57 75.29 74.86 75.09 1.11
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 75.57 75.43 74.29 75.14 74.57 72.29 74.86 75.14 75.14 75.86 74.83 0.95
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 75.71 74.86 75.57 75.43 74.57 75.14 75.86 75.14 74.86 76.00 75.31 0.45
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 75.57 74.43 76.29 74.86 74.43 75.71 74.43 75.43 75.00 76.00 75.21 0.65
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 75.29 75.71 75.43 74.71 74.43 75.14 75.43 74.71 74.57 75.71 75.11 0.45
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 74.71 76.14 74.00 75.14 71.71 75.71 74.86 71.14 75.29 74.71 74.34 1.56
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 74.00 75.00 74.71 75.14 74.29 74.57 72.43 74.29 73.57 74.71 74.27 0.76
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 30 | Model |Run1 |Run2 |Run3 |Run4 |Run5 |Run6 |Run7 |Run8 |Run9 |Run10|Mean |Std | | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | RoBERTa-bs16 | | EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG |74.86|75.14|74.86|75.71|75.57|76.14|75.86|74.43|74.71| - |75.25|0.55|

  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)

Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std

gtts-sphinx

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 96.29 95.86 96.29 96.57 96.71 96.29 95.86 96.00 96.29 96.00 96.21 0.27
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.43 95.43 95.57 96.29 96.29 96.43 96.14 96.57 96.00 96.43 96.16 0.36
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 95.86 96.00 96.29 95.86 96.29 96.43 95.71 95.86 96.29 95.71 96.03 0.25
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 95.71 96.00 95.71 96.43 95.71 95.71 96.43 95.43 95.71 95.43 95.83 0.34
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 95.86 95.71 96.00 95.86 95.57 96.43 95.86 95.43 96.00 95.71 95.84 0.26
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 96.00 95.57 95.86 95.86 95.71 95.57 96.14 95.86 96.43 95.57 95.86 0.26
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 96.43 95.57 95.86 95.29 96.71 95.86 95.43 95.86 96.00 95.29 95.83 0.45
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 96.00 95.00 95.29 96.00 95.14 94.43 96.00 95.86 96.29 94.86 95.49 0.59
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 96.29 95.86 95.71 95.71 96.14 95.57 95.43 96.43 95.86 95.86 95.89 0.30
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 96.00 95.86 96.14 96.00 96.14 96.00 96.29 96.14 96.14 96.29 96.10 0.13
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 95.14 95.00 95.14 95.14 95.86 96.00 95.71 96.00 95.57 95.71 95.53 0.37
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 95.00 95.29 94.71 95.86 95.14 95.29 95.86 95.57 96.00 95.86 95.46 0.41
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 95.29 95.29 95.43 95.00 95.57 95.57 95.86 95.71 96.29 95.14 95.51 0.36
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 95.86 95.29 95.00 95.71 96.43 95.29 96.00 95.86 95.29 95.57 95.63 0.41
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 95.29 95.43 95.43 95.86 96.71 95.00 96.29 95.86 95.86 96.14 95.79 0.49
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 96.29 95.00 95.86 95.29 96.57 95.00 95.57 95.86 95.71 96.14 95.73 0.50
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 95.00 96.14 95.57 95.29 94.14 94.29 96.14 95.14 96.43 96.00 95.41 0.75
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.29 96.00 96.43 96.00 96.29 96.43 96.29 96.30 0.17
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.43 96.14 96.57 95.71 96.86 96.57 96.14 95.86 97.14 96.29 96.37 0.42
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 96.86 95.57 95.86 95.71 96.43 96.00 96.29 96.00 96.43 96.29 96.14 0.37
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 95.86 96.14 96.43 96.43 95.43 96.43 95.57 95.43 96.57 96.57 96.09 0.45
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.57 95.43 96.86 96.71 96.29 96.57 96.86 95.00 97.14 96.14 96.36 0.64
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 96.14 96.29 96.43 95.86 96.57 96.43 96.29 95.71 96.71 96.00 96.24 0.30
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 94.71 95.43 95.86 96.00 94.43 96.14 95.71 95.71 95.57 95.29 95.49 0.52
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 94.71 96.29 95.57 94.29 94.86 94.86 95.86 95.57 96.14 96.29 95.44 0.68
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 96.43 95.86 96.29 96.29 96.57 96.14 96.43 95.57 97.00 96.29 96.29 0.37
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 96.57 95.71 96.57 95.43 96.43 95.71 96.57 95.29 96.86 96.29 96.14 0.53
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 96.14 96.14 96.14 96.29 96.29 96.43 96.57 95.86 96.43 95.71 96.20 0.25
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 96.14 96.29 96.43 96.43 96.43 95.86 96.14 96.00 96.14 95.43 96.13 0.30
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 96.43 95.86 96.29 95.71 96.29 96.29 96.29 95.86 96.14 95.86 96.10 0.24
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 96.71 95.57 96.43 95.86 95.57 96.00 96.29 95.29 96.43 95.57 95.97 0.45
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 94.57 95.57 96.14 95.57 95.71 95.14 95.57 95.29 94.86 95.29 95.37 0.42
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 96.57 96.29 94.71 96.71 96.14 96.00 95.29 94.00 96.71 95.00 95.74 0.89
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std

gtts-witai

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.64 0.15
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.51 0.13
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 98.29 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.14 98.29 98.43 98.51 0.23
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.57 98.53 0.14
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.29 98.57 98.43 98.47 0.11
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.29 98.57 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.47 0.17
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 98.29 98.71 98.14 98.57 97.71 98.14 98.29 98.00 98.00 98.29 98.21 0.27
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 97.71 98.29 98.71 98.43 98.29 98.43 99.14 98.29 99.29 99.00 98.56 0.45
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.29 98.29 98.56 0.19
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.29 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.57 98.46 0.11
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.43 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.57 0.14
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 98.43 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.14 98.43 98.43 98.57 98.54 0.21
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.29 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.57 98.71 98.57 0.14
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.57 98.59 0.16
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.29 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.14 98.71 98.71 98.54 0.22
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 99.14 98.29 98.71 98.14 98.43 98.29 98.71 98.57 99.00 98.71 98.60 0.31
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 98.86 98.00 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.43 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.59 0.27
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.43 98.61 0.13
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.43 99.00 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.43 98.67 0.17
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.29 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.67 0.16
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.43 99.00 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.70 0.15
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.71 0.13
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.43 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.64 0.17
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 98.71 98.29 98.71 98.29 98.00 98.71 98.43 98.43 98.43 98.71 98.47 0.23
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 97.14 98.43 98.14 98.71 98.29 98.43 98.29 98.57 98.57 98.43 98.30 0.42
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.86 98.71 98.77 0.09
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 99.00 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.86 98.74 0.14
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 98.57 99.00 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.71 98.57 98.71 0.13
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 98.57 98.71 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.57 98.29 99.14 98.86 98.43 98.70 0.23
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 98.57 98.86 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.57 98.57 98.71 98.86 98.69 0.11
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 98.71 98.86 98.86 98.43 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.71 98.57 98.71 98.70 0.12
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 98.86 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.86 98.57 98.43 98.63 0.16
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 98.86 98.71 98.14 98.57 98.43 98.71 98.57 98.43 99.14 98.71 98.63 0.26
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std

macsay-google

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 91.57 92.43 91.57 92.29 92.71 91.86 91.57 92.29 92.14 92.57 92.10 0.41
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 92.14 92.29 91.57 93.00 92.57 92.57 92.43 92.29 91.57 92.29 92.27 0.42
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 92.71 91.29 91.29 92.14 92.00 92.00 92.00 91.43 92.43 91.57 91.89 0.46
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 92.00 92.29 92.71 91.71 92.00 91.57 91.86 91.29 92.14 91.71 91.93 0.38
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 91.43 91.86 92.43 91.71 91.86 92.29 91.71 91.43 92.14 91.71 91.86 0.32
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 91.71 92.00 92.57 91.86 92.00 91.71 92.43 90.71 92.14 92.43 91.96 0.50
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 92.29 93.71 92.14 91.57 91.14 92.71 92.57 91.57 91.00 92.57 92.13 0.78
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 93.00 91.71 93.43 93.14 91.00 90.71 92.00 91.57 91.57 91.29 91.94 0.89
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 91.00 91.86 91.57 91.71 91.29 91.71 92.29 91.71 91.86 92.43 91.74 0.40
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 91.00 92.29 92.00 90.86 90.71 92.14 91.57 92.14 92.00 92.14 91.69 0.57
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 91.29 92.43 92.43 91.14 90.86 91.14 91.00 91.57 91.57 91.29 91.47 0.52
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 90.86 92.00 91.43 91.86 92.71 91.00 91.29 90.86 92.29 91.29 91.56 0.60
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 91.43 92.71 92.00 90.86 92.29 91.86 91.00 91.14 92.14 91.14 91.66 0.60
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 91.14 92.14 90.29 90.86 91.71 91.43 91.14 90.86 92.29 91.00 91.29 0.59
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 91.14 92.00 90.71 90.86 91.86 91.86 91.00 91.71 92.29 91.14 91.46 0.52
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 90.86 92.57 91.57 91.00 91.57 91.14 92.14 92.00 92.14 91.86 91.69 0.53
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 91.57 91.00 91.57 91.57 90.43 92.29 91.43 91.43 92.14 92.14 91.56 0.53
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 92.86 92.29 92.86 93.14 92.57 91.57 92.71 92.00 92.71 93.14 92.59 0.48
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 92.14 91.71 92.00 93.57 92.86 92.29 92.29 91.86 92.86 93.29 92.49 0.59
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 92.57 91.86 90.86 91.71 93.00 92.71 92.86 93.00 91.86 92.14 92.26 0.66
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 92.43 91.86 91.43 92.29 91.86 93.43 92.86 91.71 92.57 91.86 92.23 0.58
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 92.57 91.71 91.86 91.57 91.86 92.14 91.71 91.86 92.29 92.29 91.99 0.30
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 92.43 90.86 91.57 92.43 92.14 92.71 92.43 91.29 92.14 92.57 92.06 0.58
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 92.71 92.57 92.29 92.29 92.57 92.43 91.86 92.43 93.29 92.57 92.50 0.35
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 92.00 92.00 92.14 92.86 91.57 92.14 92.43 92.71 90.14 92.57 92.06 0.73
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 92.86 91.57 92.57 91.57 92.57 92.43 92.29 91.57 91.57 92.43 92.14 0.49
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 92.71 92.00 92.71 93.00 92.29 91.86 92.43 91.86 92.00 92.14 92.30 0.38
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 91.57 92.43 92.86 92.43 92.00 91.86 91.71 91.14 92.14 91.00 91.91 0.55
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 91.43 92.14 91.29 91.00 92.86 92.00 90.86 92.57 92.43 91.43 91.80 0.66
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 92.00 92.57 91.43 90.00 90.71 92.00 91.57 91.14 93.14 91.14 91.57 0.86
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 92.43 92.57 91.14 91.71 91.00 92.14 91.29 92.71 92.29 91.71 91.90 0.59
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-Dropout0.1 92.43 92.14 91.43 91.71 92.14 92.29 91.57 91.86 92.00 91.14 91.87 0.39
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 92.29 92.29 91.57 92.14 91.86 91.71 91.71 92.14 90.86 91.29 91.79 0.44
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 92.86 93.43 91.57 92.86 91.57 92.57 92.14 91.43 92.00 92.14 92.26 0.63
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 91.29 91.43 90.43 92.71 91.00 91.43 91.86 93.86 92.29 92.14 91.84 0.92
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std

macsay-sphinx

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 90.29 90.00 90.00 89.14 90.00 89.86 88.43 91.00 90.29 89.57 89.86 0.66
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 89.43 89.00 89.43 90.29 89.14 90.00 89.57 90.57 89.57 91.00 89.80 0.61
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 89.00 87.71 87.57 89.29 88.00 87.71 88.14 89.29 88.57 88.43 88.37 0.62
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 88.00 88.71 88.71 87.29 88.14 87.57 88.86 87.71 88.57 88.00 88.16 0.51
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 88.14 87.86 89.14 87.00 88.00 88.14 89.29 89.00 88.29 87.14 88.20 0.74
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 87.57 88.29 89.57 89.43 86.86 87.86 88.86 88.71 87.43 89.14 88.37 0.87
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 89.86 90.57 90.29 90.29 90.29 87.71 89.86 90.43 89.86 88.14 89.73 0.94
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 88.86 88.86 88.57 89.14 88.86 86.86 87.71 88.43 88.14 89.86 88.53 0.78
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 88.14 89.71 88.43 88.14 87.86 88.29 87.71 89.14 88.57 89.43 88.54 0.64
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 87.71 88.57 89.29 88.57 87.00 87.71 88.14 89.29 88.00 89.71 88.40 0.81
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 85.00 85.71 85.14 88.43 87.00 86.86 87.14 86.29 86.86 86.57 86.50 0.97
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 86.14 87.29 85.86 87.43 86.86 87.00 86.86 85.43 86.57 87.57 86.70 0.67
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 86.14 86.00 86.71 86.57 86.71 86.71 87.57 86.14 85.29 87.14 86.50 0.61
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 86.71 86.71 86.57 87.57 87.71 87.57 87.00 87.14 87.29 85.29 86.96 0.67
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 86.00 86.86 86.14 86.86 86.86 87.14 87.43 87.00 86.57 85.71 86.66 0.52
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 89.71 90.00 88.29 89.43 90.14 89.43 89.57 88.43 90.00 89.43 89.44 0.60
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 88.29 88.29 86.29 88.86 89.86 88.14 89.29 89.00 88.14 88.43 88.46 0.90
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 90.00 89.71 91.29 89.43 90.57 90.86 88.86 88.57 90.29 90.57 90.01 0.83
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 89.14 89.14 89.00 89.57 90.43 89.71 90.43 88.71 89.86 89.57 89.56 0.55
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 90.14 90.86 90.57 89.14 89.29 90.57 89.43 89.00 90.43 90.00 89.94 0.64
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 88.71 88.57 88.86 88.71 89.71 90.14 90.29 89.00 88.86 89.86 89.27 0.62
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 89.86 89.43 90.57 90.57 88.86 89.57 89.71 89.14 89.29 89.43 89.64 0.54
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 89.00 89.43 88.71 89.14 89.14 89.29 90.29 89.29 89.14 89.43 89.29 0.39
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 89.29 89.29 89.00 89.43 89.29 89.14 88.71 89.14 89.29 89.57 89.21 0.22
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 90.57 90.29 89.86 89.57 90.43 89.29 89.14 90.57 89.29 88.29 89.73 0.71
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 89.57 89.00 91.00 90.29 89.57 89.00 88.57 90.57 91.00 90.29 89.89 0.82
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 89.00 89.00 89.00 89.43 88.00 88.00 88.29 89.00 89.00 88.71 88.74 0.46
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 90.14 89.00 89.29 90.00 89.00 88.86 89.57 88.71 88.29 88.29 89.11 0.61
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 88.71 88.57 90.00 89.00 89.29 89.00 88.14 89.00 88.57 87.86 88.81 0.57
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 87.86 88.57 89.71 87.71 89.00 88.57 89.43 89.29 89.43 89.14 88.87 0.64
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 89.14 88.57 88.57 88.57 88.71 88.29 89.14 88.43 89.14 88.71 88.73 0.30
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 87.57 88.14 89.14 88.29 88.71 88.14 89.29 88.00 90.29 88.71 88.63 0.75
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 87.57 88.86 88.71 88.71 89.14 89.14 89.00 88.43 89.71 88.71 88.80 0.53
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 88.71 91.14 87.57 88.71 89.29 91.00 89.14 88.57 89.57 89.43 89.31 1.03
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 90.43 87.14 89.00 90.43 88.86 90.14 91.43 90.29 89.86 87.86 89.54 1.25
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)

BERTwithProjection deleted by mistake - Re-running now (LDS3-GPU0)

Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
LDS1 NAS - BERT-bs32 90.57 92.00 91.29 92.43 91.14 92.14 90.57 92.14 92.14 91.86 91.63 0.65
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS1 - BERTwithAtt-bs32 91.43 92.29 91.43 91.71 91.71 90.71 92.43 91.29 90.57 92.86 91.64 0.69
LDS1 - BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 90.57 91.14 91.71 92.14 91.14 91.71 90.71 91.43 90.57 90.86 91.20 0.51
LDS1 - BERTwithProjection-bs32 90.14 92.14 91.86 91.29 92.14 92.29 91.00 91.14 91.43 90.57 91.40 0.68
LDS1 - BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 91.14 91.14 90.14 91.14 92.14 91.14 91.00 91.00 92.29 91.43 91.26 0.57
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs32 91.00 90.43 89.86 91.29 91.71 92.00 91.00 91.00 89.57 90.43 90.83 0.73
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 89.71 90.29 92.86 92.86 91.43 91.14 90.57 91.00 92.00 91.71 91.36 0.98
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 92.00 91.43 90.71 91.00 92.00 91.29 91.29 90.29 91.43 91.71 91.31 0.51
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 91.29 92.00 91.57 91.57 91.43 91.57 91.29 91.57 91.00 90.43 91.37 0.40
LOCAL - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32 92.14 91.29 91.14 91.86 91.14 93.14 90.86 91.43 91.43 91.71 91.61 0.62
LOCAL - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 91.14 92.57 93.57 91.57 90.86 92.00 90.86 90.43 91.00 90.57 91.46 0.94
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 91.43 91.57 90.71 91.71 91.14 90.86 91.57 90.86 90.71 91.14 91.17 0.36
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 91.43 91.86 91.86 91.43 92.71 91.14 90.86 91.00 91.57 91.14 91.50 0.52
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LOCAL - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32 92.29 91.57 90.43 91.86 91.71 91.43 91.71 90.86 92.00 91.14 91.50 0.53
LOCAL - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 92.00 90.29 90.57 90.71 91.29 90.71 90.86 92.14 90.86 90.57 91.00 0.59
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32 91.43 92.29 92.00 91.57 92.00 90.86 91.57 91.86 91.71 91.71 91.70 0.37
LDS1 - EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 90.71 91.86 91.43 91.71 91.00 90.86 92.14 90.57 90.86 90.86 91.20 0.52
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32 92.14 91.43 90.57 91.00 92.14 91.57 91.71 91.00 90.43 90.57 91.26 0.61
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 91.86 91.71 91.43 90.57 91.29 92.29 91.14 92.14 91.14 91.00 91.46 0.51
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32 92.00 91.71 90.57 92.00 91.43 92.00 91.29 92.00 92.00 91.57 91.66 0.44
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 91.71 92.14 90.86 90.86 91.57 91.00 90.71 91.57 91.43 91.71 91.36 0.45
  • Epoch 100 - BERT bs48
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
LDS3 - BERT-bs48 90.71 90.86 92.14 91.43 90.71 91.57 91.86 92.14 91.71 91.71 91.49 0.52
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS1 - BERTwithAtt-bs48 91.57 91.86 90.86 91.71 91.00 91.86 91.71 91.29 90.14 91.29 91.33 0.52
LDS1 - BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 91.00 90.43 91.00 91.71 91.43 91.43 91.57 91.71 89.86 90.57 91.07 0.59
LDS1 - BERTwithProjection-bs48 91.14 91.14 91.57 89.86 91.43 91.00 91.43 90.57 90.71 91.29 91.01 0.49
LDS1 - BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 91.29 90.43 89.43 91.71 91.00 90.14 90.86 90.71 91.00 91.14 90.77 0.61
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs48 92.57 91.86 90.71 90.43 90.14 90.43 90.71 91.86 91.14 91.29 91.11 0.74
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 90.43 91.43 90.86 91.43 91.00 90.43 90.14 92.29 89.57 90.43 90.80 0.73
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 91.71 90.86 92.00 89.71 90.71 91.86 91.71 90.71 92.00 92.00 91.33 0.74
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 91.57 91.00 90.86 90.86 90.00 91.43 91.14 91.00 91.14 91.00 91.00 0.40
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs48 90.57 91.00 92.14 91.29 90.57 92.14 90.86 89.86 91.29 91.71 91.14 0.69
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 91.14 91.71 91.57 91.29 91.86 91.29 91.86 91.71 90.29 91.57 91.43 0.45
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 91.14 91.57 91.43 91.14 91.86 93.00 90.71 91.43 91.71 91.43 91.54 0.57
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 92.29 91.00 92.14 91.14 91.00 92.00 90.29 90.29 91.57 90.57 91.23 0.71
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 91.71 90.71 89.57 91.86 92.29 90.71 91.43 91.14 91.14 89.00 90.96 0.96
LDS3 - EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 92.14 91.43 91.14 90.86 91.14 92.00 90.86 90.71 91.14 91.29 91.27 0.45
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 90.86 91.86 91.29 91.29 91.00 90.86 89.14 91.29 91.29 92.43 91.13 0.80
LDS3 - EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 92.00 92.14 91.14 90.00 91.43 91.43 91.14 91.14 91.57 91.43 91.34 0.55
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 91.43 91.71 91.86 92.00 91.43 90.71 90.71 92.00 92.14 91.14 91.51 0.50
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 91.00 90.14 91.43 91.71 91.43 89.71 90.86 91.71 91.29 90.29 90.96 0.66
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 90.86 91.29 91.71 91.00 90.29 91.29 90.71 90.57 91.00 90.57 90.93 0.40
LDS1 - EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 90.71 91.43 91.86 91.86 90.57 90.43 90.43 91.14 91.43 91.71 91.16 0.55

macsay-witai

  • Epoch 3
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs16 96.14 96.14 96.71 96.00 96.43 96.14 96.43 96.57 96.00 96.00 96.26 0.25
BERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.43 96.00 96.43 96.29 96.14 96.14 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.00 96.30 0.21
EmbraceBERT-bs16-WRONG 95.86 96.00 96.43 95.86 96.71 96.71 96.00 96.14 96.00 96.14 96.19 0.31
EmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16 96.14 96.14 96.00 95.86 96.14 96.43 95.86 96.14 96.29 96.57 96.16 0.22
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.14 95.86 95.86 96.43 96.57 96.43 95.86 96.00 96.00 96.14 96.13 0.25
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs16+Dropout0.3 95.86 96.00 96.14 96.57 96.29 96.43 96.29 95.86 96.00 96.29 96.17 0.23
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs16-ep100 96.00 96.71 96.29 95.86 95.71 95.86 96.29 95.43 95.43 96.43 96.00 0.40
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100-WRONG 95.57 95.43 95.71 96.43 96.00 96.43 95.86 96.29 96.14 95.71 95.96 0.34
FrozenEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERT-bs32 96.00 96.14 96.43 96.57 96.14 96.14 96.43 96.14 96.43 96.57 96.30 0.20
BERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 96.29 96.29 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.43 96.14 96.14 95.29 96.71 96.29 0.38
EmbraceBERT-bs32-WRONG 96.29 96.14 96.14 96.43 96.57 97.00 95.86 96.29 96.29 96.43 96.34 0.29
EmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 96.14 95.86 96.14 96.43 96.43 96.29 96.00 96.00 96.00 95.86 96.11 0.20
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32 96.71 95.86 96.14 96.43 96.57 97.14 96.00 96.00 96.14 97.00 96.40 0.42
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.1 95.71 96.00 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.14 95.71 95.57 96.57 96.00 96.13 0.37
CondensedEmbraceBERT-bs32+Dropout0.3 95.86 95.86 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.29 95.71 95.57 96.57 96.14 96.13 0.34
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenBERT-bs32-ep100 95.71 95.86 96.29 96.43 95.86 96.00 96.43 96.00 96.00 96.86 96.14 0.33
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100-WRONG 96.14 96.43 96.29 96.43 96.14 97.00 95.43 96.14 96.71 96.57 96.33 0.40
FrozenEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100
FrozenCEBERT-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs16 96.29 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.29 96.43 96.00 96.57 96.37 0.16
RoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.43 96.43 96.14 96.86 96.43 96.71 96.57 95.71 96.57 96.57 96.44 0.30
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16-WRONG 95.86 96.29 95.71 96.29 96.14 96.14 95.86 96.14 96.14 96.00 96.06 0.18
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1-WRONG 96.29 96.00 96.43 96.57 95.57 96.57 96.29 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.33 0.31
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16 96.00 96.43 96.00 96.29 96.29 96.43 96.14 96.14 96.57 96.00 96.23 0.19
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.1 96.71 96.43 96.43 95.86 96.43 96.43 96.00 96.14 96.86 96.43 96.37 0.29
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs16+Dropout0.3 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.00 96.14 95.71 96.14 96.57 96.14 96.29 96.23 0.24
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs16-ep100 96.57 96.00 96.57 96.29 95.57 95.14 96.00 95.71 95.71 95.29 95.89 0.47
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100-WRONG 96.14 95.43 96.00 96.00 95.86 96.29 95.43 95.86 96.43 95.71 95.91 0.31
FrozenERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs16-ep100+Dropout0.1
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
RoBERTa-bs32 96.43 96.29 95.86 96.43 96.29 96.43 96.00 96.43 96.00 96.57 96.27 0.23
RoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 95.71 96.29 96.71 96.43 96.29 95.86 96.00 96.86 96.43 96.57 96.31 0.35
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32-WRONG 96.14 95.86 96.43 96.57 96.57 96.29 95.71 96.43 96.86 95.86 96.27 0.35
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1-WRONG 95.57 96.71 96.29 95.86 96.00 95.86 96.14 96.29 96.43 96.57 96.17 0.34
EmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32 95.57 95.86 95.86 96.14 96.43 96.00 95.86 96.57 96.43 96.00 96.07 0.30
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.1 95.71 96.57 95.71 96.29 95.86 96.14 95.71 96.00 96.14 96.00 96.01 0.27
CondensedEmbraceRoBERTa-bs32+Dropout0.3 95.86 96.71 95.86 96.14 96.00 96.14 96.14 96.00 96.29 96.43 96.16 0.25
----------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
FrozenRoBERTa-bs32-ep100 96.71 96.43 96.00 96.57 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.14 96.00 95.71 96.29 0.30
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100-WRONG 96.43 96.00 96.14 95.29 95.57 96.29 95.43 96.71 96.71 96.43 96.10 0.49
FrozenERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100
FrozenCERoBERTa-bs32-ep100+Dropout0.1
  • Epoch 100 - bs32 (COLING paper)
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs32 96.71 96.57 96.14 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.71 96.86 96.43 96.43 96.54 0.20
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs32 96.14 96.00 96.14 96.29 97.00 96.29 96.71 96.29 96.71 96.57 96.41 0.30
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs32 96.14 96.71 96.71 96.00 96.57 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.43 96.71 96.49 0.23
BERTwithProjection-bs32 96.71 97.29 95.86 96.71 96.00 96.57 96.14 96.86 96.43 96.00 96.46 0.43
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs32 96.86 96.57 96.86 96.43 96.43 96.86 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.86 96.64 0.19
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs32 96.57 96.14 97.14 96.71 96.29 96.71 96.57 96.43 96.00 96.43 96.50 0.31
EmbraceBERT-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.14 96.43 96.14 97.00 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.71 96.71 96.57 96.53 0.26
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32 96.14 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.71 96.14 96.71 96.86 96.47 0.23
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.00 96.29 96.29 96.57 95.86 96.43 96.57 96.29 97.00 96.29 96.36 0.30
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32 96.43 96.29 95.86 96.71 96.57 96.29 96.57 96.29 96.57 96.29 96.39 0.23
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.43 96.00 97.14 96.71 95.86 96.14 96.57 96.43 96.29 96.43 96.40 0.35
EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32 96.43 96.71 96.29 96.71 96.43 96.43 96.29 96.71 96.57 96.29 96.49 0.17
EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.43 96.86 97.00 96.29 96.71 96.86 96.86 96.71 97.00 96.86 96.76 0.22
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32 96.00 96.43 96.86 96.71 95.86 96.43 96.14 96.71 96.29 96.43 96.39 0.31
EmbraceBERT-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.29 96.43 95.86 96.29 96.43 96.29 96.86 96.29 96.29 96.43 96.34 0.23
EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32 96.43 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.14 96.29 96.86 96.46 0.19
EmbraceBERT-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.57 96.86 96.00 97.00 96.71 96.86 96.43 96.71 96.57 96.57 96.63 0.26
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32 96.00 96.57 96.71 97.00 96.29 96.43 96.14 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.44 0.27
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.29 96.57 95.71 96.57 96.29 96.29 96.29 96.00 96.14 96.14 96.23 0.24
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32 96.14 96.43 96.86 97.00 96.14 97.00 96.71 96.29 96.43 96.86 96.59 0.32
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-KVQ-withProj-bs32-p_attclsqw 96.29 96.71 96.71 96.71 96.43 96.71 96.57 96.57 96.29 96.86 96.59 0.19
  • Epoch 100 - BERT bs48
Model Run1 Run2 Run3 Run4 Run5 Run6 Run7 Run8 Run9 Run10 Mean Std
BERT-bs48 96.29 96.43 96.57 96.86 96.29 96.86 96.29 96.57 95.86 96.57 96.46 0.28
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
BERTwithAtt-bs48 96.29 96.57 96.14 96.14 96.29 96.71 96.43 96.57 96.43 96.14 96.37 0.19
BERTwithAttClsProjection-bs48 95.86 96.71 96.86 96.29 96.00 96.86 96.43 96.43 96.71 96.71 96.49 0.33
BERTwithProjection-bs48 96.29 96.14 96.14 96.14 96.71 96.14 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.33 0.18
BERTwithProjectionAtt-bs48 96.57 95.71 96.14 95.86 96.86 96.71 96.86 96.29 96.57 96.71 96.43 0.39
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48 96.14 96.71 96.43 96.86 97.00 96.57 96.71 96.43 96.00 97.14 96.60 0.34
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_attclsqw 96.71 96.00 96.14 96.29 96.14 96.43 96.43 96.14 96.57 96.57 96.34 0.22
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48 96.00 96.29 95.71 96.71 96.43 96.57 96.29 96.57 96.00 96.86 96.34 0.34
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 96.71 96.57 96.29 96.14 96.86 97.00 96.57 96.57 96.71 96.43 96.59 0.24
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs48 96.29 96.29 96.14 96.43 96.00 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.57 96.14 96.34 0.19
EmbraceBERTconcatAtt-bs48-p_attclsqw 96.71 96.14 96.57 96.29 96.14 96.29 96.43 96.29 96.57 96.29 96.37 0.18
EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48 96.14 95.86 96.71 97.14 96.43 96.00 96.00 96.43 96.43 96.29 96.34 0.36
EmbraceBERTconcatAttwithProj-bs48-p_attclsqw 96.43 96.43 96.43 96.71 96.71 96.14 96.43 96.43 96.29 96.57 96.46 0.17
-------------------------------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 96.29 96.57 96.14 96.57 96.71 96.14 96.57 96.14 96.57 96.29 96.40 0.21
EmbraceBERT-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 96.14 96.57 96.14 96.29 96.86 96.29 96.57 96.43 96.14 96.86 96.43 0.26
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 97.14 96.14 96.57 96.00 96.29 96.43 97.14 96.14 96.00 96.57 96.44 0.40
EmbraceBERTwithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 96.57 96.29 96.71 96.43 96.29 96.29 96.00 96.43 96.71 96.71 96.44 0.23
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 96.29 96.14 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.29 96.71 97.00 96.57 96.29 96.49 0.25
EmbraceBERTconcatatt-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 96.29 96.57 96.29 96.29 97.00 96.14 96.71 96.71 96.71 96.71 96.54 0.26
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery 96.29 96.43 97.14 96.57 96.57 96.57 95.71 95.71 96.57 96.86 96.44 0.43
EmbraceBERTconcatattWithProj-bs48-p_multiheadatt_bertKeyValQuery_attclsqw 96.43 96.71 96.43 96.71 97.14 96.43 96.57 96.57 96.43 96.86 96.63 0.22